While Andy tried to distract himself by punishing his muscles, the story was different at Anya's end...
What a night Anya had with Andy! First time in her life after her brother's death she felt genuinely cared for.
Andy was a lovely guy and a breathtaking partner in bed. He had given attention to her every reaction. She had a great time and some earth-shattering orgasms. She didn't feel for a second that he was a novice. In fact, she enjoyed guiding him to do what she wanted.
But things didn't go the way she would have wanted them to.
She had actually believed that being with Andy would have avoided the nightmares.
Her psychiatrist was the best in town and he had clearly said that her nightmares were a product of her loneliness.
She was shocked to see Andy staring at her with sympathy in his eyes when she had woken up with yet another reminder of what she had lost when her brother saved her.