webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of marcelll3214 in Harry Potter: The Dark Lord rebirth

Review detail

marcelll3214
marcelll3214Lv21yrmarcelll3214

17 chapters of nothing happening. Full of clishe. Mc isnt like Voldy at all and is too soft for this to have any sense. The only way this story has such a high rating is author deleting reviews and censuring comments.

altalt

Harry Potter: The Dark Lord rebirth

Krio_Genix

Liked by 10 people

LIKE

Replies7

Mysteries_
Mysteries_Lv11Mysteries_

find a psychiatrist

Daoist452371:It’s a villain story so why wouldn’t we want to read about a villain
Mysteries_
Mysteries_Lv11Mysteries_

Even if the author deletes the comments the rating would drop so your hypothesis is already invalid there, just think a little, what sane person would want to read a story with Voldemort as the protagonist? just crazy in the head, of course he would have to give me and soooo much his personality.

ibxtoycatStan
ibxtoycatStanLv4ibxtoycatStan

well that could be explained by the combination slightly effecting him and providing him with emotions.

void_ouroboros
void_ouroborosLv4void_ouroboros

no, authors can in fact delete reviews. some delete anything below 4 stars giving themself a 4.9 stars with 50 reviews. a lot of those 5 stars are "nice nice nice...." and they're allowed

Mysteries_:Even if the author deletes the comments the rating would drop so your hypothesis is already invalid there, just think a little, what sane person would want to read a story with Voldemort as the protagonist? just crazy in the head, of course he would have to give me and soooo much his personality.
Alef_Biersack
Alef_BiersackLv2Alef_Biersack

It actually makes sense that he changes he's an insignificant piece against a whole soul, apart from what little was shown about voldy not how to use him as a protagonist he was completely unbalanced making irrational decisions one after another, to use him as a protagonist would have to be a more rational and empathetic adolescent version of him, an example of an idiotic decision is him killing a student at school and hoping that there are no consequences, even more so when he could do it outside of school much more easily and much less consequences, when he goes after Harry in the canon he is already completely demented.

Aleksic
AleksicLv11Aleksic

Voldemort is truly EVIL as it states in the books and the movies and the way he carries himself because his soul is to the root EVIL, everything he does is for himself. So it’s both hard and at the same time easy to write Voldemort depending on the author ofcourse

Daoist452371
Daoist452371Lv13Daoist452371

It’s a villain story so why wouldn’t we want to read about a villain

Mysteries_:Even if the author deletes the comments the rating would drop so your hypothesis is already invalid there, just think a little, what sane person would want to read a story with Voldemort as the protagonist? just crazy in the head, of course he would have to give me and soooo much his personality.