Malleus Maleficarum

Dutton Bedroom daytime, Sarah and Dean are questioning Paul about Janet and Sam is searching the bathroom for clues as to what happened and Paul says "She was so scared I couldn't help; I couldn't do anything to stop it and I've talked to the police, and I've talked to the medical examiner and no one can explain it."Dean says "Well, that's why they put the call in to us Mr. Dutton." Paul says "But the CDC, that's disease control, right? What do you think; it's some kind of virus?" In the bathroom Sam closes the door to the bathroom and looks more thoroughly through things and Sarah's vo says "We're not ruling out anything yet. Mr. Dutton did Janet have any enemies?" Paul vo says "I'm sorry?" Dean says "Anyone that might have a reason to hurt her?" Paul asks "Wait, what are you saying? That somebody poisoned her?" In the bathroom What?! No, no, there's just no one that could've—" Sam opens the bathroom door." Dean says "Mr. Dutton?" Paul says "Uh, everyone loved Janet." Sam nods at Dean and Sarah, so they know that Sam is done investigating and Dean says "Okay. Thank you very much; I think we've got everything we need, We'll get out of your way now."

Outside Dutton's house day, It's raining as Sarah, Sam and Dean walk out of the house toward the Impala and Dean says "That dude seem a little evasive to you?" Sam says "I don't know I was under a sink, pulling this out." Sam takes a hex bag out of his pocket and hands it to Dean and the three of them stop, as Dean takes the bag from Sam and opens it and Sam says "Hex bag." Dean says "Aww gross." Sam says "Yeah, there are bird bones, rabbit's teeth. This cloth is probably cut from something Janet Dutton owned." Dean looks back at the house for a second and turns back handing the bag to Sam and walking towards the Impala again and Sarah asks "So we're thinking witch?" Sam says "Uh, yeah, and not some new age wicked water douser either and this is Old World black magic Sarah, I mean, warts and all."

The three of them get into the impala Dean turns to Sam and Sarah and says "I hate witches." Sam and Sarah both chuckles, "They're always spewing their bodily fluids everywhere." Sam says "Pretty much." Dean says "It's creepy, you know, it's down right unsanitary." Sarah says "Yeah, well someone definitely had it out for Janet Dutton." Dean says "Yeah, someone who snuck into that house and planted the bag. So what are we thinking, we're uh, looking for some old craggy Blair bitch in the woods." Sam says "No it could be anyone. Neighbor, coworker, man, woman—that's the problem, Dean, they're human, they're like everyone else." Dean says "Great. How do we find 'em?" Sam says "This wasn't random; someone in Janet Dutton's life had an ugly axe to grind. We find the motive—" Sarah says "We find the murderer." Sam says "Yeah." Dean starts the Impala and pulls away from the curb, driving off in the rain.

Elizabeth is tending to her garden as Amanda pulls into her driveway and gets out of the car, Elizabeth looks up and tries to get Amanda's attention and she says "Amanda." Amanda is distracted and grabs a grocery bag out of the back seat of her car and starts to walk to her door and Elizabeth says "Hey Amanda!" Amanda says "Oh, Elizabeth hi. Sorry, I've got like a thousand things on my mind." She keeps walking toward the door to her house and Elizabeth asks "Are you okay sweetie? You didn't come to book club last night." Amanda says "Yeah, sorry I was gonna call, I just—I got busy, you know? But I'm fine, really, I am." Amanda hurries into her house, waving her hand behind her at Elizabeth. Amanda walks into the kitchen and sets down the grocery bag on the counter and goes to the oven, opening the door and reaches in to take out a platter with food on it and the food is rotten. Outside in the street Paul is sitting in his car pulled over on the side of the street and reaches over and turns on the radio, Every Rose Has its Thorn by Poison starts to play on the radio as he begins to eat a burger.

