Review Detail of VardorStormDragon in I Might Be A Fake Cultivator
Review detail
You need to be aware before reading this that it is a very low brow comedy. This best way I can describe this is "A wannabe Marx brother clone does Xianxia" or something like that. For some reason I was expecting a normally intelligent MC forced or tricked into taking a somewhat broken or difficult system and working through the comedic problems in order to transform it onto a somewhat OP system. What I got was totally different. Sorry I don't consider constant ludicrous stupidity as funny nor do I classify it as comedy. Since this is only about stupidity, I find it to be just that, stupid. However I have to say, if you enjoy that sort of thing then you will probably find this to be absolutely hilarious and I highly recommend this to you. In that case you should consider this a 5-star review. If you have a low tolerance for abject stupidity then stay far away from this. Since I am in this category, my personal rating is less than 1-star and my advice is avoid at all costs. What experience you have will depend upon what direction your sense of humor heads in.
I Might Be A Fake Cultivator
Bright Moonlight Frost On The Ground
Liked by 179 people
LIKEReplies41
This review is pretty one sided, you don't mention the world building, the character development nor any important factors that make up a novel. You fake your reviews and make a huge bias in order to lure people into reading your review. Well I hope you're happy in lowing the stars for this novel because although the comedy was different, not everyone likes to know that the comedy they like is in your words, "stupid".
What world building? And character development?? Lacking. The world is big and in the heaven realm. Thatâs all we know. The people??? The MC is an idiot, becomes friends with another idiot over a fight. Girl next door is nice but we know nothing about her. His review is pretty accurate.
WatermelonBandit:This review is pretty one sided, you don't mention the world building, the character development nor any important factors that make up a novel. You fake your reviews and make a huge bias in order to lure people into reading your review. Well I hope you're happy in lowing the stars for this novel because although the comedy was different, not everyone likes to know that the comedy they like is in your words, "stupid".
You must either be someone who is an underage or one of those "glorious" chinese "50 cent army" member. He said it's **** because author tries to make stupid jokes out of stupid situations. I fully agree to his review. Nobody cares about world building and character development if the PLOT itself is stupid or ludicrous.
WatermelonBandit:This review is pretty one sided, you don't mention the world building, the character development nor any important factors that make up a novel. You fake your reviews and make a huge bias in order to lure people into reading your review. Well I hope you're happy in lowing the stars for this novel because although the comedy was different, not everyone likes to know that the comedy they like is in your words, "stupid".
This is a parody of most cultivation novels... If you liked One punch man.... Then this is the novel for you. Don't believe the one star ratings.... Those are just snobbish pricks who think their tastes are superior to others just because they read more "intellectual" novels. They think they are above others. I say each has their own taste. Just because some like trashy cultivation harem novels as opposed to liking the more serious ones.... Doesn't make they have **** taste.
Well it is true that my review is one sided, but that is deliberate. I could have mentioned that the world building was nonexistent and I could have mentioned that the character development was nonexistent. However I am of the opinion that focusing on these things would be misleading and missing the point of the novel. In my opinion the whole point of the novel is the comedy/parody of a generic xianxia setting. Since there was nothing in this novel other than the comedy, that is the point I focused on. Not sure what you mean by fake reviews. Do you think I have presented someone else's view and not my own? Or do you think I am not professionally qualified to review this novel? Since you don't seem to realize it, let me be the one to inform you that this IS NOT a professional forum of editors and book reviewers. It is a forum of READERS. That means these reviews are a polling of the opinions and impressions of the readers. As a person who has read this novel, I am qualified to write my opinion of what I have read. The only fake reviews would be the ones by those who did not actually read the novel. For example: "I like the concept, please follow thru. 5-star." "I love the cover picture, I plan to read this. 5-star." "I hate the MC's name. It is the villains name from my favorite novel. I will never read this. 1-star."
WatermelonBandit:This review is pretty one sided, you don't mention the world building, the character development nor any important factors that make up a novel. You fake your reviews and make a huge bias in order to lure people into reading your review. Well I hope you're happy in lowing the stars for this novel because although the comedy was different, not everyone likes to know that the comedy they like is in your words, "stupid".
I like one punch man and obsolutely hate this novel :/ Like the review say, there is a difference between true comedy/parody and something that just feel stupid
constant1521:This is a parody of most cultivation novels... If you liked One punch man.... Then this is the novel for you. Don't believe the one star ratings.... Those are just snobbish pricks who think their tastes are superior to others just because they read more "intellectual" novels. They think they are above others. I say each has their own taste. Just because some like trashy cultivation harem novels as opposed to liking the more serious ones.... Doesn't make they have **** taste.
