Unforgiven

Sam is listening to the television news program intently, TV says "Sources said prosecutors were getting closer to a decision on whether to charge the actor. But they adamantly denied that any prosecution was in any..." Dean asks "What are you watching?" Sam says "Just trying to catch up. So...Mel Gibson really took a turn this past year, huh?" Dean says "Or he's possessed. Seriously, think about it. So, I just got off the blower with Bobby." Sam asks "Oh, yeah? You got anything else on this, uh, 'Mother of All' thing?" Dean says "Uh, no, nothing solid. He says it's quiet." Sam's cell phone dings, announcing a new text "Quiet like quiet or quiet like too quiet?" Dean says "When is it ever just quiet?" Sam says "RightSam checks his cell phone and sees he has received a text message of coordinates "Hmm." Sarah asks "What? What are these, coordinates? Who's it from?" Sam says "I have no idea." Sam looks the coordinates up on a map and Dean asks "Well?" Sam says "Uh, Bristol, Rhode Island, where three women disappeared in the last week. Apparently, the, uh, victims seemed to vanish into thin air." Dean says "Could be something. Who's the text from?" Sam says "I don't know. It just kept ringing." Sarah asks "What's that about?" Sam says "Could be another hunter looking for backup, throwing us a case? Who knows how many hunters I even met, working with the Campbells, you know? But I think we should go."

Dean says "Whoa, wait. We're just gonna drop everything?" Sam says "Dude, two minutes ago, you weren't doing anything." Dean says "You got mysterious coordinates from a mysterious Mr. "X," leading to a mysterious town? That doesn't throw up red flags to you?" Sam says "I don't know. Maybe. But that doesn't mean we can just ignore a bunch of missing girls. Right?" Dean says "Okay. We'll check it out. But if things get squirrelly, we dump out, okay?" Sam says "Yeah."

Inside the Impala Nighttime, Sarah, Sam and Dean drive by a sign welcoming them to Bristol, Sam flashes back briefly to when he was last there and Dean says "What?" Sam says "Nothing." Inside the Restaurant Daytime, Dean looking through missing persons leaflets "Well, freak's got a type—brunettes. Whoa. This one's got a little bit of a wild side. It's all in the eyes, Sam and Sarah See it?" Sarah says "All right, well, aside from your little deep insight there, these women actually have nothing in common—different jobs, different friends, different everything. So, what's the connection?" Dean says "I don't know. Why don't you figure that out? I'm gonna go hit the poop deck." Dean heads to the bathroom, marked with the sign 'poop deck'

Woman approaches Sarah and Sam she looks to Sam and she says "Agent Roark? It's good to see you again." Sam says "It is." Woman says "Oh, you remember my husband?" Gestures to her husband and Sam says "Right." Woman says "Don." Sam says "Of course, right. Um, hi." Woman says "So, you're back 'cause it started again, right—the disappearances?" Sam says "Uh, yeah. Yeah, right. Um...So, if either of you two hear anything, please let us know." The woman asks "Where's your partner? The big bald guy? Agent Wynand, right?" Sam says "Agent Wynand, of course. Well—" Dean interrupts and says "Sex rehab. Yeah, you've heard of plushies, right?" Sam says "This is, uh—this is my new partners." Sarah shakes both of their hands and Dean says "Hi. Pleasure. shakes the woman's hand "How you doing? Hi. shakes Don's hand Uh, so, Agent, we should, uh—" Sam says "Yeah. Yeah, of course." Woman says "Of course. Uh, nice chatting with you, Agent Roark." Sam says "You too." Woman touches Sam's shoulder, and he flashes back to when they last met. It seems they had sex in a bathroom In Sam's Memory " Cuff me." Dean says "What was that? She just cougar-eyed you." Sam says "I think Samuel and I have worked a case in this town." Sarah says "You think? Dean shows Sam a polaroid he got from the wall of customers who won the restaurant's eating challenge, which shows Sam and Samuel in the background, behind a winner "Come on. Let's get the hell out of here."