In Amanda's house in her living room showing various occult objects, including a candle, bones and symbols drawn on wood, the same as before. Now she places the platter of rotten food where Janet's toothbrush was and lifts the same dagger she sliced her hand with previously and looks at it and in his car, he's chewing the food he has eaten as the song continues. He puts down the burger and goes to check his watch, but his wrist is bare and he looks confused and Amanda begins the incantation Voiceover says "Echranmuk madan fiéré marc oh don" Amanda places a watch on the platter with the rotten food and continues her incantation "Duer kianave kihér tolic einder bolic marc oh don duer kianave. This dinner was cooked for you Paul Arthur Dutton." Amanda stabs the dinner with the dagger and says "Now you're going to eat it." Paul puts down the burger as I Put a Spell on You comes back on the radio and he leans forward starting to choke and he opens the door of his car, falling out onto the pavement hunched over as Sarah, Sam and Dean arrive in the Impala. Dean and Sarah runs over to Paul and yells at Sam "Check the car!" Sam searches under the dashboard and steering column as Dean and Sarah tries to help Paul and Sarah says "Sam!" Sam gets up removing the hex bag he found as Dean and Sarah pulls Paul up from the pavement.

Dean says "Come on." Sam lights the hex bag on fire and drops it to the ground as it glows with blue and green flames, Inside Amanda's house she begins to cut her hand with the dagger and continue the ritual, the platter of rotting food bursts into flames. Paul recovers from choking and leans back against his car and Sarah asks "You okay?" Paul asks "What the hell is happening to me?!" Dean says "Someone murdered your wife and now they're trying to kill you, that's what's happening to you." Paul says "That's impossible! There's no way—" Sarah says "If we hadn't have been following you, you'd be a doornail right now. Now who wants you dead?" Paul says "I-uh..." Dean asks "Come on think." Paul says "There's a woman—uh—" Sarah says "A woman, okay?" Paul says "An affair—a mistake, she was un-balanced, she was blackmailing me and I put an end to it a week ago." Sam asks "What's her name?" Paul says "Wha–What could she have to do with—?" Dean asks "Paul! What is her name?" Inside Amanda's house, Amanda is frantically flipping through the pages of a book with occult symbols on it and foreign language written around the symbols. A wind blows through her house blowing out the candles on her altar. Amanda stares at them warily, then suddenly screams and holds out her left arm where one cut has already been sliced in her wrist vertically. Two more slice down next to that cut with no visible assailant and blood begins to pour out of the wounds and she says "No! No...aah no!" Three cuts slice into her right wrist vertically, matching those on her left wrist and blood pours out of them despite Amanda's screams in protest. She falls forward, pushing the altar off the table and lands face down on her glass coffee table, blood from her cut wrists pooling around her arms her eyes shut.

Dean picks the lock and enters Amanda's house , followed closely by Sarah and Sam , with their guns drawn. They enter the room and find Amanda lifeless on the table covered in blood and switch on the light and the flames are still burning, so this is very shortly after she died, Dean staring at the body "That's a curveball." Sam says "Yeah." They approach Amanda's body and Dean lifts her right arm with the barrel of his gun then looks at the other as well and Sarah says "Three per wrist, vertical. She wasn't foolin' around." Sam puts his gun in the back of his jeans and bends down to look at the scattered remnant of the altar holding his nose to the smell of the burnt rotten food and says "Yeah, looks like she was working some heavyweight evil here." Dean says "Yep."Dean turns around, then jumps back, startled – he nearly walked into a rabbit, hanging from the ceiling, dead and says "Oh god! Freakin' witches! Seriously man, come on!" Sam says "Guess we know where she got the rabbit's teeth from." Sarah says "Well, Paul sure knows how to pick 'em huh? It's like Fatal Attraction all over again." Sam says "Yeah." Dean asks "And why does the rabbit always get screwed in the deal?! The poor little guy." Sam says "You know what I don't get, Dean Sarah? If she was so bent on revenge, why do this?" Sarah says "Well, she got Janet Dutton, thought she finished off Paul, decided to cap herself and make it a spurned lover's hat-trick."

Sam says "Maybe." Sam starts to look under the glass table that Amanda on, Dean says "I mean, this doesn't exactly look like the TV room of a bright and stable person, you know?" Sam says "No, but then..." Sam reaches around and pulls out another hex bag that is tucked under the table and stands up tossing it to Dean and says "There's this." Sarah says "Another hex bag? Come on!" Dean opens the bag to find similar contents of the bag they found in Janet's bathroom and he tosses it on the table reaching for his phone and Dean says "Looks like we got a hit, huh? A little witch-on-witch violence?" Sam says "I guess." Sarah dials the phone and hold it up to his ear and says "I'd like to report a dead body, 309 Mayfair Circle. My name? Yeah, sure my name is—" Sarah clicks the phone shut, cutting herself off, Sarah asks "Why are witches ganking each other?" Sam says "I don't know, but I think maybe we got a coven on our hands."

