webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of David_Drake in Reaper (Being Re-written)

Review detail

David_Drake
David_DrakeLv44yrDavid_Drake

Wasted potential. You had the cool dementor story going on but when he eats Sirius's soul he turns into a freaking toddler. He finds a secret room, becomes a 10 year old boy by constructing a body in 2 months and some how escapes the prison. Then you just had to make Sirius's soul influence the MC so much that now this 17yr toddler is going to protect the black family in his name because the MC feels bad for devouring him.... Gah such a disappointment in writing.

altalt

Reaper (Being Re-written)

SykoNex

Liked by 120 people

LIKE

Replies23

SykoNex
SykoNexAuthorSykoNex

You must have been a real mature savant at 16 damn bro that's sick.

David_Drake
David_DrakeLv4David_Drake

Sarcasm isn't your strong point. Accept the criticism for what it is.

SykoNex:You must have been a real mature savant at 16 damn bro that's sick.
SykoNex
SykoNexAuthorSykoNex

Damn I was actually about to delete comment this after I clicked your profile. I realized you really don't have any good opinions... on like any novel. But oh well lol.

David_Drake:Sarcasm isn't your strong point. Accept the criticism for what it is.
David_Drake
David_DrakeLv4David_Drake

And you are bias on leaving all those xp 5 star reviews. At least I'm honest with my self

SykoNex:Damn I was actually about to delete comment this after I clicked your profile. I realized you really don't have any good opinions... on like any novel. But oh well lol.
DDax
DDaxLv5DDax

I checked to he rly does not have any hahaha

SykoNex:Damn I was actually about to delete comment this after I clicked your profile. I realized you really don't have any good opinions... on like any novel. But oh well lol.
David_Drake
David_DrakeLv4David_Drake

sorry not sorry :(

DDax:I checked to he rly does not have any hahaha
Seraphy64
Seraphy64Lv10Seraphy64

I'd rather see honest reviews than the mindless 5 star spam you see on so many fics. And his review isn't wrong here either. The fic had a lot of potential, but I don't see it living up to it really. That said it's still better than 70% of the other fics I've seen on the site.

Ilumie
IlumieLv11Ilumie

I didn't even read any of this but I upvoted your review out of principle since bad review deleter are just pathetic

David_Drake:And you are bias on leaving all those xp 5 star reviews. At least I'm honest with my self
David_Drake
David_DrakeLv4David_Drake

Thanks for the support. My comments are usually showing some of my salt for people who do things like that.

Ilumie:I didn't even read any of this but I upvoted your review out of principle since bad review deleter are just pathetic
Blake_Chronos
Blake_ChronosLv3Blake_Chronos

I agree. I felt the same when I read it. I don't get why the 'author' is angry at you. He didn't even wrote the novel. This is a translation.

David_Drake
David_DrakeLv4David_Drake

Wow you serious?

Blake_Chronos:I agree. I felt the same when I read it. I don't get why the 'author' is angry at you. He didn't even wrote the novel. This is a translation.
DarkImmortal_Intel
DarkImmortal_IntelLv14DarkImmortal_Intel

Ya

Aurafyre
AurafyreLv13Aurafyre

Is this really a translation, I looked and couldn't find anything at all suggesting that?

DarkImmortal_Intel:Ya
KumThrone
KumThroneLv2KumThrone

Thank you for saving my brain from reading such a disappointing book.

Pokoj11
Pokoj11Lv4Pokoj11

He is right so wasted potential to do side kick....

Thenoicemaster
ThenoicemasterLv3Thenoicemaster

Really you just made me feel like rewriting this fanfic Hey could you check out my fanfic I just posted 2 chapters and Id like a few reviews To see if theres a direction I can take in the stroy And your cRitisism is Seems better than some people giving me five star review I gave myself some critique I want critica to yell at me whats wrong with my atory so I can think of things to make my story more fun for thenfew pwople who checked it out

Airelda
AireldaLv4Airelda

Aren't the stories with the ORIGINAL tag on their pic supposed to be written by those who upload it?

David_Drake
David_DrakeLv4David_Drake

No. You're able to translate someone's work if you have permission. However, people play around with this terminology by pirating people's works for some cheap go fund me cash. Also, this should be a fanfic considering the 'author' is using the HP universe to write his story.

Airelda:Aren't the stories with the ORIGINAL tag on their pic supposed to be written by those who upload it?
ShoShoShoSho
ShoShoShoShoLv3ShoShoShoSho

phaha what an idiot

SykoNex:Damn I was actually about to delete comment this after I clicked your profile. I realized you really don't have any good opinions... on like any novel. But oh well lol.
Nathanielornsby
NathanielornsbyLv14Nathanielornsby

I understand the premise and honestly I haven’t read enough of the story to pass judgment but for the stuff I have seen I’ve liked wel apart from a few things but thats due yo personal reasons like I love how he was a dememtor but when you made him human It just put me off. 😂

SykoNex:Damn I was actually about to delete comment this after I clicked your profile. I realized you really don't have any good opinions... on like any novel. But oh well lol.