webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Navasu_69 in Harry Potter: Dimensional Wizard

Review detail

Navasu_69
Navasu_69Lv42yrNavasu_69

I find it in very bad taste that he is making a body so he can revive lily only to "give" it to snape as if it were an object and not a person.

altalt

Harry Potter: Dimensional Wizard

LazySageDao

Liked by 100 people

LIKE

Replies22

Daoist198784
Daoist198784Lv4Daoist198784

in life, she turned down Snape and chose another, what makes him think that she will choose him now? And even more so, he argues as if she is a thing and he can give it to anyone he wants

Moho_Amine:bro first of all this is litarly a fanfic to which the author can write whatever he likes second as he is the ruler of the empire he made polygamy legal so there is that for her husband he has the right to accept or deny ,also there is actually something called devorce it happen when two married couple dont agree to live together anymore surprise right?
LazySageDao
LazySageDaoAuthorLazySageDao

just because he is reviving lily does not mean that she will instantly fall in love with or belong to Snape. Edward just made a deal with to revive her in exchange for all his potion knowledge.

DaoistnMkJQ8
DaoistnMkJQ8Lv3DaoistnMkJQ8

so MC is literally an idiot

Kal_Thanatos
Kal_ThanatosLv3Kal_Thanatos

Dude, you should have used spoiler feature

Angry_Sheep
Angry_SheepLv13Angry_Sheep

Where did that come from...?

DaoistnMkJQ8:so MC is literally an idiot
SUBSCRIBE_MY_LIST
SUBSCRIBE_MY_LISTLv5SUBSCRIBE_MY_LIST

Tbh by that process it is an object. After all, he created the body, and whilst the soul isn't his... The body technically is if he litterally created it. That makes it a moral dilemma, and a form of copyright infringement. After all, it's like building the exact same house as someone else, but then inviting them to live in yours. Does that still make you retain ownership of the house you invited them to? Another question is whether the soul inserted is really lily's. For all we know, the object summons not a genuine soul but creates a construct with a personality imprint based on your idea of someone's personality. In which case, is said imprint still said person, and since said person is dead and the construct might well be another object of your making, it makes the outcome in either body and soul being objects a very controversial thing. Ultimately, if they are both a construct made by his imagination then giving Snape a replica version of lily, is technically the same as handing him an object, because technically she would be. Morality wise tough, it becomes a very slippery sloap, where does it start, and where does it end?

Daoist198784
Daoist198784Lv4Daoist198784

What about her husband?

LazySageDao:just because he is reviving lily does not mean that she will instantly fall in love with or belong to Snape. Edward just made a deal with to revive her in exchange for all his potion knowledge.
Faithlesszealot
FaithlesszealotLv3Faithlesszealot

You all assume he is "giving" Lily to Severus, I am under the impression he is giving him not her body but the chance to revive her. She will have all memories and her soul from the time of her death.

proganerx_Dave
proganerx_DaveLv4proganerx_Dave

So she made a deal to Mc to revive her husband if she can teach love magic to some one?

LazySageDao:just because he is reviving lily does not mean that she will instantly fall in love with or belong to Snape. Edward just made a deal with to revive her in exchange for all his potion knowledge.
DarkKnight32
DarkKnight32Lv6DarkKnight32

lily can bring him back when she is able to teach someone to use love magic.

Daoist198784:What about her husband?
kairus
kairusLv4kairus

You should have read it right before posting this comment.

Apache_h1
Apache_h1Lv4Apache_h1

from what I've read he didn't give lily to snape he just delayed her husbands revival to give snape a chance

Apache_h1
Apache_h1Lv4Apache_h1

also before he left he got Rowena to revive her husband(rip snape forever single) and gave her the points she deserved

its_L
its_LLv3its_L

author san is your second novel journey of the fate destroyer emperor harem or not?

LazySageDao:just because he is reviving lily does not mean that she will instantly fall in love with or belong to Snape. Edward just made a deal with to revive her in exchange for all his potion knowledge.
LazySageDao
LazySageDaoAuthorLazySageDao

it's not

its_L:author san is your second novel journey of the fate destroyer emperor harem or not?
its_L
its_LLv3its_L

already on chapter 70 great novel till now

LazySageDao:it's not
See_rer
See_rerLv13See_rer

from war machine 😂😂😂😂😂😂

Angry_Sheep:Where did that come from...?
Selectials
SelectialsLv4Selectials

Fool. You forget that besides Lily's resurrection, everything else happened in their world. And also the human selling part exists in the real world, like in tajikistan.

214dnde
214dndeLv4214dnde

Hope lily with the mc tbh

Moho_Amine
Moho_AmineLv4Moho_Amine

bro first of all this is litarly a fanfic to which the author can write whatever he likes second as he is the ruler of the empire he made polygamy legal so there is that for her husband he has the right to accept or deny ,also there is actually something called devorce it happen when two married couple dont agree to live together anymore surprise right?

Daoist198784:What about her husband?