Inside Van Allen's house nighttime, Ron is standing in the doorway to the room that the women are in and Ron says "All right, all right. I'm going. I'm not fooled by your little book club by the way, I know what you ladies get up to when I'm gone. It's all dish and gossip." The women laugh as Elizabeth walks in and joins Ron in the doorway and says "Hi Ron." Ron says "Oh, hello Elizabeth. I mean, when's the last time anyone actually brought a book?" Tammi and Renee in unison says "Goodnight Ron." Ron says "All right." Ron leaves and as soon as the door closes behind him Elizabeth goes into the room seemingly upset and asks "He doesn't know? You didn't tell him?" Renee says "About Amanda? Oh, I think that's book club business, don't you?" Tammi gets a candle holder with three tapers in it and sets it on the coffee table in front of the sofa and Renee says "Thank you Tammi." Elizabeth says "The police just took away her body, and what? We're just gonna pretend it didn't happen?" Renee says "We loved Amanda." Tammi says "It's true." Renee then says "We know that she was a little... unstable." Tammi says "Also true." Renee says "And we have to face it, she probably killed Janet Dutton." Tammi says "People just don't spit out their teeth all of a sudden." Renee shakes her head in agreement with Tammi and Elizabeth says "We have to stop. We have to stop Book Club. This has all gone too far." Renee gets up from the sofa and says "Elizabeth, just take a deep breath. Calm down." Tammi says "We can't... stop." Elizabeth says "But people are dying!" Renee scoffs "Amanda killed herself yes, and yes she killed Janet Awful, awful business of course, but that's all over now and think about what Book Club has gotten us hmm? Your husband's promotion, that little trip to Hawaii that you won and what about me? My home pottery business is finally taking off and you wanna just stop? Do you wanna stop?" Elizabeth shakes her head 'no' and Renee claps her hands together and says "'kay, now come on, we don't have much time, Ron gets back from his Fantasy Football in an hour." The three of them start getting ready for 'Book Club' which is their witches coven meeting by putting a cloth with a demonic symbol on it down on the table, putting the 'Book of Shadows' in the middle of it, and lighting the candles in the candle holder, the three of them says "Book of Shadows we kneel before you, let us serve your master as you serve us. Book of Shadows we kneel before you, let us serve your master—"

Elizabeth's garden daytime, Elizabeth is turning the soil of her garden with a small trowel when Sarah, Dean and Sam walk up her driveway to question her and Sam says "You must have a green thumb." Elizabeth says "Excuse me?" Sam says "Getting these herbs to grow out of season like this, quite impressive. I'm sorry; I should have introduced myself first." Sam reaches on the pocket of his suit jacket and takes out a badge and says "I'm uh, Detective Bachman, this is Detective Turner and this is Detective Lund." Dean and Sarah take out their badges and flashes them to Elizabeth and says "Hi-ya." Sarah says "We're following up on Amanda Burns' death, going around the neighborhood and talking to neighbors and stuff like that." Elizabeth says "But didn't she— I mean she killed herself right?" Sam says "Maybe, maybe." Dean asks "We heard you were friends with the deceased right?" Elizabeth says "Yeah, I guess so." Dean asks "Did you have any idea about her practices?" Elizabeth says "I'm sorry, what kind of practices?" Sam says "Well see, her house was littered with Satanic paraphernalia." Dean says "A regular Black Sabbath." Elizabeth says "No, the— but she was an Episcopalian." Dean says "Well, then we're pretty sure she was using the wrong Bible." chuckles, Renee and Tammi walk up unseen, and Renee speaks causing the brothers and Sarah to turn and take notice of their arrival. Renee asks "Elizabeth, you all right?" Elizabeth says "I'm fine uh Renee, these are detectives and They say Amanda was— she was practicing—" Renee says "I'm sorry detectives; you can tell that Elizabeth is a little bit upset." Dean asks "Of course, Miss ... ?" Renee says "Missus. Renee. Van Allen." She says it slowly and emphatically, like it's significant and she's important "Would you like me to spell it for you?" Dean says "I'll get by, thanks." Renee says "This Amanda business has been hard for Liz. For all of us." Tammi says "Yeah. I mean, you think you know a person." Dean says "Well, I guess we all have secrets don't we?" Sam says "Well, thanks, um, we'll be in touch." Sarah says "Have a nice day." Tammi says "Bye."

