Humiliation.
The spell tower groaned. "What is the world coming to? Are we to fear a furry now? Simulation or not, I think this is disgraceful to us paragons."
The immortal power said in agitation, "We will fear whatever furry that can incapacitate a speedster in moments and still try to kill the other one. Now shut up if you don't have anything useful to say "
That outburst silenced any more voices of dissent. They all began to take the situation seriously. They started by sharing their opinion of the situation one after the other.
The speedster said, "I think that it might be a mistake to have them roaming around the plane. If they are capable of becoming what this furry is then they are a threat that must be eliminated. We should wipe them all out when we get home."