Abandoned House Daytime, Dean asks "Hey, come on. Hop to, would you?" Sam says "We can't go, Dean and Sarah." Sarah says "Uh, yeah, we can." Sam says "No, listen—five guys went missing a year ago. They never found the bodies. I mean, that's got to be the job me and Samuel worked, right?" Dean says "Great. What difference does it make?" Sam says "A year ago, five guys go missing, and—and now suddenly all these women go missing. Something's here. So either we just didn't stop it, or we only thought we did." Sarah asks "Okay, but why the gender bend, huh? First it's dudes. Now it's chicks? That's a totally different M.O." Sam says "I don't know. Who knows? The point is, something's still here." Dean says "Great. We'll call Bobby. He can deal with it." Sam asks "Why? We can deal with it." Dean says "Are you serious? Sam, there is a reason that hunters don't hit the same town over again—'cause we have a habit of leaving messes behind." Sam says "Right. I agree." Dean says "One of dad's rules -- you never use the same crapper twice." Sam says "Everyone uses the same crapper twice."

Dean says "Not us. You know what I mean." Sam says "Okay, look—this creature is still walking around 'cause of me, right? I mean, I let it go. Dad also said, "you finish what you start." Okay, I get it." Dean asks "Do you?" Sam says "Yes. You're afraid I'll stroll down memory lane and I'll kick this wall in my head so hard, Hell comes flooding through, right? And then all of a sudden, I'm some drooling mess on the floor." Dean says "It's not a joke." Sam says "Okay. I know. But listen—what's happening here right now—it's because I messed up somehow, in some big way. So every person who gets taken, every person who dies—that's on me. I have to stop it. And you'd do the same thing." Dean says "All right me and Sarah follow up with the brunettes. You see what you get from the cops."

Inside Nicole's House, Dean says "So, you and Nicole were roommates for a long time." Nicole's Roommate says "Since college, but we've been best friends forever." Dean says "Hmm." Nicole's Roommate asks "his whole thing's really surreal. Are you any closer to finding her, or...?" Sarah says "We're doing everything we can. Now, you were with Nicole the night she went missing. Did she say anything?" Nicole's Roommate says "Nothing. It's like I told the cops -- I wish there was something." Dean finds a business card from "Agent H. Roark" and asks "Where'd you get this?" Nicole's Roommate says "Oh, Nicole got that from that FBI guy." Dean says "Agent Roark. About -- about yea high?" Nicole's roommate says "Yeah, that was him. One of the men that disappeared last year lived in our building." Dean says "Right." Nicole's Roommate says " So Agent Roark was asking us all questions about it, I guess." Sarah says "You guess? So he -- he came by here?" Nicole's Roommate says "Oh, he came -- by a few times." Dean asks " Did he? To, uh...Speak to Nicole." Nicole's Roommate says "Right." Dean asks "And how would you...Characterize their relationship?"Nicole's Roommate says "Relationship? No, they weren't having a --" Sarah asks " just the -- the -- the tone or the nature of their conversation." Nicole's Roommate says "Well...Loud. And...Athletic."

