webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Tarhanis in Harry crow ( harry potter fanfic)(FINISHED)

Review detail

Tarhanis
TarhanisLv53yrTarhanis

DID YOU ASK PERMISSION OF THE AUTHOR ?? IF NOT YOU SHOULD BE BAN... THIS A JUST A MATTER OF RESPECT, YOU DON'T GO AROUND PUBLISH PEOPLE WORK WITHOUT ASKING THEM, EVEN MORE WHEN IS A GREAT STORY 😒😒😒

altalt

Harry crow ( harry potter fanfic)(FINISHED)

Khaled_Sellami

Liked by 31 people

LIKE

Replies16

Above_All
Above_AllLv1Above_All

I don’t understand your point?

Stuffedcrow:actually at one time she stated she supported fan fics though then again she wrote Hermione as white in the story and now says she didn't so...
Darkoss
DarkossLv2Darkoss

right but the original author asked permission for jk rowling? wouldn't that be a little bit hypocritical?

Tarhanis
TarhanisLv5Tarhanis

There is a difference between create a fanfic and just copy a book ...😒 That why you would be sued for the latter and not the former ... Just logic and respect, there is nothing wrong writing fanfic. However if someone copy your work without permission, THIS is wrong. Unfortunately not everyone have common sense.

Herach
HerachLv4Herach

No. Permission was not given. That much is certain considering what the Author wrote in the author notes in his most recent fanfic. This kind of thing is honestly not okay.

glmo11
glmo11Lv5glmo11

They have disclaimer for that.

Darkoss:right but the original author asked permission for jk rowling? wouldn't that be a little bit hypocritical?
This_Dick
This_DickLv2This_Dick

DAMN BRO I DONT THINK THEY DID BUT THEY ARENT REQUIRED TOO YOU FUCKING NONCE

MIKK
MIKKLv11MIKK

The point of a fanfic is that it is the writer's own interpretation of the story. The story should be unique to the writer and this is holds even more true for a fanfiction as popular as this. There was no need for him to post it on webnovel, if the Original fanfic author wanted to, he would have done so himself.

Darkoss:right but the original author asked permission for jk rowling? wouldn't that be a little bit hypocritical?
DaoistSoulDive
DaoistSoulDiveLv4DaoistSoulDive

Honestly do people really care you are just trying to find a excuse to bash the person putting this on webnovel which allows people who don't use the trashy fanfiction.net to enjoy the story on a better novel provider so please just shut your trap and enjoy the story.

Tarhanis
TarhanisLv5Tarhanis

"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing " Edmund Burke. You have to fight when people act without thinking of others (and their rights). If everyone were to do like him ... Just hope some people will have some common sense and respect others rights and liberties. Who would like his work to be copy by another without authorization ? Show empathy pls ...

DaoistSoulDive:Honestly do people really care you are just trying to find a excuse to bash the person putting this on webnovel which allows people who don't use the trashy fanfiction.net to enjoy the story on a better novel provider so please just shut your trap and enjoy the story.
ReincarnateMe
ReincarnateMeLv4ReincarnateMe

This webpage is better

Hunter_Rodgers_3462
Hunter_Rodgers_3462Lv2Hunter_Rodgers_3462

yup

Shadewind
ShadewindLv6Shadewind

Yeah its hard to read in fan fiction. Net even the app is hard to use . So I rarely read there and it's hard to even find good fan fic as there is so much of them . So I think if the guy Don't make money and gives all the credit to the original author then I guess it's okay but if the original author don't like you posting his work without his permission then I guess you should respect his decision and put down the story .

ReincarnateMe:This webpage is better
Above_All
Above_AllLv1Above_All

Jk rowling did permit fanfic??????

Darkoss:right but the original author asked permission for jk rowling? wouldn't that be a little bit hypocritical?
Stuffedcrow
StuffedcrowLv14Stuffedcrow

actually at one time she stated she supported fan fics though then again she wrote Hermione as white in the story and now says she didn't so...

Above_All:Jk rowling did permit fanfic??????
lnsomniac_
lnsomniac_Lv4lnsomniac_

JK Rowling wrote one of the most iconic series of all time and proceeded to trash it more and more with each comment she made about the story. At this point Dumbledore and Snape are gay for each other and Lily had fun with Prongs from what I've heard.

Stuffedcrow:actually at one time she stated she supported fan fics though then again she wrote Hermione as white in the story and now says she didn't so...
Stuffedcrow
StuffedcrowLv14Stuffedcrow

Honestly besides the flaws we see when we re read it now just the fact she put Hermione with Ron was enough to ruin it lol but yea she has made enough hate for it all that its ruined it for many though she is still one of the few authors to support fan fiction writing of thier own works.(today's population has way to many snow flakes as my dead grandfather would call them to ever handle people having opinions anyway lol)

lnsomniac_:JK Rowling wrote one of the most iconic series of all time and proceeded to trash it more and more with each comment she made about the story. At this point Dumbledore and Snape are gay for each other and Lily had fun with Prongs from what I've heard.