Fallen Elf Dungeon I

The arrival of the girls brought about some heightened tensions. Rias was the real deal and Akeno followed suit. It would be safe to assume the trigger was the fact that Anna broke the status quo.

Me? I had no problem whatsoever. I was already expecting to make both Rias and Akeno mine. The question was when? I thought when they were both adults but they rushed things up. 

Akeno and Rias are now my girlfriends too and they are... chummy, to say the least. Staying in a room the whole day they wanted, and so we did. 

I had three blushing beauties naked in front of me, of which only Anna shily covered herself, not from my gaze but from Akeno and Rias'.

It was amazing to see these three young goddesses lined up. I didn't shy away from reaching out to grasp Rias' silky hair and sniff it. 

"Don't do that... it is embarrassing..." She blushed up.

"What is it? Can't I touch my girlfriend's hair?".

"Okay touch it, but you don't have to smell it!"

"I'll smell it all I want, Rias!"

I pinned her down and straddled her waist. Rias panted in all her nakedness, expecting my next move. 

"You can't ignore me, Ray-kun!"

"What about me!"

Akeno and Anna each took my arms. I sighed, entertaining three beautiful girlfriends thirsty for attention is not going to be easy. I'll blitz through their feelings like a hurricane while thriving at the edge of morality. No matter what I can't go all the way, this is my pledge!

So I started with what I'm the best at, a massage. 

"Uhm!!!~"

It was not a formal session, just a casual massage from me. I lined up my three girls to do a standard Swedish kneading session. With my hands working them out, their true natures quickly showed. 

Anna transformed into her beautiful yet eerie youkai form, she sucked my blood... lots of it. 

"Ahn!~ It is delicious Ray-chan!~"

Akeno's devil wings and fallen angel wings flapped out, I knew her complex so I gave some extra love to her fallen angel wings. 

"There, keep scratching there!~"

As for Rias, hers was more special. I took both hers and Akeno's first kiss and she was quite fond of them, so instead of massaging her back, I massaged her front and kept kissing her all along. 

"So good!~"

Her massage was the most difficult. It was a double-edged sword. I could see her giggly big boobs and pointy buds asking for me to fondle them. But Anna and Akeno were watching, they were already expecting me to do more than just a massage. Anna in particular, because I have already done a lot of naughtiness with her... she must be waiting for the best moment to strike while playing the fool talking about snacks. 

Anna-chan, I already know you're not so innocent, you can't fool me.

If I started fondling Rias' breasts all of a sudden... this would turn into a warzone. I restrained myself and limited the interactions to just kisses and caresses. 

"Do you want me to kill Raiser?" I asked.

I held the three in my embrace as we waited for food to be brought by the castle's servants. 

She had told me her issue... and it was frankly inconsequential for me. I could take her away from the Gremory Household as easily as snapping my fingers. But Rias wanted to do things right.

"No, that would be a bit overboard... now that we're like this, I want to do things the right way. It is my responsibility to call out that engagement with my own strength".

"Then in that Roygun Belphegor's case, shouldn't it be right for me to defeat her?"

"Ray-kun, it is not that simple... as the Heiress of Gremory, Rias has to uphold the honour and reputation of her family. The best way to do it is by defeating both Riser and Lady Roygun" Akeno explained. 

"Then what would be the best way for me to help you? Should I help you get stronger?" It was a bit of a headache but when it comes to women, the best way to make them happen is to sit down and listen. 

"That would be ideal... disputes in the underworld between high-ranked devils are rarely solved in a duel. We have a system called rating games in which both 'kings' fight each other with their peers. To marry you safely within the devil community I would have to defeat both Riser and Roygun in a rating game".

"I see, so not only do I have to help you get stronger... but your peerage as well?".

If that was the case, would it be enough to get her a few powerful members? But it would be not very sensible to get her powerful members if she couldn't control them. I thought to myself of a certain dragon that I defeated not too long ago, his puppet armour at least. 

Rias nodded, caressed my chest and smiled, "I am happy that you want to help me, but so long as you believe in me, your love is all the strength I need~"

"..."

"Hyan!~"

The three of them are so damn cute, I took the three of them into another kissing session that lasted for nearly an hour until someone knocked on the door two times before entering. 

!!!

Aqua looked at me and the girls had a four-way kiss. 

"S-S-S-Sorry!!"

...

"This is Aqua, a Goddess of Water and currently performing as my assistant" I introduced her. Aqua had been earning her keep by attending the annoying meetings I couldn't be arsed to attend. She fell asleep in most of them, but it didn't matter... she just had to attend and relay to me the summary, most of the time her summary was accurate. Soon I'd give her a good massage and hopefully, that would help her recover her powers. 

Aqua had an immense desire to take revenge on Kazuma, she said she didn't want to kill him... she wanted to make him suffer. So when the time is nigh, she and Azrael may travel to that world for some witch hunt. 

Perhaps you don't recall... but Azrael also wants Kazuma dead. 

Nevertheless, Aqua has already expressed an interest in staying with me.

"Goddess..." Anna, Rias and Akeno hurriedly circled up the goddess with interested, putting the blue-haired girl in an awkward spot, wondering who these were. 

"Aqua, these are Rias, Akeno and Anna; they're my lovers from the world I hail from" I introduced the girls too.

"Huh, more lovers?" Aqua pouted.

!!!

"Huh?" The three girls stared daggers at me, wondering how many more there were. It was a misunderstanding. I don't have that many lovers here!

'Aqua, you can get people killed like that!' I cursed inwardly, she noticed my glare and immediately changed her narrative. 

"I-I meant, because Ray is such a kind god hehehe, he treats all women like his lovers".

"Is that so?" Their glare lessened but didn't disappear. 

Was that supposed to fix the situation? I feel like you just dug me even deeper in shit. After some explanation, I told them that I didn't have that many lovers here and didn't plan to increase the numbers either. 

I'm already a bit overwhelmed... rather than getting new lovers here, I'd rather go back to my girls in Japan. 

They nodded wisely and let me go, but Aqua would get scolded later. 

"Hiya!~" Out of the three, as would be expected, only Anna welcomed Aqua with open arms while Akeno and Rias cursed inwardly at the earlier interruption. 

"Is there something the matter, Aqua?".

"Jicniv arrived from his tour... he is meeting Anna now for dinner"

"Anna!? Nobody has met Anna" Anna-chan lashed, speaking in the third person as she used to when we were kids. I recall they have the same name, the same long hair and the same boobs size. 

"Huh, the other Anna..." Aqua stammered. 

"There is another Anna...?" My girlfriend glared at me hard, once again I was in the line of fire. It is because this girl is so silly for foolish reasons!

"Let me explain..."