webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of rubber_band123 in I'm Gohan!

Review detail

rubber_band123
rubber_band123Lv51yrrubber_band123

The writing quality is equivalent of the average chinese novel. so ehh... Story Development is eh... Character Design is also eh... nothing special but nothing out of the ordinary or OCC. Until the Yamcha incident. Keep reading to know why. oh I also got insulted as Yamcha fanboy for giving valid criticism lol World Background is also eh. The novel doesn't really explore the world building then again its a fanfiction. Most ff don't even bother w this part. So let's talk about the Yamcha incident. Let me explain like those 4chan story because it much more fun. >be me a ff enjoyer >reading a DBZ ff >hoping it be a good a ff where it fix many mistake that Toriyama made such as neglecting the OG series such as Krillin, Yamcha, and Tien. >yamcha become much much stronger >yamcha IQ is lowered to room temperature for some reason >become a comic relief telling the enemy about the Dragonball because? >still die to sibamen suicidal attack >me criticize author for writing Yamcha so Out Of Character >got called as Yamcha fanboy in return LOL ff author aren't the most mature being but this is just childish. Don't bother reading. Look elsewhere maybe fanfiction.net.

altalt

I'm Gohan!

LordPhenex026

Liked by 73 people

LIKE

Replies5

rubber_band123
rubber_band123Lv5rubber_band123

There is word that describes a person attitude that is not immature or mature attitude. It is either one or the other. And I hope you not foolish enough to lie to me and to yourself the author attitude to criticism is "mature". But if you do find a word that describes the author attitude, not immature but not mature either. Do let me know, would love to know such word. The author showing his true colour/character is the fact he has a strange grudge against a fictional character, name Yamcha. He turn one of the respectable character in the OG series (before Toriyama butcher and neglect him in Z series and its sequel) into a half arse comic relief (or I assume it is comic relief) and plot convenient for the reason the story is following the canon route and y'know anywhere but the canon route, basically lazy writing. Yamcha is probably not even a comic relief considering how 2D little depth in his character, acting like a chinese arrogant character, seriously the whole story is written like those chinese novel filled with arrogant character from left to right. Is there any reason for Yamcha IQ to turn into room temperature other than plot convenient a.k.a lazy writing? Nope. Not that I can think of. Oh, and he also die despite the fact Yamcha is a veteran martial art fighter who received warning to not underestimated the enemies. Also can we talk about how the Gohan, the MC just deliberately was never there when the Saiyan arrive, allowing them to wipe a city from the face of the planet and fighting the Z warrior resulting Yamcha death and telling Vegeta about the Dragonball? What was it that Gohan while the Saiyan pods arrive in his planet? Was he jerking off or something? Literally epitome of lazy writing. Which is nothing wrong about putting half arse effort into their story. it is a fanfiction, but to pretend their writing is anything but lazy writing is so shameless.

RVE1:I'm not siding with the author but... is all he did call you a Yamcha fanboy? It's annoying to hear but it doesn't sound THAT bad that you think he's immature and saying he 'showed his true colors'. Idk, just some outside perspective.
LordPhenex026
LordPhenex026AuthorLordPhenex026

Okay, Yamcha fanboy. Goodbye

rubber_band123
rubber_band123Lv5rubber_band123

Who hurt you lol? Can't even take criticism without sounding like a 12 year old.

LordPhenex026:Okay, Yamcha fanboy. Goodbye
RVE1
RVE1Lv1RVE1

To be fair, you said his novel was meh, or fairly normal, but then proceeded to give him a 1 star. If I was him I wouldn't listen to your criticism either.

rubber_band123:Who hurt you lol? Can't even take criticism without sounding like a 12 year old.
RVE1
RVE1Lv1RVE1

I'm not siding with the author but... is all he did call you a Yamcha fanboy? It's annoying to hear but it doesn't sound THAT bad that you think he's immature and saying he 'showed his true colors'. Idk, just some outside perspective.

The content has been deleted
Dao_of_Lazy
Dao_of_LazyLv3Dao_of_Lazy

LordPhenex026:Okay, Yamcha fanboy. Goodbye