webnovel
MEA_24_Lv132yr
2023-02-28 16:13

Your characters felt hollow. Lacking in another word. You've already established the world background and even the side character story background so seamlessly that it impress me but then, the chapter about the 'Black Group' entering the lab for Jake's energy stone to 'level up' I was expecting the character development. you know? His own development,we already get the idea that he's the clown of the group, the failure in the eyes of his parents etc. etc. You've made your point. And was extremely excited that He realized that what was the point of getting the gem if they died and with the sacrifice of kitty/Kate to escape from the ants and the pressure of not being able to get out and added another pressure from the gf fainting or he shouldn't have pushed Kyle to go find his gem element to immediately rank up. I sense the character development. Also Dylan? The silent of the three could've felt the pressure especially with the mutant ants rank 4 and up digging below. And then what? Kitty awake, Kyle level up, gf awaken etc. Etc. Err author what's the point of that adventure the thrill or the sci-fi you classified this novel as? you shouldn't write you know if it's for the sake of making more money or if it's readers satisfaction, if you can't take criticism or you yourself just tooo influenced by Chinese webnovel but the thing is I've read many Chinese novels but they have one thing many people want, change. I like the characters, the concept of our mc being cat, and even Kyle who's cold cuz of trauma (typical ml) but Err 'naughty little kitty' thing? Aughr eww. and also always same attitude towards kitten except being suspicious of the cats identity by testing blood and being soften by few character development (when Kate knew Kyle massacred few people and more. )and few grammar errors otw that's fine but please, find an editor or even proofreader if this novel of yours is behind pay wall every chapter before 45 right? . And even some of your chapters felt incomplete like you literally cut them in half literally and figuratively. There's a limit on how much you can take before people leaving unsatisfied with your book I just reached from 150+ chaps but ahh meh. Ill try to read more to see your improvements on your story after you read my critique and maybe I'll read more soon. Alos don't be offended from some of my words or some of the double meaning behind them of that helps, I won't be sorry but if I'm wrong in some points I'd point out please correct me, I may or may not leave some info around to analyze more.

Liked by 6 people

LIKE
Replies5
SorahanaAuthor

it's fine, I don't mind getting critique and I have faced harsher curses and others that couldn't be seen due to the censor system here. I mainly write this story because I want to and I was trying to cross genres after reading too many similar themes novels 😅 (before being an author, I'm naturally also a reader) Idk about your expectations when reading the story, I mainly write a light-hearted one that didn't have heavy conflicts. Even if there's some character development, it was not much for this story 🤔 there's only some changes and yeah, it's indeed far from perfect. If you wished to read a lot of character development, then this might not be your cup of tea. 😅 for editor... I usually edit myself with the help of word or Google word. I'll pay more attention to it along with the grammar as much as possible. (>.<) thank you for your review 🙂

MEA_24_Lv13

My expectations is just you know Jake's just can't be the clown of the group like I expect something more from him and even Dylan in the face of pressure in the 'getting the gem for Jake scene' with kitty's space collapse, I thought maybe I'll see some development that they don't have eto depend on Kate on every turn there's a hurdle the grain arc I can accept with them escaping with the help of kitty's space. Then here on the point I'm saying like that certain scene or arc I've talking about I can't get over it cause you know. Yknow! Like there could be a breakthrough after you added trails of breadcrumbs before that arc like the getting the grain scene and escaping from a horde of insects. I don't really know what I'm talking about now but in the face of my criticism you took it head on and I'm proud to say you look pass the attacks and face the real issue. To me that's hard to deal with, especially with many authors from the web I've encountered.

Sorahana:it's fine, I don't mind getting critique and I have faced harsher curses and others that couldn't be seen due to the censor system here. I mainly write this story because I want to and I was trying to cross genres after reading too many similar themes novels 😅 (before being an author, I'm naturally also a reader) Idk about your expectations when reading the story, I mainly write a light-hearted one that didn't have heavy conflicts. Even if there's some character development, it was not much for this story 🤔 there's only some changes and yeah, it's indeed far from perfect. If you wished to read a lot of character development, then this might not be your cup of tea. 😅 for editor... I usually edit myself with the help of word or Google word. I'll pay more attention to it along with the grammar as much as possible. (>.<) thank you for your review 🙂
MEA_24_Lv13

Part 2 it's also my cut of tea. Especially the concept of the the world your making it a aught my eye. I'm okay with the lighthearted and comedic novel it added for the toppings but the cherry on top is the soul of your characters or the thing I've been calling 'character dev' also I'm pointing this out so maybe yknow you could improve on it and level it up. Also please don't take some of my frustration that I hate your book. It's a meaning to some readers that were so invested in the author's story that we can't help but just complain or give pointers as a readers point of view. Ahem* that is all.. I think.

Sorahana:it's fine, I don't mind getting critique and I have faced harsher curses and others that couldn't be seen due to the censor system here. I mainly write this story because I want to and I was trying to cross genres after reading too many similar themes novels 😅 (before being an author, I'm naturally also a reader) Idk about your expectations when reading the story, I mainly write a light-hearted one that didn't have heavy conflicts. Even if there's some character development, it was not much for this story 🤔 there's only some changes and yeah, it's indeed far from perfect. If you wished to read a lot of character development, then this might not be your cup of tea. 😅 for editor... I usually edit myself with the help of word or Google word. I'll pay more attention to it along with the grammar as much as possible. (>.<) thank you for your review 🙂
SorahanaAuthor

Hmm, I don't have much plan for Jake tbh, which is why his character development is the fewest 🤔 The only development is in regards of his relationship with his gf in the later chapters but for his own innate characters I set, it's a bit difficult. I'll try to add some more characteristics in the future chapters as deemed suitable. And thanks haha. After facing some unreasonable readers, yours can only be considered cute for me. 🤗 Some authors actually don't mind criticism, so perhaps you just hadn't met with the right ones 😅

