Review Detail of Reynerio1996 in Rebirth in KurokoNoBasket [DROPPED]

I mean at least change the rating to a higher mark if you're gonna praise it.

Bro you can't just put one star on update stability and writing quality just because you dislike the story. Write a fair review.

Bro you can't just put one star on update stability and writing quality just because you dislike the story. Write a fair review.

bro you cant just give 5 star rating when somethings don't deserve it but it seems that doesn't affect you from doing it

Well I’m guessing he enjoyed it that much to give it a 5 star review,but giving a one star review,when you know some aspects of this novel is amazing,like the stability of updates.

well it seems he hated it so bad that didn't matter

I haven't given this story a review and if I did I wouldn't give this 5 stars. At most 4, but it may be less than that. I like this story, I like the concept, the writing could be better, plot too, but you and a lot of people have been giving one stars when we all know this story deserves better than that. And I get some people leave 5 stars while just writing gibberish and I understand that so I don't comment on all one star reviews and instead turn a blind eye to even out the ratings. But this one explicitly said that he/she is giving a one star review because he didn't like the mc for losing. He did raise some points in the story that were questionable (Author explained why in the discord and I think in the ANs). And I like that, give honest reviews, but also leave an honest rating. Just because others leave 1 star or 5 stars doesn't mean you should too.

I haven't given this story a review and if I did I wouldn't give this 5 stars. At most 4, but it may be less than that. I like this story, I like the concept, the writing could be better, plot too, but you and a lot of people have been giving one stars when we all know this story deserves better than that. And I get some people leave 5 stars while just writing gibberish and I understand that so I don't comment on all one star reviews and instead turn a blind eye to even out the ratings. But this one explicitly said that he/she is giving a one star review because he didn't like the mc for losing. He did raise some points in the story that were questionable (Author explained why in the discord and I think in the ANs). And I like that, give honest reviews, but also leave an honest rating. Just because others leave 1 star or 5 stars doesn't mean you should too.

what's wrong with him not liking the mc losing a match he had no reason losing only because of the author whims and now that just killed the story unless he goes to another school he doesn't have a chance of ever winning again cause 1 player cant defeat a team

There's nothing wrong with him not liking the mc but it still doesn't mean you should leave a completely one star review. He should given at least a 4 or 5 star for the update stability since fiction updates almost daily and 3 or 4 star writing quality since there are only a few grammatical errors within the atory

i never said he doesn't like the mc I said he destroyed the story to make the mc lose never said anything about the mc personality also there isn't any problem with him being so disappointed with the story he doesn't bother to give it any 5 star rating for stability of updates because he doesn't think it matters that much and like the other guy said some guys like a story so much they don't care about other things like stability of updates and want to give a 5 star well here who got a guy who hated what the author did so much he got a 1 star rating here this is life

You said "he doesn't like the mc" in your last comment and he clearly said it in his review man. You're the one explaining that you don't like it because the author destroyed the story by making the mc lose. What you said about "hated the story so much that he didn't bother giving a 4 or 5 star for updates because it didn't matter." Well it does matter because it's what's being fair is all about. I've read stories much worse than this with writing so awful it's painful to even read, but I still gave the author what they deserved for making stable updates. He/she at least deserves that for the effort they put in. So I'm going to throw your words right back at you, does this story deserve a 1 star? Do you honestly believe that this story deserves a one star rating? If you don't then I rest my case. If you do, well that's okay too but i'd rather not talk to anyone so petty. Either way this argument is over; it's not like he's going to delete his review, so I won't waste my time for a futile action. I just wanted to give him a piece of my mind.

