webnovel
RandyButterNups
RandyButterNupsLv21yr
2023-11-01 03:56

It's pretty rare to see a fanfic centered around Oldeus, but it's always nice to see. The story is pretty good; the only major issue with the story, in my opinion, is Rudy's character. In the Oldeus timeline, Rudeus suffers horrific trauma after horrific trauma and becomes a depressed, homicidal, womanizing alcoholic (albeit a very powerful alcoholic) that's hellbent on revenge and becoming stronger. So, you'd expect after he time travels these things would deeply affect him, but said events feel to have little impact on his character. That being said, the story isn't finished, and the author may very well be planning to address this concern. On a more positive note, in almost everything else I can think of, the author does very well, especially in his writing of Paul and Rudy's interactions. Sometimes it honestly feels like how Rifujin would write the two.

Liked by 2 people

LIKE
Replies3
Sacred_Author
Sacred_AuthorLv3

I think the reason why it has little impact because Rudeus is tempting to become a better person and redeem himself in specific ways. Besides, despite the world not having age restriction on alcohol. I highly doubt Rudeus is stupid enough get wasted on booze and affect his younger body and health. When he could use that energy to get stronger in his magic skills like healing, gravity magic and disabling magic. So he doesn’t run the risk of losing his family again. That’s the whole purpose of the story being about Rudy getting a second chance.

traceeee
traceeeeLv4

you don't understand Old Rudeus had major ptsd and survivor's guilt. Even reborn he should've had nightmares about his love ones death and space out a lot. The early chapters should've showed it but didn't you don't magically get better from remembering how your loved ones died in your arms the sacrifices they made for Rudy. Over all this feels like the Cannon Rudy who died of old age surrounded by his family

Sacred_Author:I think the reason why it has little impact because Rudeus is tempting to become a better person and redeem himself in specific ways. Besides, despite the world not having age restriction on alcohol. I highly doubt Rudeus is stupid enough get wasted on booze and affect his younger body and health. When he could use that energy to get stronger in his magic skills like healing, gravity magic and disabling magic. So he doesn’t run the risk of losing his family again. That’s the whole purpose of the story being about Rudy getting a second chance.
Sacred_Author
Sacred_AuthorLv3

I think I understand why the author didn’t implemented Old Rudeus’s nightmares and daydreaming about his previous life traumas because the author was still a novice in writing fanfiction stories.

traceeee:you don't understand Old Rudeus had major ptsd and survivor's guilt. Even reborn he should've had nightmares about his love ones death and space out a lot. The early chapters should've showed it but didn't you don't magically get better from remembering how your loved ones died in your arms the sacrifices they made for Rudy. Over all this feels like the Cannon Rudy who died of old age surrounded by his family
Other Reviews
Related Stories

One Piece: Deriving All Things

Sanders has crossed into the world of One Piece, blessed with a unique ability: he can derive and master any power—Haki, Devil Fruits, combat techniques—everything can become his. To survive and grow stronger in this chaotic world, he joins the Marines, seeking structure and safety. But fate takes a dark turn when his adoptive parent is ruthlessly murdered by a Celestial Dragon. Sanders vows revenge, yet before he can act, he is captured by Sengoku and Kizaru, locked away in the depths of Impel Down. In the infamous prison, Sanders uses his power to derive new abilities from legends around him: the Moa Moa no Mi, the Fusion-Fusion Fruit, even Barrett's fearsome Haki. As years pass, Sanders grows more powerful, biding his time. Finally, he decides the moment has come—he walks out of Impel Down, shaking the world to its core. "You fought Kaido in a fierce battle; derivation time for the Azure Dragon Fruit reduced by one year." "You battled Whitebeard with all your strength; Gura Gura no Mi (Quake-Quake Fruit) successfully derived." "You clashed with Big Mom; her indomitable Steel Balloon Physique is now yours." At the Summit War, Sanders challenges the might of all three Admirals singlehandedly. Marine Headquarters: "He was once one of us; now, we regret it deeply." Boa Hancock: "I’ll stand by Sanders—let’s declare war on the Celestial Dragons!" Nico Robin: "Only he can bring me true safety." Join Sanders as he faces the mightiest forces of the One Piece world, deriving power from the strongest to fulfill his destiny. -------------- Access 30 chapters in advance on my Patreon: p@treon.com/OneFic This is a translation work; I do not own it. Raw:航海:推衍万物,顶上硬撼三大将

OneFic · Anime & Comics
4.8
112 Chs