While I haven't read this, I do know One Punch Man has comedy that is not stupid. It has world building. The main and side characters all have a backstory. And there's character development. Those are the things that make One Punch Man so popular despite the fact that so many people hate op main character's. And others have already said this novel lacks the things that made OPM great. It's not just about comedy
constant1521:This is a parody of most cultivation novels... If you liked One punch man.... Then this is the novel for you. Don't believe the one star ratings.... Those are just snobbish pricks who think their tastes are superior to others just because they read more "intellectual" novels. They think they are above others. I say each has their own taste. Just because some like trashy cultivation harem novels as opposed to liking the more serious ones.... Doesn't make they have **** taste.
This seems like a one side review but atleast he read the novel and reviewed it's content and said why he didn't like it which is also a review he even went into detail of why he didn't like and his right if like like stupid humor this is for you(me) and if you don't I don't think you will like it. I like stupid humor so I'll read it.
It's quite funny seeing everyone complaining about him rating the novel with just a star. He does points out major flaw of this novel. I had to stop myself from face palming after i read the first few chapters. So I whole heartedly agree with the OP. About the rating? We all can agree that Qidian's rating system is broken, one sided and utterly useless. I believe that more than 95% of the reviews just contain unintelligible gibberish, emotes and one line statements which are supposed to tell us everything. Any true review, if ever written, is soon submerged under the flood of nonsense reviews. Btw, most of the novels hosted here, barely have an average 3.5 star rating. Basically, Qidian is just flooding the market with mediocre novels. Anyway, I never see people complaining about the 5 star ratings which have well... Nothing. Hypocrites. Sorry for the rant!
omg I totally agree People get butthurt cuz of one-star reviews and they're even deleted while five-star ones which basically have no context and many of them are there just to get the exp, no one cares about them
Heretoc:It's quite funny seeing everyone complaining about him rating the novel with just a star. He does points out major flaw of this novel. I had to stop myself from face palming after i read the first few chapters. So I whole heartedly agree with the OP. About the rating? We all can agree that Qidian's rating system is broken, one sided and utterly useless. I believe that more than 95% of the reviews just contain unintelligible gibberish, emotes and one line statements which are supposed to tell us everything. Any true review, if ever written, is soon submerged under the flood of nonsense reviews. Btw, most of the novels hosted here, barely have an average 3.5 star rating. Basically, Qidian is just flooding the market with mediocre novels. Anyway, I never see people complaining about the 5 star ratings which have well... Nothing. Hypocrites. Sorry for the rant!
omg I totally agree People get butthurt cuz of one-star reviews and they're even deleted while five-star ones which basically have no context and many of them are there just to get the exp, no one cares about them
Heretoc:It's quite funny seeing everyone complaining about him rating the novel with just a star. He does points out major flaw of this novel. I had to stop myself from face palming after i read the first few chapters. So I whole heartedly agree with the OP. About the rating? We all can agree that Qidian's rating system is broken, one sided and utterly useless. I believe that more than 95% of the reviews just contain unintelligible gibberish, emotes and one line statements which are supposed to tell us everything. Any true review, if ever written, is soon submerged under the flood of nonsense reviews. Btw, most of the novels hosted here, barely have an average 3.5 star rating. Basically, Qidian is just flooding the market with mediocre novels. Anyway, I never see people complaining about the 5 star ratings which have well... Nothing. Hypocrites. Sorry for the rant!
constant1521:This is a parody of most cultivation novels... If you liked One punch man.... Then this is the novel for you. Don't believe the one star ratings.... Those are just snobbish pricks who think their tastes are superior to others just because they read more "intellectual" novels. They think they are above others. I say each has their own taste. Just because some like trashy cultivation harem novels as opposed to liking the more serious ones.... Doesn't make they have **** taste.
constant1521:This is a parody of most cultivation novels... If you liked One punch man.... Then this is the novel for you. Don't believe the one star ratings.... Those are just snobbish pricks who think their tastes are superior to others just because they read more "intellectual" novels. They think they are above others. I say each has their own taste. Just because some like trashy cultivation harem novels as opposed to liking the more serious ones.... Doesn't make they have **** taste.
It's not like he's a professional reviewer. This is pretty much the comments section of the novel. Only it has actual comments rather than stupid emojis and worthless "great chapter" comments. The review is perfectly fair and valid.
WatermelonBandit:This review is pretty one sided, you don't mention the world building, the character development nor any important factors that make up a novel. You fake your reviews and make a huge bias in order to lure people into reading your review. Well I hope you're happy in lowing the stars for this novel because although the comedy was different, not everyone likes to know that the comedy they like is in your words, "stupid".
constant1521:This is a parody of most cultivation novels... If you liked One punch man.... Then this is the novel for you. Don't believe the one star ratings.... Those are just snobbish pricks who think their tastes are superior to others just because they read more "intellectual" novels. They think they are above others. I say each has their own taste. Just because some like trashy cultivation harem novels as opposed to liking the more serious ones.... Doesn't make they have **** taste.