The Impala is driving down a country road through fog, Dean is driving, Sam is in the passenger's seat and Sarah is in the backseat and Dean says "Well, I'm already sold on that Elizabeth chick. Did you see that victory garden of hers? Belladonna, wolfsbane, mandrake, not to mention that little flinch she threw when we mentioned the occult." Sam says "Well, she's definitely had a good run lately, gone up a few tax brackets; won almost too many raffles. Kinda thing a little black magic always helps with." Dean says "Yeah." Sarah says "I don't think she's alone either. Looks like 'MRS. Renee Van Allen' has won almost every craft contest she has entered in the past three months." Dean says "Yeah, a regular Martha Stewart, huh? Except for the devil worship, I'm thinking that was the coven we met back there, minus one member." Sam says "Amanda was clearly going off the reservation. What do you think, they killed her to keep up appearances?" Dean says "Seems like an appearance kind of crowd, don't you think?" Sarah says "Yeah." Dean says "If they killed the nut-job, should we uh, thank them or what?" Sam says "They're working black magic too, Dean. They need to be stopped." Dean says "'Stopped' like stopped?" Sam and Sarah gives him a look that says 'of course'. Dean says "They're human, Sam and Sarah." Sarah says "They're murderers." Dean looks at Sam and Sarah for a second with surprise and then shrugs in agreement and says "Burn witch, burn." Dean continues to drive when the Impala stutters and starts to choke up and he says "What the hell?"

The head lights of the Impala on and then back on again as it slowly comes to a stop in front of a figure sanding in the middle of the road. The view from the inside of the Impala shows that it is Ruby, Sam gets out of the car, Sarah and Dean follows and Sam says "Ruby." Ruby says "Sam, listen to me, there's no time." Sam asks "For what? What are you talking about?" Ruby says "You have to get out of town." Dean says "So this is Ruby, huh?" Dean raises the colt and aims it at her, cocking it he says "Never had the pleasure." Sam says "Dean!" Dean ignores Sam and says "I was hoping you'd show up again." Ruby says Point that thing somewhere else." Dean says "Hahahaha! Right." Ruby says "Sam, please. Go. Get in the car and don't look back." Sam asks "Why? I don't understand." Dean says "Hey, hot stuff, we can take care of a few kitchen witches, thanks." Ruby says "I'm not talking about witches, you jackass. Witches are whores. I'm talking about who they serve." Dean, Sarah and Sam both look confused for a second, but then it dawns on Sam and Sam says "Demons. They get their power from demons." Ruby says "Yeah. And there's one here, now." Sarah says "Oh, what, you mean besides you?" Ruby says "Sam, it knows you're in town and it's gonna come after you and its way more than you can handle." Dean says "Oh come on, what is this, huh? Please tell me you're not listening to this crap!" Ruby says "Put a leash on your brother, Sam, if you wanna keep him."

Sam says "Dean, look, just chill out." Dean says "No! No! She's messing with your head, God knows why, that's who they are!" Ruby says "I'm telling you the truth." Dean says "And I'm telling you to shut up, bitch." Ruby asks "I'm sorry, why are you even a part of this conversation?!" Dean says "Oh, I don't know maybe because he's my brother, you black-eyed skank!" Ruby says "Oh, right, right. You care about your brother so much and That's why you're checking out in a few months, leaving him all alone with Sarah?" Dean says "Shut up." Ruby says "At least let me try and save them, since you won't be here to do it any more." Dean says "I said shut up!" Dean moves to fire the Colt at Ruby and Sam says "Dean no!" Sam pushes Dean's arm away from Ruby as he fires the Colt, and Dean tries to fight against Sam's hold and they lock arms and both look to where Ruby was standing to see that she has vanished. Sarah was shocked by what Sam did, Dean and Sarah gives Sam a look of disappointment and goes back to get in the Impala, as Sam looks around in vain for Ruby.