MEA_24_:My expectations is just you know Jake's just can't be the clown of the group like I expect something more from him and even Dylan in the face of pressure in the 'getting the gem for Jake scene' with kitty's space collapse, I thought maybe I'll see some development that they don't have eto depend on Kate on every turn there's a hurdle the grain arc I can accept with them escaping with the help of kitty's space. Then here on the point I'm saying like that certain scene or arc I've talking about I can't get over it cause you know. Yknow! Like there could be a breakthrough after you added trails of breadcrumbs before that arc like the getting the grain scene and escaping from a horde of insects. I don't really know what I'm talking about now but in the face of my criticism you took it head on and I'm proud to say you look pass the attacks and face the real issue. To me that's hard to deal with, especially with many authors from the web I've encountered.
SorahanaAuthor

Haha, it's ok. I have experienced a few readers who chased me online with a knife in discord chats 😂

MEA_24_:Part 2 it's also my cut of tea. Especially the concept of the the world your making it a aught my eye. I'm okay with the lighthearted and comedic novel it added for the toppings but the cherry on top is the soul of your characters or the thing I've been calling 'character dev' also I'm pointing this out so maybe yknow you could improve on it and level it up. Also please don't take some of my frustration that I hate your book. It's a meaning to some readers that were so invested in the author's story that we can't help but just complain or give pointers as a readers point of view. Ahem* that is all.. I think.
Other Reviews
Related Stories

A Wilderness Within

Emma Castle has always loved reading but didn’t know she loved romance until she was enduring the trials of law school. She discovered the dark and sexy world of romance novels and since then has never looked back! She loves writing about sexy, alpha male heroes who know just how to seduce women even if they are a bit naughty about it. When Emma’s not writing, she may be obsessing over her favorite show Supernatural where she’s a total Team Dean Winchester kind of girl! Join Emma’s Private Reader Group “Emma Castle’s Crew” here: https://www.facebook.com/groups/429283600812685/ The world he knows and loves is gone… Lincoln Atwood survived the contagion that wiped out the nine tenths of humanity. As the last survivor in a secret government bunker and a Delta Force soldier, he knows that the other survivors are scared, angry and dangerous, just like him. After weeks alone with the mummified bodies of his colleagues, he escapes the bunker. But the world outside has changed. Among the empty cities and crumbling ruins of civilization, he loses himself to the wilderness in his soul. When he sees Caroline, a fellow survivor, she is vision of light in a world gone dark. He wants to help her, but she won't trust him, when there's danger around every corner. How can he convince her that fate has brought them together? She will not go quietly into the night… Caroline Kelly survived hell when she escaped quarantined Chicago in search of her family after the outbreak. But it's not as easy to travel from Illinois to Missouri with the world gone dark in the space of three months. The last she thing she needs is to get captured by a muscled, bearded mountain man who looks and acts like a damn super soldier. When it’s clear she can’t escape him, she finds herself becoming fascinated with the brooding, intense man who knows how to survive. He makes her heart race and blood pound. When tragedy strikes, Caroline realizes she might have a plan to save the world, but she’ll need Lincoln’s help. Can she trust Lincoln not only with humanity’s future, but also her heart?

Emma Castle · Sci-fi
Not enough ratings
38 Chs

The Dark Fairy

Kidnapped at the age of three, Rain found herself amongst the people who put monsters and devils to shame. Subjected to their torture since young age, she turned out to be the cold-blooded killer with no emotions but was gifted some superhuman abilities. As a result, she began turning into one of those demons herself. But two little angels in the form of her brothers saved her from this eternal damnation and to protect those angels from the fate same as her, she decided to flee from the shackles of those monsters. Rain believed herself to be one of those monsters whose sole goal in this life was only to create a safe world for her brothers. But the interference of a certain pesky man forced her to question her goal. He just barged into her life and made her believe that although she was filled with darkness, she was a fairy. “A Dark Fairy” is what he called her. After marking his presence and establishing his position as the ruthless leader in the underworld, Elliot Harvey finally decided to take over his family business. But before that he had to intern in his own company under a disguise as Kai. It was there that he met Rain. Now gone was the ruthless king of the underworld and what remained was a young puppy in love who just wanted to be noticed by this mysterious girl who had captured his heart with her hypnotizing eyes. ******** “Wha… Just what happened here?” his best friend gulped as soon as his gaze landed on a girl standing there like a demon sent by the Hades himself. “Elliot. What in the world happened here? Why does Rain look like thi… like this….”. He wanted to say demon when he heard Elliot say “Fairy.” “Fairy??!!! Are you out if your mind? She’s clearly a Demon, okay?? A DEMON! Straight from the hell!!!” his friend trembled. ********** Although she had escaped, she soon realised that she could never be free unless those monsters were annihilated from the face of the Earth. Thus began a secret war. A war to save humanity. This is her journey of redemption. This is his journey to unbound her from the darkness within her. The story of his assistance to her quests, complimenting her where she lacked. He thought that he was lucky enough to get a chance to join her in this war but unknown to him, he had already signed up for this war before he even met her. But what is it that they are fighting? What is it that she is protecting her brothers from? How was Elliot involved in this war before he even knew her? Will she be able to overcome the darkness within her to lead a happy life? Let’s accompany Rain on her excursion to find the answers. (Warning- This story have a BL romance later into the story. Hence those people who are uncomfortable about reading such stories are suggested to re-consider before picking up this story. As for the rest of the readers, Thank you for your support. Happy Reading \\^_^//) Ps- The credit of the picture on the cover goes to the original owner in Pintrest whom I don’t know.

Dwarika · Sci-fi
Not enough ratings
200 Chs