nobody is betting their names yet? omggg, come on guys, I'll start!!!! 1st for P >>> Penelope! Why? Because the author has a header of the third season of Bridgerton and who's the FML???? Penelope!!!! 2nd for A >>> Alexander! Why? I just love the name, lol.

age gap is the best in both ways 🥂🥂

u take the knifes I'll take the guns

that means bad breakup 👀

haven't read that one yet, is it good? im starting her novels w this onre

not to judge you, but already judging you, what is there to like in KATE man? omgggg Chaos has been warning us, did you forgot?

I would BE Chaos the spirit if I could 😌

11. black and dark green (I'm a Slytherin) 12. the first 3 books of Dune 13. Padam Padam by Kylie Minogue 14. my hair, my smile, and my body 15. the 1st Dune movie (the one with Timothée, Zendaya, and Oscar the-goat Isaac)

mother has returned 🛐

YESSSS

🥂

🖋️

Ann, girl, this is AMAZING. exactly my type of novel, I have no more words. I devoured this and now I'm starving for more. omggggg the angst lmao, and the tension. I feel the time skip coming soon and I CAN'T WAIT cuz I need Natasha to be with either Theo or Joshua soon. THOUGH I have a theory that they are the same person. Yes, I can't stop thinking about this from the beginning, and by the comments I'm glad I'm not the only one who thinks this, cuz OMG THE FORESHADOWING. Fr, I don't know exactly what is happening to my boys, but my gut is telling me they are THE SAME PERSON. They mentioned that some shit happened to Joshua, and I may sound crazy af, but maybe, maybe, MAYBE, the person with Soul magic and with the Soul Spirit (maybe the dude from the Goddess church we don't know much about and who's shady af) did this to him? Like, he fragmented his soul in two or some shit, and he now has an alter-ego, Theo, Ethan Theodore. Cuz I'm sure they are the person connected to her in the prophecy Nat's grandma foresaw. And that would explain why this happened. Nat might be the one to put his soul together (with... chaos magic? cuz it's opposing and all that), and get Theo and Joshua's minds to merge as one again. Lmao, bro, I'm theorizing like a bitch here, my brain is frying up. My favs are Nat, Val, Chaos, Theo/Josh, Casteel and Leo, and I'm terrified because of the death flag I'm seeing up in Val's head. Don't you dare to kill him, Ann. Omg I'll throw hands if you kill him. Or Chaos, cuz that shit he said about a spirit guardian being able to give his life to it's bond? HELL NO, that sounded like a foreshadowing to me. If Chaos or Val die for Nat she's be broken again, I can't stomach that gurl, my baby already suffered too much 😭 About Kate, I totally agree with Chaos, she is SUS af. Hah, and that sudden interest in Grand Duke Gil??? I don't like it. She is scheming something, I can feel it. She might not even be who she says she is, bro, God, I can smell the betray from my country. For all I know, she could end up being that infiltrated Princess bitch from the barbarian Empire who supposedly came with that monster who collects eyes. Either way, Nat is set to be broken and I'm scared lmao. Srsly, I can relate with her is so many levels. One more thing, I need them to die asap: Dalilah, Nat's mom whose name I don't care to remember, Octavian, the Empress, Christopher, and Kate. Sorry Kate, I can't stomach your ass. It's funny cuz the Empress and Christopher haven't even appeared yet, and I hate them so fucking much already, omg. Looking forward for the bloodbath Nat will be causing soon, and to the mess she'll turn her birthday ball in lmao. OMG I can't wait for her to review that Octavian is a ✨bastard✨ and not her father's son. It'll be iconic, though I'm scared to what will happen afterwards, as this will totally be a trap. Especially after she kills Dalilah's maid. Speaking of the bitch again, I'm curious to know who she'll brainwash and control to become her little murderous puppet. Don't let it be Leo 😫 Back to Theo/Joshua, I'm curious about how both of them have a different spirit guardian, as I'm positive they are the same dude. Maybe my theory is right and it's because their soul is... fragmented? Which kinda of leaves him with a split personality now, I guess. Now to what's important, I firmly believe that Joshua is the one who stole her magic and the Empress wiped it the memories. Josh was a little kid, so it must have been a total accident, maybe it was the exact moment he awakened this stealing magic, and that's why he feels guilty for something. Theo may not know that cuz Josh's soul must have been divided after that, which might even have been a punishment. The Empress on the other hand, must have messed with people's memories because it would absolutely taint the Imperial family if someone knew that the Imperial Crowned Prince was the one who stole the magic powers of the daughter of the strongest Grand Duke. So, fucked up. His stealing magic might also be why his family low key fears him and isolated our boy as a kid? Cuz they must have been terrified of him accidentally stealing ✨their✨ magic too. AND HE'S TOTALLY THE EXECUTIONER WHO SENT HER BACK TO THE PAST AND IS DOING THAT WEIRD THING WITH THE MEMORIES OMGGGGG. I'M CERTAIN IT'S HIM. Val and Casteel totally will be able to tell if they see his true appearance which only Nat can see. He may not have his memories of their first life like Nat yet, but that might potentially change if she kisses him (ON THE MOUTH!!!!!!!), because if he put a kiss in the forehead head for the others, than he definitely must have put a trigger for himself to get his memories of everything too. Which will make them the most powerful couple ever, so, COME FASTER TIME SKIP I NEED YOU. I love how Josh and Theo are in love with her, as again, I'm sure they are the same person. It's just magical. They are really star-crossed and meant for each other 🥺 NO AND LMFAO THEO KNOWING THAT LEO IS DATING ADELYN, BUT JOSH NOT KNOWING ABOUT IT LMAOOO. Just chef kiss, he'll probably learn about it when both Theo and Josh's minds merge together again. But in case I'm delusional and my theories are absolutely wrong, lmao, I'll feel stupid, cuz I'm so so so certain of this. Waiting for more. Thanks again, Ann, for this amazing story, and for making me crazy with theories like this. Stories that make me think this way are my favorites of my life. Nat is my ultimate babe and I just want her to be happy AND ALIVE!

happy bday, author-nim! I wish you the best and thank you for sharing with us your amazing writing skills.

right? and ahhhhh it's close to 50K

yah

ahhhhh I haven't read those yet, only this one and Do You Remember That Night, but I'll

I would name it Calypso