Sheriff's Station, Sam is walking toward the entrance of the building, when he is spotted by Sheriff Atkins aiming gun at Sam " Hold it right there! Stop right there! Hands where I can see them! Man, you are dumb as a sack of hair --coming back here after what you did?." Sam says "Look, there's been a misunderstanding here." Sheriff Atkins says "You are not a damn Agent, okay? The FBI never heard of you." Sam says "Just listen." Sheriff Atkins asks "Where are the bodies? Mothers want to bury their loved ones." Sam says "I don't know." Sheriff Atkins asks "Where's Sheriff Dobbs?" Sam says "I don't know." Sheriff Atkins says "You run out of town soaked in blood --Oh, and you bash my brains in to do it -- and you really expect me to buy that?" Sam says "Look, would you believe that I don't remember anything?" Sheriff Atkins says "No. But good luck selling it to the judge." later that night Brenna Dobbs approaches Sam's cell and she asks "What happened to my husband?" Sam says " I-I don't know." Brenna says "Don't lie to me. I know who you are, Sam. I know what you do." Sam asks "What? You do?" Sam remembers talking to Sheriff Ray Dobbs and Brenna, his wife lat time he was in town with Samuel and Sheriff Ray Dobbs says " Let me get this straight -- you're not feds. You actually hunt things." Samuel says "We know how it sounds." Sheriff Dobbs says "I'm not sure you do."

Sam says "You saw those crime scenes, Roy. You really think something human could have taken those guys?" Brenna says " What you're saying -- it's impossible." Sam says "You know, I'm sorry, I-I don't understand what she's got to do with any of this." Sheriff Dobbs says "She's my wife. She works with me at the sheriff's station. You tell something like this to me, you tell it to her, too. All right, what do you need us to do? Back to Present Day, Sam says "Your husband -- he's the sheriff." Brenna says "as the sheriff, until he vanished... And you vanished. What was I supposed to think? T-that thing got him, or that you killed him? I just want to know what happened." Sam says "So do I. Believe me. Something happened to me. I have no memory of being here, ever." Brenna asks "What is this, "Days of Our Lives"? You're telling me you have some sort of amnesia?"

Sam says "If I knew any of this, would I have stepped foot into this station? I'm sorry. I-I don't even know your name." Brenna says " If this is some sort of a game, you're either incredibly clever or incredibly stupid." Sam says "I'm telling the truth. Look... I don't know what happened to your husband. But I can find out." Brenna asks "How?" Sam says "If you really know me, then you know that's my job." Brenna asks "You really don't remember?" Sam says "No. I really don't." Brenna says "I'm Brenna Dobbs." Sam says "Brenna...I'm sorry about what happened to your husband. But I can find answers...Just not from in here." Brenna unlocks the cell door and releases Sam "Come on. Help me find some rope. If it's gonna look like a break-out, you're gonna need to tie me up." Inside Don's House, Debbie looking at her husband, Don, while getting a glass of boxed wine from the fridge "What? The boxed stuff doesn't get better with age, Don." she heads to the basement, and something from under the stairs grabs her "Ahh! Aah!"

In Abandoned House, Sam hears someone approaching, draws his gun and waits by the door and Dean says " Hey, Sam. So, how does it feel to be a fugitive again? Hate to say "I told you so."" Sam says "You love to say "I told you so."" Dean says "Actually, you're right -- I do love to say "I told you so." So, me and Sarah found out something on, uh, "crazy eyes McGee." Turns out you two knew each other." Sam says "What?" Sarah says "Biblically, we just spoke to her roommate we got to say, man -- you really got around. I mean, soulless or not I'm actually kind of impressed." Police Scanner "Eight Sierra Papa. Got a 1057, 1100 block of Hope Street. Over." Sam says "Missing person -- another one." Dean says "Okay, all right me and Sarah will go and you stay here." Sam says "Yeah. Fine." Dean says "Sam?" Sam says "What?" Dean says "Stay here." Sam says "Fine! Go!"

Don and Debbie's House, Dean says " Listen, thank you for your time. We're on it." Don says "Yeah, thanks." Dean calls Sam's phone and gets his voicemail " This is Sam. Leave a message." Dean says " Sam, answer the phone, damn it we found the connection between the missing chicks. They all banged the same dude -- You. It's you, Sam. The texts, the victims, all of it -- it's a trap for you. Call me back." Inside Dob's House, Brenna finds Sam and is startled, Sam says "I'm sorry. I'm sorry." Brenna says "You can't be here!" Sam says " Okay, p-please just listen." Brenna asks "What happened to Debbie Harris?" Sam says "Debbie?" Brenna says "I let you out, and she's just gone." Sam says "And y-you think I did something to her?" Brenna says " I don't know what to think." Sam says "Look, um, I need your help." Brenna says "Are you kidding?" Sam says "I need the case files that your husband made about the disappearances last year." Brenna says "So go to the station and find it." Sam says "It's not there. I broke in and I looked, and it's gone and I have a theory about who might have it. Look, we both want the same thing here, Brenna. I promise. We want to find out what happened last year, and we want to stop what's happening right now."