At the hotel room nighttime, Dean walks in first and switches on the light Sarah and Sam follows right behind him and Dean asks Sam "What the hell were you thinking?" Sam says "What?! What the hell was I thinking?" Dean says "She's a demon, Sam. Period. All right? They want us dead, we want them dead." Sam says "Oh, that's funny; I remember that demon chick in Ohio, Casey? You didn't want her dead." Dean says "Yeah, well she wasn't stringing me along like a fish on a hook." Sam says "No one's stringing me along! Look, I know it's dangerous, that she is dangerous, but like it or not, she's useful." Dean says "No! We kill her before she kills us." Sam asks "Kill her with what? The gun she fixed for us?" Dean says "Whatever works." Sarah lays on the bed leaning against the bed sitting quietly unsure of what to say, Sam says "Dean, if she wants us dead, all she has to do is stop saving our lives." Dean turns away from Sam and goes to the sink turning on the water.

Sam says "Look, we have to start looking at the big picture Dean, start thinking in strategies and – and moves ahead." Dean splashes water on his face. "It's not so simple, we're not – we're not just hunting anymore. We're at war." Dean turns off the water and looks at Sam in the mirror above the sink, grabs a towel to dry off his face and turns back around to Sam and asks "Are you feeling okay?" Sam sighs "Why are you always asking me that?" Sam sits on the foot of one of the beds in the room, and Dean moves back toward Sam and Sarah "Because you're taking advice from a demon, for starters. And by the way, you seem less and less worried about offing people. You know, it used to eat you up inside." Sam asks "Yeah, and what has that gotten me?" Dean says "Nothing, but it's just what you're supposed to do, okay? We're supposed to drive in the freakin' car and freakin' argue about this stuff. You know, you go on about the sanctity of life and all that crap." Dean rubs his stomach uncomfortably Sam says "Wait, so �� so you're mad because I'm starting to agree with you?" Dean looks at Sam and exhales, he says "No, I'm not mad, I'm— I'm— I'm worried, Sam—" Dean moves and sits down on the foot of the other bed in the room "I'm worried because you're not acting like yourself." Sam says "Yeah, you're right, I'm not. I don't have a choice." Dean asks "What is that supposed to mean?" Sam says "Look, Dean, you're leaving – right? And me and Sarah So the way I see it, if we're gonna make it, if we're gonna fight this war after you're gone, then me and Sarah gotta change." Dean has been looking increasingly uncomfortable during Sam's last speech, and is now clutching his stomach in discomfort and leaning forward slightly and asks "Change into what?"

Sam says "Into you, we gotta be more like you." Dean shakes his head, then tightens his face in pain, and leans further over, still clutching his stomach and side with his left hand and says "Ah." Sarah asks "What's going on with you?" Dean moves around in pain, still clutching his stomach, and he can barely force words out and says "I don't know. bends, gasps "Oh----Sarah, Sam something's wrong— bunch of knives inside of me—" Sam says "Dean?" Sarah and Sam Moves off the bed and kneels in front of Dean who is now leaning all the way forward with his head almost between his legs and Dean says "Son of a bitch—" Sam says "Dean, hey." Dean says "The coven man, it's gotta be the coven." Sarah says "Don't worry." Sam and Sarah gets up and rushes into the bathroom opening the cupboards below the sink looking for the hex bag as Dean yells in pain and lies back on the bed, his face still twisted in pain. Sarah pulls things out of the cupboard throwing them aside, Dean leans forward again falling to his knees in front of the foot of the bed, spitting out blood, choking and sputtering Sam and Sarah pulls off the covers to the bed tearing back the sheets and slices the mattress open with his knife and still cannot find the hex bag and Sam says "Dean, I can't find it." Dean falls over sideways and looks weak and hurt and still in pain and Sarah says "No." As Dean continues to cough blood more weakly now, Sam rummages through his bag and pulls out the Colt and opens it to make sure there are bullets in it Sarah asks "Sam, what are you doing?" Sam gets up and moves toward the door, Dean says "Sam!" Sam leaves closing the door behind him and again he says "Sam!" Sarah stays by his side, Dean groans in pain.