You said "he doesn't like the mc" in your last comment and he clearly said it in his review man. You're the one explaining that you don't like it because the author destroyed the story by making the mc lose. What you said about "hated the story so much that he didn't bother giving a 4 or 5 star for updates because it didn't matter." Well it does matter because it's what's being fair is all about. I've read stories much worse than this with writing so awful it's painful to even read, but I still gave the author what they deserved for making stable updates. He/she at least deserves that for the effort they put in. So I'm going to throw your words right back at you, does this story deserve a 1 star? Do you honestly believe that this story deserves a one star rating? If you don't then I rest my case. If you do, well that's okay too but i'd rather not talk to anyone so petty. Either way this argument is over; it's not like he's going to delete his review, so I won't waste my time for a futile action. I just wanted to give him a piece of my mind.

i said not liking the mc loseing a match he had no right to I don't know how that could have translated into we hate the mc but I'm bored with you when you grow half a brain come back and talk to me, no what don't because you are a f##king hypocrite and have no right trying and tell anyone anything I'm done with you

I'm here to argue that what the author did was right in making the MC lose the fight against the GOM because I'm gonna guess that he is going to win in the final tournament during middle school because of the training he is currently going through, and also the fact that the team was so useless against GOM makes them train like hell. Bur that's just my guess, I mean it's either that or fresh blood as good as GOM goes to that middle school and the MC finds them and did what he did with the eagle eyes kid.

It will be a weakened GOM who don't play as a true team anymore. So it doesn't matter, it feels like a consolation win for Shun. Not to mention that I don't care if the author was right in making him lose, if the loss doesn't feel or flow right with what's written before it. When it doesn't flow correctly, it feels like the author bending events to force the plot to flow along his own framework, with no regard to natural progression of events. We did read the same initial chapters in which he makes 3 extremely overpowered wishes at the beginning and all the training he did for years from a little kid right? The first loss was against unawakened inexperienced GOM too. He lost from a lucky three pointer from someone who doesn't shoot three pointers. The second loss, he randomly collapses from exhaustion, but none of the people chasing him around the court collapse from exhaustion, like Aomine. If you can't feel how the author is bruteforcing events in the direction of his plot framework with no regard for how it gets there, then I don't know what to tell you.

But wait, it was going with the flow, there were multiple cases of foreshadowing of what was going to happen to him. I will agree with you on that the first tournament lose was dumb because it was "pure luck" but in my mind there could have been excuses for that as well but still not enough to justify that he should have won. Yes we did see him train from basically when he was a kid, but that does not not mean that the people from GOM was also not doing the same. Another argument for the mc fainting due to fatigue he was 1vGOM and they GOM would have taken some stress off of each other. My bad for the structure of this paragraph, if I missed a point please tell me so I can "argue" against you if this is even arguing.

Bro if you read it wholeheartedly you will understand that he is not too OP in the game as he is also a human, have you ever seen a human playing 48 mins straight without stopped as he is mentally and physically drained, surely not. But you have said he isn't using his abilities; He was using it from the beginning sometimes and other times not as it will have more straining on his body understand that he in the 12,13 if you've looked it from that direction you will understand. Another point how come you have given only 1 star in the overall rating Background is good Update is good. Character same World design same Maybe we can have the same idea if its development as I also don't want him to lose. But if you want another one just search for this novel I CAN'T MISS Its also basketball based having unbeatable MC

Bro if you read it wholeheartedly you will understand that he is not too OP in the game as he is also a human, have you ever seen a human playing 48 mins straight without stopped as he is mentally and physically drained, surely not. But you have said he isn't using his abilities; He was using it from the beginning sometimes and other times not as it will have more straining on his body understand that he in the 12,13 if you've looked it from that direction you will understand. Another point how come you have given only 1 star in the overall rating Background is good Update is good. Character same World design same Maybe we can have the same idea if its development as I also don't want him to lose. But if you want another one just search for this novel I CAN'T MISS Its also basketball based having unbeatable MC

Bro if you read it wholeheartedly you will understand that he is not too OP in the game as he is also a human, have you ever seen a human playing 48 mins straight without stopped as he is mentally and physically drained, surely not. But you have said he isn't using his abilities; He was using it from the beginning sometimes and other times not as it will have more straining on his body understand that he in the 12,13 if you've looked it from that direction you will understand. Another point how come you have given only 1 star in the overall rating Background is good Update is good. Character same World design same Maybe we can have the same idea if its development as I also don't want him to lose. But if you want another one just search for this novel I CAN'T MISS Its also basketball based having unbeatable MC