Brenna says "The file's upstairs. I'll be right back." Sam has a flashback of Samuel "Let's go!" Sam remembers the last time he was in Brenna's house with Samuel "So, you guys just travel all the time? I mean, you just pick up and go? Doesn't that get hard?" Samuel says "Not when you're young -- it's great. Once you got a family, it's a little tougher. Deanna got pregnant, and we didn't know what we were gonna do. But Mary was...She was a blessing." Samuel notices his beer is empty and Roy says "There's more in the garage." Samuel says "Ah, listen, you sit. I'll get it." Brenna to Sam "He misses her. You know, at least you two have each other." Sam says "Well, Samuel wasn't really around when I was a kid. We have more of a, uh, business relationship." Brenna asks "Uh, do you have any other family?" Sam says "Family just slows you down." Present Day, Brenna says "Sam? Sam?! You all right?" Sam says "Yeah. Um...All right, let's see what you have."

They start going through the case file, Sam remembers more In a Restaurant, Samuel says "Best guess --it came from an Arachne." Sam asks "You ever seen one?" Samuel says " No one has -- not outside of Crete, not for about 2,000 years." Sam asks "Then what do we even know about them?" Samuel says "Zip. Just a bunch of guesses and a blurry picture on the side of a Greek vase." Restaurant Patron says "Yeah!" Waitresses says " Yo ho sea captain!" they place a pirate hat on patron's head, and snap a polaroid and Sam says "So, I gather we got no clue how to kill this thing, huh?" Samuel says " I guess we just go at it till something sticks." Sam says "Well, I got an idea of where it might be, at least. So far, all the vics have been men in their 30s, and they've all gone missing within a 2-mile radius." Samuel says " So we just get out and kick bushes." Sam says "No, that'd be a waste of time. I mean, it's all suburban sprawl -- hundreds of houses, at least. It could be anywhere."

Samuel looking at where Sam is pointing on the map "Lonely Pines Park." Sam says " Yeah. I say we make this thing come to us." Samuel asks "How do we do that?" Present time Sam asks "Hey, um, Brenna, do you mind if I -- if I, um, borrow all this stuff for a couple hours?" Brenna says "Um, okay, I guess. You really don't remember Roy, do you? He was a good man. I've made peace that he's dead. I have. But I just want to know what happened." Sam says " I'm sure he died a hero." Sam exits the house and checks his voicemail there's one voicemail and it's from Dean "Sam, answer the phone,damn it we found the connection between the missing chicks. They all banged the same dude --You. It's you, Sam. The texts, the victims, all of it -- it's a trap for you. Call me back." Sam transfixed by a spiderweb, is surprised when he is tapped on the shoulder and levels his gun "Whoa. Whoa." Sam says "I almost shot you both...Again, What the hell?" Dean says "We figured you'd come and talk to her. I told you to stay home, man. Did you get my message? Come on. We got to get you out of here. Let's go."

