This is a good read so far, the class he gets is from what I can tell OP but not cheat level, he has to put in a lot of hard work which is nice compared to other instant skill novels, very realistic reactions etc, only thing I don't like is he forgot about his beginner free stay points - _- Other than that small blip it's great, not that many blacksmith novels and this has great potential Don't drop this or I might cry myself to sleep 😭

Nice

It starts off as an amazing book, i Literally couldnt stop reading it. However lately every Page released seems extremely short and is 70% just listing stats of gear. the wrotimg has become extremely lazy honestly. That or it jumps to anoyjer character for no reason at all and nothing has been accomplished. i really like the book but am probably gonna stop reading as now it feels more like its beimg dragged out for votes and money.

I love it! It's a stable and fluent read as I did not see any mistakes in grammer/etc. yet (ch. 36) (could be because my low english skills but I think its perfectly done). Can't say anything 'bout the updating stability yet as I binged it but it says 11 chapters a week ... great! The story development is kinda slow compared to other novels (again, could be because I usually binge read 100 to up to 500 chapters at once) but its perfect for a story with a blacksmith as protagonist as actual forging is an important part of such novels. Didn't even find plotholes yet, but alot of humourus references. And last but not least the worlbackground. It's really well done. Without trying to spoil too much it seems to be a post apocalyptic world but not the normal nuclear bomb scenario but it uses the climate change. This gives birth to interesting and new enemies and enviromental conditions. A (in my eyes) unique and nice approach to the genre.

Started out really well but after about chapter 30-40, the MC leaves his world and so it no longer becomes an apocalypse story but closer to a an isekai. Granted, I am only about 80+ chapters into it at this point, but I was expecting something completely different from the description and name of the story. It's not bad and I can see why others would enjoy it, but it no longer holds my interest. I might pick this back up later, but for now I am going to have to drop this novel.

Unique perspective on post apocalypse type novels with blacksmithing class. Initially didn't have any expectations but now I've been surprised. The system and blacksmithing itself is cool. Currently the story is still new but very good in my opinion

good novel, i like it . 🔽🔽🔼🔼⏫⏩⏪⏫⏫⏫🔼⏫⏩⏩⏩⏫🔼⏫⏫⏩⏫⏫⏫⏫⏫⏫⏫⏬🔼⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏬⏪⏫⏪⏫⏫⏪⏬⏬⏪🔽⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏬⏪⏪⏬⏬⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪⏫⏪

I have read to chapter 66(most recent chapter, when I wrote the review). I would rate this story as good and I like it, because I was immediately immersed in the story and read all available chapters in one sitting. What i liked: + The MC's class that provided a well balanced amount of crafting and fighting ability + The MC's character: I liked how well he accepted his class, being introvert, capable, how he healed with the apocalypse and that he has no delusional desire for a harem and being king. + The described world As the story has not ended yet and is not really far into the plot(I guess), this is not a negative point, but what I hope to still appear in the story: The title of the story is a blacksmith in the apocalypse. I don't feel that the story has gone into details about the apocalypse. So I hope that in the future, the MC will return to his world and we can really see and experience the apocalypse that happened.

This has turned out surprisingly to be a quite a good book. A lot of times crafting books get a bit boring, but the author manages to keep you interested with battles, world descriptions and more . World development is fascinating and the characters around MC are interesting as well. The only wish is for the author to do more updates!🙏