webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Kiti in A Time Traveller's Guide to Feudal Japan

Review detail

Kiti
KitiLv134yrKiti

The quality of this novel is much better than most in Qidian, The writer's writing skill is pretty good, and he's very clear in what direction he wants to take his story forward. The writing is void of *******ism, which is rare to find in Qidian. The writer's command of english is very good. However, I felt his understanding of Japanese culture isn't sufficient enough. The biggest problem to the storytelling is the attempt to blend and use old Japanese, modern Japanese, and modern english words and terms to tell the story. Very frustrating for me to see other characters keep calling the mc Miura-kun, as if he's a high school boy in shounen novel. Also, his sister (Very shounen sister, she has all the traits) calling him nii-san and nii-chan instead of Aniue or Onii-sama/san (It actually should be Tadakata-Onii-sama/san, because she has another older brother, especially when all three of them are presented). These details are important, at least I deem them to be when the Author expects us to learn the archaic Japanese words for 'spearman' and 'archer'. If you want to be that authentic, you need to walk the whole nine yards, not using english pound for draw weight, and definitely not having these Japanese characters talk like modern people. This breaks the story for me, more than anything else. I'm very critical when I comment, especially when I recognize that the Author is competent. Mark twain once said "The difference between the right word and the almost right word is really a large matter – it is the difference between the lightning and the lightning bug.", and this sums up my feeling of this novel. I know that the story will get better, and it's actually top-tier when you compared to other webnovels, but please for the love of all things holy and good, be more careful with details. This later part of comment is just nitpicking: The mc is typical, in the way a genius mc in webnovel is. The achilles's heel of writing this type of mc is that he's expected to be very good with science, and anytime he isn't, that breaks the reading experience. The most glaring example is from Ch.1 when he tried to explain the time-traveling conundrum: Yes, sentience is weightless, but it has mass. The different between weight and mass is basic science. This is Ch.1, and I already doubt the mc intelligent, and my prejudice against him being a genius has formed. So his subsequent actions will be question every time they make no sense. It's one of the reasons I dread genius mc, and it turned me away from the story when I read this kind of sloppiness. You can't be a technological genius when the A.I. you created—after it evolved to its v.1000, self-claimed as the peak of technology, and even capable of time-traveling—still don't have a 'please confirm option'. To put it into perspective, even the Gameboy version of Pokemon has this option when you select your first Pokemon. That game is sold in 1995, when we still listen to our music through cassette tape, and I can say for certain though it has entertain a whole generation of mankind, it sure hasn't reach the peak of technology yet. Also, I don't think the Sengoku period is the time for peacefully raising your family, the only thought I've when reading this was, 'The mc and the A.I., they aren't that intelligent, aren't they?' This part is so contradicting to the mc character and his pet A.I., even truck-kun makes more sense.

altalt

A Time Traveller's Guide to Feudal Japan

Nick_Alderson

Liked by 86 people

LIKE

Replies9

NoxxTaotie
NoxxTaotieLv3NoxxTaotie

goddamn.

Supreme_Devil
Supreme_DevilLv4Supreme_Devil

You slathered him/her, welcome to the army.

Torren
TorrenLv3Torren

Well, my current theory is that it’s just all a simulation that the ai has propped up for the main character. The story in the beginning has some big plot armor for our main mc as well as in the later parts of the story, veers off the “realism” tag like a drunk man driving a car whilst having a bottle in each hand. It gets all “he’s the chosen one” and chi attacks with the monks. The writing quality also gets worse from way better than webnovel writers to just a tad better than webnovel writers.

amaturewriter
amaturewriterLv4amaturewriter

This is the greatest review i've ever read.

Mc_Fly
Mc_FlyLv13Mc_Fly

damm

Lorist_Norton
Lorist_NortonLv5Lorist_Norton

Burn!!!

CivilizedLaeyioun
CivilizedLaeyiounLv2CivilizedLaeyioun

Why you gotta reply like that guys?! I, for one, enjoy it even when this comment is clearly right in some points. I just gotta say, if you see this author, then please just take this criticism as a challenge to improve upon this work of yours so no one would say these kind of things again. I am invested in the book and it's because the writing is better in some parts that introspective readers like us are conversely disappointed by falling just a bit short of the potential greatness it surely has. I am certain if you address these issues in your own approach then you have a high chance of earning our satisfaction and wholehearted praise 😉👌

Chickenman_manz
Chickenman_manzLv3Chickenman_manz

As long as the novel is good all the minor details can be ignored, or just read fantasy novels where nothing makes sense and can still go on(that is unless the author is that bad and you have no idea what’s happening).

Noirit_K
Noirit_KLv4Noirit_K

Not gonna lie, I just read the whole comment without leaving anything