Inside Abandoned House, Sarah says " Well we know that this is a monster with opposable thumbs and unlimited text messaging, and we know that it wants to kill you specifically. Does that about cover it?" Sam says "It's an Arachne." Dean says "A what?" Sam says " I remembered." Dean says "You remembered? Y-- I'm sorry. Uh, what else have you remembered?" Sam says "Don't worry, all right? I-it's nothing to do with Hell." Dean says " Uh-huh. Not yet, anyway." Sam asks " What can I do, Dean? The stuff is just starting to come back, all right? Maybe it's natural." Dean says "We're leaving." Sam says "No, we can't." Sarah says "We are not the only hunters on the planet, okay? We can call Bobby. He and Rufus could come and wrap up." Sam asks "How? Like Dean said, it could be anybody, we got jack for leads." Dean says "We know that it hates you." Sam says "I know who did this. I just -- I can't remember." Dean says "I don't think you get the risk here, Sam." Sam says "Yes, I do." Sarah says " Really? You get that every time you scratch that wall, that you are playing Russian roulette?" Sam says "Sarah, Dean I get you're worried, okay? And I know what you think is gonna happen. But you know what? It will or it won't." Dean says "Sam---."

Sam interrupts and says "--look, I'm starting to think that -- that I might have done some bad stuff here, Dean. And so I don't care if it's dangerous. I have to set things right, 'cause I got a frigging soul now, and -- and it won't let me just walk away. I'm staying here and I need both of your help to back me up." Dean says "All right. Why not? Well, let's "memento" this thing, shall we?" They pin all the evidence they have up on the wall and Sam gets another flashback, Debbie asks " So, you're back 'cause it started again, right -- the disappearances?" Roy says "You're not feds. You actually hunt things." Brenna says "You really don't remember?" Dean says " I, uh, found something on "crazy eyes McGee." Turns out you two knew each other." Dean asks "You Okay?" Sam remembers, In a Restaurant, Sam on the phone "That's right. Yeah, Lonely Pines Park,one hour. Thanks, Roy. All right." Samuel asks "Are you sure about this?" Sam says "The Arachne's been snacking on mid-30s guys. We need bait that fits the demo. I'm too young. You're too old." Samuel says "9 and counting. I still think that we should have looped Roy in on the plan." Sam asks "Do we want a credible performance, or don't we?" Samuel says "But what if something goes wrong?" Sam says "Roy's a big boy. He'll be fine.Trust me." Samuel says "It's just... not the way I'm used to doing things." Sam says "Got it. Welcome to the future. Let's go."

Park, Sam says "Let's hope this thing's hungry." Roy attacked be arachne "Ugh! Aah!" Samuel says "Let's split up, look for him." Sam says "No, no, wait. It's too late." Samuel says "Let's go!" Sam says "They're gone, Samuel! Look -- it's okay. I turned on the G.P.S. on Roy's cell." Samuel says " In English, please." Sam says "We can track them back to wherever she goes." Samuel asks "So, what, Roy's just some redshirt to you, just spider bait?" Sam says "No, no, of course not. This is my back-up plan." Samuel says " My God, son, you're about as cold as they come. You know that?" Sam says "Let's go." Sam and Samuel follow the GPS back to where the Arachne is hiding - a large building by the docks, they find several men trapped in spider-webbing Samuel cutting through the webbing to reveal a man with glasses "Poor bastard." he web-trapped man gasps for air, and the other trapped victims do as well, they are all still alive and Roy says " Help me. I can't...Feel..." Sam says "Roy, hey, where is she? Sam is thrown back by Arachne, Arachne Sam from where he has fallen on the floor, kicks the arachne, and she staggers back "Ugh!" amuel shoots the arachne, and she throws him across the room, Sam slices off Arachne's head with a machete "Well, I guess decapitation works. Roy. You're gonna be okay. Just hang in. We're gonna get you some help. Listen, if we can get him to the hospital quick --"

Sam says "He can't be helped." Samuel says "What?" Sam says " I don't know about Arachne, but I do know about spiders. One brown recluse bite can kill you. This thing? Look at these guys -- that poison's eating them alive. They're just dead men walking." Samuel says to Sam "So, what are you saying?" Sam says " I'm saying we put him out of his misery." Sam draws the gun and Roy says "Sam...Please." Sam says "Killing this thing saved a lot of lives. We couldn't have done it without you." Roy says "No." Sam says "You're a hero Sam shoots Roy in the head, and continues to execute all the other victims "We can't just leave the bodies here. Get the gasoline." Back to current time, Sam says "I know what happened."

