OK, I've read 185 chapters and have a pretty solid grasp of the story. I'll rate 5 stars, but will also provide some feedback. Pro's: Compelling story, makes you want to keep reading. Feels authentic to the Chinese style. Author keeps track of his characters and events and few plot holes I saw. Mostly decent grammar and isn't annoying to read for a native English speaker like many novels on here are. No Curse Book that solves everything without any effort (so far). Feedback: Somewhat shallow character interaction, a particular disciple is said to feel extremely close to MC more than their own father, but it feels unearned because we don't see any bonding scenes and relevant events that make such a staggering statement feel justified. Character emotional development can't happen off-screen or we the readers won't care about them and will feel like their relationships don't feel real. No romance (yet) - I get it, MC is busy cultivating, but won't he always be busy cultivating until the end of the story when he is The Supreme Creator God or whatever? If you're going to do it, then find a way to make it happen. Also make sure we get the proper emotion building to go with it, better to have no romance than 1 dimensional romance imo. For the future: One of the great limitations of TTP is how reliant on the System Han Jue was, the more you read the more you realised that the System was basically the MC with a Han Jue attached - the System was so ridiculously overpowered that a pig could have been the host and would have done just fine. Make sure that the MC stays front and centre, makes plans intelligently and acts based on human wants, needs and desires, otherwise just watching a System give out endless Deus Ex Machina type treasures that happen to solve all his problems just when he needs them gets old and is not conducive to a healthy novel long term. OK, that's all I can think of for now, you're a good writer, keep it up.

Han Jue, huh? 😁 well, I would love to read your book but it's still... you know, chapters aren't enough to entertain me so I'll wait till there are 60 or 70 amassed. 👍

Story isn’t bad, but it’s simply a rehashing of Top Tier Providence. The description states that this takes inspiration from that novel, but it’s entirely too similar aside from the beginning and the characters themselves obviously. There’s no appeal to this novel if you’ve already read Top Tier Providence in my opinion.

is this novel dropped?ggghhhhhhhhbbbbbbbbbh

Even if i have not read this book, i read top tier providence and finished it. I have been looking for a novel like that for months, the fact that you can recreate it in your own way is enough for me. Thank you I'm satisfied with your work, i hope you work hard and improve your writing abilities.

I like that you like top tier providence. its my first ever novel that was so interesting, it is also my favourite novel.

Great story 9/10 pretty simmilar to Top Tier Providence, Secretly Cultivate for a Thousand Years but there are unique stuff and at most few things are simmilar but some things mc at that novel got late here he might get early or other way anyway its at most slight connection but yeah just like that novel its great, only problem is that autho uploads 3 ch per week.... which is very slow, as long as he uploads more it will be much better review: ch213

Really good story in my opinion . The grammar is pretty good for English not being your first language( I think you said that). The only thing I don’t like is that he pretty much gets the same rewards each time he cultivates maybe change it up a little instead of getting a new robe each time. I also dislike that the mc allows too many people to depend on him .

Youre write is good. It’s true that some people will criticize but don’t take too much into account what others say, do what you like. I really like the world you created and I hope you can finish this work. 5stars[img=strong]

Very good work I encourage the author[img=update]