Inside Van Allen house nighttime, Elizabeth, Renee and Tammi are around the coffee table again with the altar set up, chanting and the three woman says "Kihér tolic echranmuk, madan fiéré, marc oh don duer kianave-" Sam kicks in the door and the women scream out of fear getting up from the altar raising their hands in surrender, Sam enters the room with the Colt drawn and says "Let him go." Renee asks "Let who go? What are you doing? You're insane, get out!" Sam says "Look, if you know about me, then you know about this gun. You're killing my brother now let him go and get away from the altar." Renee says "What?" Sam says "Now!" They all move away from the altar with their hands still up as Sam keeps the Colt trained on them.

Dean is leaning over a pool of blood he has spit out gasping and coughing blood still. There are quick footsteps outside and the door is kicked open and Ruby steps in and finds Dean and Sarah who looks up and sees her and Sarah moves out of the way, Dean says "You wanna kill me? Get in line bitch." Ruby goes over to Dean and pulls him up by the collar tossing him on the bed, leans over him and forces his mouth open with her left hand as Dean tries to push her away, Ruby sprays a dark brown liquid into his mouth from a bag at her side with her right hand while Dean still struggles under her hold. Ruby stands up as Dean chokes on the liquid and spits some back out, Ruby panting says "Stop ... calling me bitch."

Sam is still aiming the gun at Elizabeth, Renee and Tammi and Sam says "Go!" The three woman move over in front of the fireplace with their hands still up in the air and Elizabeth asks "What— we— we weren't hurting anyone." Renee says "Please, we don't even know your brother." Sam says "Stop the spell, or die. Five seconds." Renee says "What?" Sam cocks the gun and points it back at them and says "Four." Renee says "No, please, please don't kill us." Elizabeth says "We were just getting Renee a lower mortgage rate!" Sam looks confused but still holds the gun ready, Back in the Hotel nighttime, Ruby says "Next time you point that gun at me, I'm not gonna just disappear, understand?" Ruby tosses a sawed-off shotgun over to Dean who is back to sitting on the foot of the bed and Sarah standing beside him, His face is somewhat cleaned off from the blood and liquid 'cure' that Ruby gave him and he says "You ... saved my life." Ruby says "Don't mention it." Dean asks "What was that stuff? God, it was ass. It tasted like ass." Ruby says "It's called witchcraft, short bus." Ruby turns and walks out of the room, closing the door behind her and leaving Dean on the bed and Sarah beside him, Dean slightly offended.

Inside the house nighttime, Sam says "Okay, maybe it's not you—" Sam points the gun at Elizabeth, "Or you." He points the gun at Renee this time, "Maybe it's you." Sam points the gun at Tammi who sobs, upset and scared says "I don't even know what he's talking about. What a–re you even talking about?" Sam says "I mean, all of you, everyone in your little coven, you've all had runs of good fortune and newsworthy good fortune. Except for you, Tammi. Now tell me, why is that? You didn't want anything for yourself? Or is it because you're already getting what you wanted – like these women's souls." Tammi says "I can't- I-I'm not- I-I-I don't..." She sighs and puts her hands down, going from looking frightened to calm and her eyes change to black revealing that she is the demon Ruby warned them about, The other women gasp, looking shocked. Tammi says "Nice dick work, Magnum." Sam says "Let My Brother Go." Tammi asks "What's wrong? Couldn't find my hex bag? Sorry, sweetheart, but your brother's lungs should be on the floor by now." Sam shots the colt The bullet slows as tammi lifts up her hand, The bullet loses momentum, slows, stops, and falls to the floor. Elizabeth gasps and Tammi says "You're in a lot of trouble, Sam."

Tammi motions her arm at Sam and Sam is thrown against the wall behind him, and pinned there and Elizabeth asks "Tammi, what's wrong with your eyes?" Tammi turns her head and attention on the other two women, making her eyes look human again sam is still pinned helplessly to the wall and Renee asks "Tammi, what are you doing?" Tammi says "Renee, shut your painted hole." Renee says "What? I-I will— You can't— Not in my house, Tammi Fenton." Tammi, annoyed, waves her right hand at Renee and Renee's head snaps to the right so far it almost turns completely backwards, killing her instantly. Her body falls to the floor as Elizabeth shrieks in terror, covering her mouth and Sam says "Look. You got me – let the girl go." Tammi says "Wait your turn, young man." Elizabeth makes another scared noise, bringing Tammi's attention back to her, "Shhh, Lizzie, it's okay." Elizabeth says "You're not Tammi." Tammi says "No, but I'm wearing her meat and I had to break the ice with you girls somehow." Elizabeth says "You killed Renee." Tammi says "Renee, Amanda ... That's what happens to witches who get voted off the island." Elizabeth asks "Who are you?" Tammi says "Funny story, actually you remember all those dark demonic forces you prayed to, when you swore your servitude? Just who did you think you were praying to?" Elizabeth says "No, no, we didn't know—" Tammi says "Oh, yes you did and you knew every step of the way, and now your ever livin' souls are mine."