Brenna's House, Roy enters, but he looks like the Arachn Brenna says "Roy?" Roy says " I love you." Inside Abandoned House, Dean asks "What are you gonna say to Brenna?" Sam on the phone "Relax, Dean. Hey, Brenna, it's -- it's Sam. I'm just checking in. Yeah, of course I can swing by. Okay. Yeah. Bye." Sarah asks "What was that about?" Sam says "She wants me to swing by." Dean says "For?"Sam says "She said it's no big deal, but I can tell she's in deep trouble." Brenna's House Sam says "Sarah and Dean, back door." Dean says "Sam. Light's on in the shed. My spidey senses are tingling." Sam says "Shh." Brenna says "Sam?" Sam says "Brenna? Hey." Brenna says "What you did to Roy...Is it true?" Roy attacks Dean, then Sarah, and then Sam and grabs Sam by the throat and Roy says "Answer the question, Sam."

Roy has trapped Sam, Sarah and Dean in webbing "You got to admit I look good, Sam. Well, except for your little souvenir." Roy points to his forehead and the bullet sized scar there and Sam says "You win. I'm here. Let Brenna go. This has nothing to do with her." Roy says "You come back around, start hanging out with my wife, and you think this has nothing to do with her? But then...you thought I was out of the way, right? I got to say, you get a hell of a lot wrong, Sam, like that thing you threw me to. You thought it was here to feed." Sam says "She was here to breed." Roy says "Yeah. That thing was playing the mating game, and I guess I fit her profile...Me and all those other poor bastards. She bit us to turn us into what she was. By the time you pulled that trigger, I wasn't human. Not anymore. So bullets didn't hurt me much. Oh, and neither did fire. So after you left, well, we ran. Me -- I hid for months, nearly starved. But you know what kept me going? Every night, I dreamed about ripping your throat out. I thought I was sending you a neon sign. The text? Taking all those girls you screwed? I was kicking so much sand in your eye, I couldn't figure out why you weren't getting it! Then Bren tells me you've got brain damage. It's just too good." Sam asks "Where are they, Roy...the women?" Roy says " Scattered...In the wind. They're like me now. You killed one monster, you made so many more. Congratulations. The only question is, do I kill you...Or turn you?" Dean cuts himself free with a glass shard, and attacks Roy "Ugh." Roy throws Dean, and picks him up by the throat "No! Roy, stop!" Brenna frees Sam and Sam decapitates Roy, Dean goes and helps Sarah out of the web.

Dobb's House, Sam says "Look, I am so sorry. Brenna, I-I mean, I..." Brenna closes her door without ever turning to look at Sam, Abandoned House Dean asks "You okay?" Sam says "You were right. We shouldn't have come back here." Dean says "Well, you did kill uh...spider man." Sam says " So, you're suggesting what I did back there was a good thing?" Dean says "I'm just saying --" Sam says "What?" Dean says "Sam, y-y-you got to understand that all that crap last year -- all of it -- none of it was you." Sam says "Let's be crystal clear, okay? It was me." Sarah says "Well, can I get you anything?" Sam says "What are you now, my waitress?" Dean says "She's just trying to make you feel better. Don't be a bitch." Sam says "Yeah, I'm fine." Dean says "Yeah, you look fine. All I'm saying is everything's gonna be okay." Sam says "I don't know, Dean and Sarah If I did this here, then who knows how many oth--"there is an audible thud as Sam drops to the floor both Dean and Sarah runs over to Sam and Dean says "Sammy? Sammy?! Sammy, talk to me!" in his mind's eye, Sam remembers the Cage, remembers burning, and screams.