I think people are being too judgemental, he said he didn't remember his past life. That means he has 11 years of being a lonely, neglected, and heavily abused boy in his head but no love or close relationships. He doesn't understand how they work. He assumed his value of her was equal to her value of him. While that is a little silly, considering he sees her as someone to groom; he also sees her as his only friend and someone important that he doesn't want to lose. The fact she was willing to lose him, for an education he's already proven is subpar is understandly bruising his limited feelings. Though in her defense, she doesn't know about the other schools. If he told her, maybe her answer would change.

I agree with the comment above. I get what you're going for but it's so strange to me that everyone and i do mean literally everyone has a horrible opinion of her even if they are being "nice" about it. She literally saved their lives and if it wasn't for her; no one would know Quirrell was after the stone since NO ONE WOULD LISTEN TO HER including Professor McGonagall.

I know this is a very on par hermione thing but this is not at all what a friend would do. Rose is too nice; I would have dropped Hermione. No way am I downplaying myself and my skills to make you feel better about yourself.

I see what you were going for but I highly doubt Bellamy would just blurt this out to a stranger just because Angus said hi.

Probably because in reality; that's exactly what the death eaters would have done especially to muggle women and the imperious curse would make it all the easier.

Is this because it's an AU or going off the assumption that wizards haven't kept up with muggles and therefor know nothing about the science, etc.?

Isn't OP the best kind of fan fiction? So long as the author doesn't stagnate themselves by making them OP with no direction or purpose.

I think - unless this is AU - in the first season there is no way Lydia would have admitted to wanting to do anything academic; this was when she was still pretending to be a dumb bimbo for Jackson.

It's kind of funny that all these new Twilight Fics want to be "Original" by making Alice the mate/love interest, because she "doesn't get picked as a love interest in fanfiction"; but now it's become as overused as a Rosalie pairing.

I've already been assuming but I think this is confirmation that this is a translated Fic likely from Chinese or Japanese.

I don't get why people are complaining - I get that its "overused" but it is the simplest and canonical way for someone to handle this situation when they have studied magic beforehand. Accio is the summoning spell - who cares if people used it in many fics? That's how the spell works! It's what a prefect SHOULD have done if they went cabin to cabin searching for Trevor in the book/movie. People really use any excuse to complain these days.

If someone writes this - I would love to read it too!

The confusion for everone stems from the fact that the shifters were not WEREWOLVES; the wolf form was a coincidence. The true children of the moon were hunted to near extinction by the Volturi and were monsters incapable of controlling themselves on the full moon.

The ShapeShifters protected humans. The werewolves were monsters who hunted everything including humans and vampires but were hunted into extinction.

Isn't he 5? She's his MOM. I -

I know this is old and technically this may have been for story purposes; but in reality, with HP magic you should be able to make those supplies last... well, indefinitely. The spell they use where they can simply multiply something; as long as you have at least one you can have theoretically speaking, an infinite number of them. Like the spell they use on the food in the Great Hall. And if you know a stasis charm of some sort; you can keep it all good and fresh, too.

If he was immortal, I could understand showing off all of his things including Helia, but since he isn't all, he is doing is putting a really large target on his head.

You should really start using legilimency on everyone. You have no idea who you can truly trust if you don't, especially with your MC telling every-one and their brother about his powers, healing, and a whole cure.

Feather Light Charm Bro, It shouldn't weigh a thing.

FF - it has its own rules.