Tammi turns back to Sam who is still pinned to the wall and she asks "Comments? Questions? Hmm, Sammy Winchester, wow! Right here in our little town. You know, my friends and I, we've been looking for you." Sam says "Why? Oh, right, 'cause I'm supposed to lead some piss poor demon army." Tammi says "No, not at all. You're not our Messiah. We don't believe in you. But, there's a new leader rising in the West – a real leader. That's the horse to bet on, Sam, the one who's gonna tear this world apart. Thing is, this demon? It doesn't like you very much. It doesn't want the competition." Tammi raises her hand and Sam slides up the wall, groaning, and is suspended against it "Nothing personal, it's a P.R. thing, so, buh-bye." Tammi keeps her hand raised, and Sam begins to be crushed into the wall, paint and plaster cracking as he is pushed harder into the solid wall, Elizabeth stands there watching, frozen in fear and the front door to the house slams open Dean and Sarah runs in with their shotguns drawn and Tammi turns around, easily throwing them over the sofa, and when he gets up, she pins him to the wall behind him and says "Three for one, lovely." Unfortunately Sarah's head had hit the wall pretty hard and knocked her unconscious, Ruby's voice cuts in before Tammi can finish what she started and she says "Wait." She walks in with her hands raised in surrender, "Please. I just ... came to talk." Ruby puts her hands down, Tammi says "You made it out of the gate. Impressive. That was a bitch of a fight, wasn't it?" Ruby says "Doors out of Hell only open for so long."

Tammi asks "What do you want, Ruby?" Ruby says "I've been lost without you, Take me back. That's why I led the Winchesters and a little bonus." Dean looks over at Sam and mouths ""I told you so" Ruby says "They're for you ... as a gift." Tammi says "Really?" Ruby asks "Let me serve you again. I've wanted it – I've wanted you – for so long." Tammi says "You were one of my best." Ruby and Tammi look at each other, and Ruby pulls her knife out and tries to stab Tammi but Tammi catches it in mid-air and says "But then again, you always were a lying whore." he knife is thrown sideways out of their hands across the wood floor, Tammi and Ruby fight, and Tammi throws Ruby into the TV, but she gets up and kicks Tammi and goes to run past her, and Tammi clotheslines Ruby causing her to fall flat on her back. Tammi pulls Ruby up and throws her into a bookcase and gets a fireplace poker from the stand on the hearth, looking at Elizabeth who is still cowering from Tammi, before she walks back to Ruby poker in hand and she says "You're really telling me you threw in your chips with Abbott and Costello here?" Ruby , panting, tries to get up, and Tammi hits her across the face with the fireplace poker. Elizabeth runs to the altar and dumps a bunch of pins out of a bow onto the cloth with the demonic symbol on it and she's unseen by Tammi, who is still paying attention to Ruby.

