Why did the author write Dream of the Red Chamber as a tragedy?The reason why 'Dream of the Red Chamber' was written as a tragedy was because the author, Cao Xueqin, wanted to use the novel to show the complicated emotions and contradictions in life. In the novel, Cao Xueqin described the lives and emotions of the main characters such as Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu and Xue Baochai, but through their stories, Cao Xueqin revealed many defects and contradictions in human nature. These flaws and contradictions led to conflicts and misunderstandings between the characters, which eventually led to their tragic ending.
The emotional entanglement between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu in the novel was also one of the important reasons for the tragedy. They loved each other deeply, but due to various complicated factors, they could not be together in the end. In addition, the novel also depicted the fate of Xue Baochai and other characters, who faced similar difficulties as Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu.
"Dream of the Red Chamber" reflected the darkness and fragility of human nature by showing all kinds of complicated emotions and contradictions in life, so it was generally regarded as a great literary work.
Why was the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' a tragedy and not a comedy?The reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was a tragedy was because it depicted a complicated relationship between the characters and the social reality, but in the end, it did not achieve the perfect harmony shown in the comedy ending.
The tragedy of a novel usually means that the protagonist has experienced various setbacks and hardships but ultimately failed to achieve his or her desired goal. As the main character in the novel, Jia Baoyu experienced the decline of his family, the setback of love, the loss of friendship and other unfortunate events. Finally, he died in the deserted garden. Such an ending showed the impermanence and unpredictability of life, which made people feel deeply regretful and sad.
The tragedies in novels usually contained deep human thoughts and moral implications. Through the tragic love story between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu, Dream of the Red Chamber expressed the author's deep reflection on the complexity of human nature and social reality. For example, through the relationship between Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu, the novel explored the relationship between love and friendship, as well as the good and evil, vanity, greed and other aspects of human nature. This kind of ending not only made people feel emotional pain, but also made people think deeply about the nature of human nature and society.
To sum up, the reason why the ending of Dream of the Red Chamber was a tragedy was that it depicted a complicated relationship between the characters and social reality, but in the end, it did not achieve the perfect harmony shown in the comedy ending. At the same time, the tragedy of the novel also contains profound human thinking and moral meaning, which makes people feel emotional pain and make people think deeply about the nature of human nature and society.
Why would there be two completely different 'girls' in 'Dream of the Red Chamber'?Why would there be two completely different "girls" in "Dream of the Red Chamber"?
This question involved the names and titles of many characters in 'Dream of the Red Chamber'. In the novel, every character's name and address were unique and often related to their appearance, personality, status, and other factors.
In 'Dream of the Red Chamber', two completely different' girls 'appeared in the novel. These two "girls" were the Grandmother Jia's granddaughter, Lin Daiyu, and the Grandmother Jia's granddaughter, Xue Baochai. Although the two "girls" had the same name, they were addressed differently. Lin Daiyu was called "Daiyu" while Xue Baochai was called "Baochai".
The appearance of these two " girls " was necessary for the development of the novel's plot. Lin Daiyu was Grandmother Jia's granddaughter and had a deep relationship with Grandmother Jia. She was Grandmother Jia's darling. Xue Baochai was Grandmother Jia's granddaughter. Because her mother, Grandmother Jia, had received a favor from Aunt Xue, she had a higher status in Grandmother Jia's heart. Therefore, in the novel, Grandmother Jia's attitude and address towards Lin Daiyu and Xue Baochai were different, which reflected the difference in status and relationship between the characters.
Why would there be two completely different "girls" in "Dream of the Red Chamber"? The answer was to satisfy the development of the novel.
Why are the characters in the show different from the characters in the novel?The main difference between the characters in the TV series and the novel was that the purpose and audience of the TV series and the novel were different.
The main target audience of the TV series " Drawing Swords " was the audience in the mainland of China. In order to cater to the taste of this audience, the setting of the characters in the TV series would pay more attention to the performance of the battle and action scenes. At the same time, some political and historical elements would be added to make the story more complete and attractive. Therefore, the characters in the TV series might be more exaggerated and dramatic, with more emphasis on the intensity of the battle and the spirit of heroism.
The main target audience of the novel, Drawing Swords, was the readers in the mainland of China and overseas Chinese circles. They paid more attention to the character's personality, experience, and fate, as well as the restoration of historical background. Therefore, the image and personality of the characters in the novel may be more realistic and close to history, paying more attention to the inner contradictions and emotional processes of the characters.
