In the novel Celestial Bane, Biyao did not revive in a specific chapter. Instead, she lived forever through a special setting. In the novel, Biyao once committed suicide because of a conflict with Xiao Ding. However, after Xiao Ding died, her soul did not leave this world. Instead, it was attracted by a mysterious force and was finally saved by Xiao Ding's disciple, Zhang Xiaofan, and kept in her body for a period of time. Since Bi Yao's soul had always existed in her body, she had not really been resurrected and had always maintained her original state. In the novel, this setting was called " the eternal survival of the soul ". It was a unique plot setting in Celestial Bane.