webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of fat_mermaid in Chat Group For Magicians

Review detail

fat_mermaid
fat_mermaidLv54yrfat_mermaid

I don't mean to send hate to the author, just making a constructive criticism, so don't be too violent and radical to comment, please. The author is very inexperienced, it seems to me a version of Cultivation Chat Group, but with magic instead of cultivation, but not so well written. When we read CCG, we are pleased to see the growth of the character, both in power scale and persona. As much as some mcs become forets and gain power, it should not be written as something so easy and explicit, there is no sense of satisfaction reading something like this. Come for free, if I can explain it that way. The dialogues seem very artificial too, just like the plot, it is a continuous dump of situations, the text has no flow, when you read something and feel that the text is fluid it is wonderful, unfortunately it does not happen here. There is no assimilation of the facts, in the matter of falling over and the MC easily and naturally accepting the situations, we do not have the process of adapting and digesting things as in GCC. I'm not going to talk about side portraits, because building the MC itself is problematic, very superficial (and no, adding a drama about it wouldn't make any improvements. The point is, we don't have a well-built character, with the psychological and differentiations, a A very good example would be the construction of Lord of Mysteries messages, this is really a very good one, use for reference). I feel no planning in writing and plot. Always keep in mind the elements of textuality: Coherence, Cohesion, Informativity, Intentionality, Acceptability, Situationality, and Intertextuality. Always review what is written and try to improve. Read a lot, because it helps, not just novels, because the construction of novels is not exemplary so to speak, I say really good book works, it helps a lot. The development of the characters must be done carefully too, try to imagine their characters and other books and novels, I can understand that there is a mind behind certain characters, as if they were a person, in others it is very superficial, sometimes Some authors and novels (many actually) tend to project themselves on the characters, especially the main ones, you are the author, not the characters, know this and create something really believable. Characters will never be the same, differentiate them and work on each other, let them grow during the narrative, mature is necessary, if not, there is a problem. The construction and actions of society and the world must be taken into account, cultural and personal habits, beliefs, religion, customs, prejudices, sexuality and gender, ways of thinking (besides that they change and are shaped by other ietns as well) . There is a lot of work, a lot of improvement to do. The novel was not to my liking and lacked in quality, I am sorry, but this is so that others do not spend time on something that will not be useful, as it was not for me. There was no real criticism when I looked at the comments, so I had to read to find out. More criticism is needed (better than mine and well written reviews by readers in all the nines, so that we can evaluate better than comments on how we liked it, love it, exp, thank you and comments that don't really appeal to us that we are looking for something solid to take as a reference). Very annoying to write this, but I felt I should. I realize my comment was not as well written as it should have been, but I was tired. Sorry if I offended anyone, but I don't feel sorry for the message.

altalt

Chat Group For Magicians

Kyosei

Liked by 19 people

LIKE

Replies5

Kyosei
KyoseiAuthorKyosei

Yeah, I know. You see, I am not experienced in writing this novel and I barely have time with all the novels I am writing. I know it was a noobish one to boot and I am sorry. But still, thanks for the review because even though it's a low rating, you expressed your opinion and all the flaws this novel has. I am quite a busy person and I barely have time to do research on some stuff so please bear with me in the meantime because I am still learning the ropes. Still, I appreciate what you have said since its not just about low rating without any constructive criticism.

fat_mermaid
fat_mermaidLv5fat_mermaid

I'm really sorry if I hurt you and hurt your feelings. I hope you improve your writing over the course of this novel and others you write in the future, good luck and happy new year! I'm rooting for you, dear Author.

Kyosei:Yeah, I know. You see, I am not experienced in writing this novel and I barely have time with all the novels I am writing. I know it was a noobish one to boot and I am sorry. But still, thanks for the review because even though it's a low rating, you expressed your opinion and all the flaws this novel has. I am quite a busy person and I barely have time to do research on some stuff so please bear with me in the meantime because I am still learning the ropes. Still, I appreciate what you have said since its not just about low rating without any constructive criticism.
Kyosei
KyoseiAuthorKyosei

Happy new year too and god bless

ArashiTenebris
ArashiTenebrisLv5ArashiTenebris

I have some writing information I like to share with you here (this is only for research to improve, not mean to force you to write in a certain way) https://***.royalroadl.com/forums/thread/98657 (I do sometimes update new material and tips here including in the comment of the post, there are new material near the end of my second post, it have #NEW tag with it This site can help you find the topic you are not clear in writing here (though he tend to make it into a rigid rule, which is bad for the creative writing, so take a grain of salt and only for reference some idea) https://curiosityquills.com/limyaael/ (this is a website with tons of different topics covered for writers, from female protagonists that don't suck, how to avoid bad infor dump to creating languages.) And finally there are some youtube channel like this that could help give some idea (in this case, how 'not' to write those topic) PLOTTING A STORY - Terrible Writing Advice https://***.youtube.com/watch?v=TTZEFGvMH0k

Kyosei:Happy new year too and god bless
Kyosei
KyoseiAuthorKyosei

Hey, thanks for the info, I will check it up once I am available.

ArashiTenebris:I have some writing information I like to share with you here (this is only for research to improve, not mean to force you to write in a certain way) https://***.royalroadl.com/forums/thread/98657 (I do sometimes update new material and tips here including in the comment of the post, there are new material near the end of my second post, it have #NEW tag with it This site can help you find the topic you are not clear in writing here (though he tend to make it into a rigid rule, which is bad for the creative writing, so take a grain of salt and only for reference some idea) https://curiosityquills.com/limyaael/ (this is a website with tons of different topics covered for writers, from female protagonists that don't suck, how to avoid bad infor dump to creating languages.) And finally there are some youtube channel like this that could help give some idea (in this case, how 'not' to write those topic) PLOTTING A STORY - Terrible Writing Advice https://***.youtube.com/watch?v=TTZEFGvMH0k