The purpose and audience of TV series and novels were different, which led to the difference in character settings.
What was the ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber'? Why was it different from the one on television?The ending of 'Dream of the Red Chamber' varied according to the different versions and different adapted versions. Here are some possible endings:
1 Cao Xueqin's death: In some versions of the Dream of the Red Chamber, Cao Xueqin wrote the novel before his death but did not complete it. Later on, Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, and the others had a different ending.
2. Jia Baoyu Becomes a Monk: In other versions of Dream of the Red Chamber, Jia Baoyu eventually chose to become a monk.
3. Jia Baoyu's Death: In the original work of Dream of the Red Chamber, Jia Baoyu died of illness. However, in some adapted TV dramas or movies, Jia Baoyu was chosen to live and continue to be with Lin Daiyu and others.
The difference between the book and the television might be because the book was created by Cao Xueqin himself while the television was adapted by a screenwriter or director. Television might focus more on the plot and character development, while books focus more on the exploration of the novel's theme and structure. In addition, the audiences of television and books may also be different, so they may have different opinions on the ending of the novel.
Why was it said that Dream of the Red Chamber was the first tragedy novel in China? Were there no tragedy novels in China before that?Dream of the Red Chamber was hailed as a masterpiece in the history of Chinese novels, and also one of the tragic novels in the history of Chinese literature. The reason why it was said so was because it depicted the story of a complicated and huge family. In the end, this family encountered a disaster that triggered a series of tragic plots.
The tragic elements in Dream of the Red Chamber were not only reflected in the ups and downs of the family's fate, but also in the character's personality. Lin Daiyu was an important character in the novel. She was smart, sensitive and talented, but in the end, she could not escape the tragic fate because of her environment and personal encounters.
The tragic plots and characters in Dream of the Red Chamber not only reflected the traditional Chinese culture and values, but also demonstrated the author's outstanding literary talent and creative skills. Therefore, it was reasonable for Dream of the Red Chamber to be the first tragedy novel in China.
There were indeed many tragic novels in China, such as Water Margins and Journey to the West, but the tragic plots and characters presented in them were still different from those in Dream of the Red Chamber. The tragic plots and characters in Dream of the Red Chamber had distinctive characteristics, which was an important milestone in the history of Chinese literature.
Why did Cao Xueqin write a great work like 'Dream of the Red Chamber' into a tragedy?Cao Xueqin wrote the masterpiece 'Dream of the Red Chamber' into a tragedy because of his deep insight and thinking about human nature and social reality, as well as his deep understanding of his own era and society.
'Dream of the Red Chamber' depicted the rise and fall of a wealthy family, reflecting the corruption and isolation of feudal society. In this process, the negative emotions of human nature such as greed, selfishness, desire, and jealousy were fully displayed, and the relationship between people became indifferent, alienated, and hypocritical. These negative emotions and relationships lead to the decline of the family and the death of the characters, making the whole novel full of tragedy.
Cao Xueqin also showed the variety and complexity of human nature through the description of the fate and personality of different characters. He created many characters with distinct personalities, some of whom had very tragic fates, such as Lin Daiyu and Jia Baoyu. The interweaving of these characters 'fates and personalities made the novel more vivid and touching.
Cao Xueqin faced many difficulties and challenges when writing 'Dream of the Red Chamber', including economic, historical, cultural and other constraints. All these factors made the plot and the characters of the novel more complicated and profound, thus increasing the tragic nature of the novel.
In summary, Cao Xueqin wrote "Dream of the Red Chamber" as a tragedy because of his deep insight and thinking about human nature and social reality, as well as his deep understanding of his own era and society. At the same time, it was also because of his unique understanding and pursuit of art and literature.
Why is the plot of Fates 'novel different from the plot of anime?The main difference between Fate novels and anime was due to copyright and adaptation issues. The Fate series was originally written by the Japanese novelist Kiryu Nanko, who later adapted it into animation and manga. Fate/Stay Night and Fate/Zero were anime and novels produced by the company, Type-Moonoon. The storyline was adapted according to the wishes of the original author.
Due to copyright issues, different adapted versions might have different storylines and character settings. In addition, because the Fate series has many fans around the world, there may be differences in different adapted versions and translation. If you want to know more about the Fate series, I suggest you watch the original work or read the relevant materials.