Tammi says "Come on. Get up." Ruby is panting and not moving, with blood coming out of her nose "I said, get up!" Tammi tosses the poker aside and crouches over Ruby , grabbing her by the jacket and pulling her up "We've been here before, haven't we?" Tammi chuckles to herself and looks over at Sam and says "She didn't tell you?" She turns back to Ruby and says "Pretty mortifying, I guess she was one of mine and I turned her out a long, long time ago. Ruby here was a witch of course, that was when you were human." Dean and Sam both look surprised even though they are still both pinned to their respective walls, Tammi throws Ruby back down onto the debris of the bookcase she crashed through and stands up "Didn't want your friends to know that all those centuries back, you sold yourself to me? Embarrassing, I guess. But don't worry love, no secrets where you're heading remember?" Tammi begins to chant and black smoke rises out of Ruby's mouth curling and hovering inches above her mouth. "Monyé valack forsa, ulu iri regatt ruac, fieesh nieesh forthsa lé inmist infirum forthsa por un betest a té un fornalles ecclaisee –" Tammi begins to cough and Elizabeth is chanting under her breath at the altar. As Tammi coughs harder, Dean is dropped from the wall and he falls forward he checks on Sarah who slowly regains conscious and then Sam lso falls from the wall and drops to the floor as Tammi brings her hand up to her mouth. Tammi coughs up a handful of long pins into her hand, her mouth bleeding in the process, he looks at the pins and raises her right hand and clenches it into a fist and Elizabeth's breath catches and her eyes go wide as her heart stops and she falls onto the altar, dead.

Dean comes up behind Tammi and stabs her in the back repeatedly with Ruby's discarded knife, Tammi dies as well as the demon that was inside of her and she falls to the floor. Dean looks at Ruby and goes to help Sam and Sarah up and they move toward the door and stop to look at Ruby and she says "Go." Ruby looks at them, slightly embarrassed, and wipes the blood away from her mouth and says "I'll clean up this mess." Dean and Sarah starts to walk toward the door, helping Sam on their way and says "Come on." Sarah, Dean and Sam stop and look back at Ruby one more time she turns her eyes black and glares at them and says "Go." The three of them walk out the door, Ruby leans over Tammi's body, takes her knife out of Tammi's back and holds it up, The knife is covered in blood, and is smoking.

Inside the motel nighttime, Sarah is sorting out her forehead which is bleeding a little and Sam is splashing his face with water and looks in the mirror above the sink with a worried expression etched in his face, outside of the motel Dean is walking outside of the motel, As the lights flicker, he looks around, and then around again to see Ruby standing there in the shadows of the hotel parking lot and Dean says "So the devil may care after all, is that what I'm supposed to believe?" Ruby says "I don't believe in the devil." Dean walks towards her and says "Wacky night. So let me get this straight, you were human once, you died, you went to hell, you became a..." Ruby says "Yeah." Ruby turns to leave and Dean asks "How long ago?" Ruby says "Back when the plague was big." Dean says "So all of 'em – every damn demon – they were all human once?" Ruby says "Every one I've ever met." Dean says "Well, they sure don't act like it." Ruby says "Most of them have forgotten what it means, or even that they were. That's what happens when you go to Hell, Dean. That's what Hell is – forgetting what you are." Dean says "Philosophy lesson from a demon. I'll pass, thanks." Ruby says "It's not philosophy. It's not a metaphor. There's a real fire in the pit. Agonies you can't even imagine." Dean says "No, I saw "Hellraiser". I get the gist."

Ruby turns and starts walking away she says "Actually, they got that pretty close. Except for all the custom leather." Dean looks thoughtful and Ruby stops her departure, and turns back to Dean and says "The answer is yes, by the way." Dean says "I'm sorry?" Ruby says "Yes, the same thing will happen to you. It might take centuries, but sooner or later Hell will burn away your humanity. Every Hell-bound soul, every one, turns into something else and turns you into us. So Yeah, you can count on it." Dean asks "There's no way of saving me from the Pit, is there?" Ruby sighs and says "No." Dean says "Then why'd you tell Sam that you could?" Ruby says "So he would talk to me, You Winchesters can be pretty bigoted. I needed something to help him get past the–" Dean says "The demon thing? It's pretty hard to get past." Ruby laughs and says "Look at you. Tryin' to be all stoic My god, it's heartbreaking." Dean asks "Why are you telling me all this?" Ruby says "I need your help." Dean asks "Help with what?" Ruby says "With Sam, The way you stuck that demon tonight – it was pretty tough. They're almost there, but not quite you need to help me get them ready – for life without you and To fight this war together." Ruby turns and walks away and Dean says "Ruby she pauses "Why do you want us to win?" Ruby turns back around to face Dean and says "Isn't it obvious? I'm not like them. I don't know why. I – I wish I was, but ... I'm not. I remember what it's like." Dean asks "What what's like?" Ruby says "Being human." Dean looks down lost in his thoughts, and when he looks up Ruby has disappeared leaving Dean alone in the parking lot.