webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Just_Alan in Forging my Legend in One Piece

Review detail

Just_Alan
Just_AlanLv43yrJust_Alan

As an author you have to make the story believable so that the readers remain invested in the story. Granted this is a fanfiction and you might not be a proffesional author, but due to some things in the fanfiction I wasnt able to continue. Author, you have full freedom on how to write ur MC. But the thing in this story is that MC's motivation, actions and history dont line up. MC is someone who was tortured (gruesomely tortured) while he was a slave and he himself said it outloud that he would slaughter world nobles especially his slave owner when he escapes. But what does he actually do when he gets the chance to do that, he just slashes his slave owners face. I could have bought this if MC was icky about killing, but u just stated a chapter before that he killed so many people while in arena that his kill count was much bigger than pirates. This forces us readers to reason with commonsense as to why he might have done that. Either u should change MC motivation to make it in line with his actions. Anyway try this novel and see if it is for you. I didnt pick up any errors in the writing so that was a pro. I also liked the pacing of the story, it wasnt too fast nor too slow, this is subjective but I liked the pace. I might come back when there is more chapters and if the author improved his MCs character design. Good luck author and Hope u dont feel demotivated by this review and I hope u keep writing, I just wanted to point out some flaws in writing the author could improve on. 😊👍

altalt

Forging my Legend in One Piece

Black_Paladyn

Liked by 85 people

LIKE

Replies6

Black_Paladyn
Black_PaladynAuthorBlack_Paladyn

I don't mind bad reviews at all, as long as they give useful criticism in a respectful way. Thank you.

Aht
AhtLv14Aht

You sure about that? Grammar is quite bad for this one. Lots of spelling mistakes, improper use, grammatical structures, (like you don't leave spaces when you use " ", when someone asks a question, you use ? and not .) etc Author I suggest you proofread your chs or use something like Grammarly to assist you (:

Black_Paladyn:I don't mind bad reviews at all, as long as they give useful criticism in a respectful way. Thank you.
WHAT_NO_MONEY
WHAT_NO_MONEYLv13WHAT_NO_MONEY

He might be like me where the shit grammar get blurred out by the brain and makes up the gaps internally.

Aht:You sure about that? Grammar is quite bad for this one. Lots of spelling mistakes, improper use, grammatical structures, (like you don't leave spaces when you use " ", when someone asks a question, you use ? and not .) etc Author I suggest you proofread your chs or use something like Grammarly to assist you (:
Jackson_Alucard611
Jackson_Alucard611Lv14Jackson_Alucard611

who are the harem members?

Black_Paladyn:I don't mind bad reviews at all, as long as they give useful criticism in a respectful way. Thank you.
Fachi
FachiLv1Fachi

What do you mean by "Are you sure about that"? Yeah, he is. He said he is fine with low star reviews as long as they give actual criticism and that's what this is.

Aht:You sure about that? Grammar is quite bad for this one. Lots of spelling mistakes, improper use, grammatical structures, (like you don't leave spaces when you use " ", when someone asks a question, you use ? and not .) etc Author I suggest you proofread your chs or use something like Grammarly to assist you (:
ibxtoycatStan
ibxtoycatStanLv4ibxtoycatStan

to much xianxia bro

WHAT_NO_MONEY:He might be like me where the shit grammar get blurred out by the brain and makes up the gaps internally.