How I FUCK Two Girls In One Night
When I was a freshman I started behaving pretty fucking ridiculously. My high school girlfriend and I had just broken up. I was just too horny and there were too many options. I suppose it helped that I sold weed on the side and also that I had a fake ID that I used sort of frequently. Sex-wise, I did things like fuck a girl on the couch in the common area of my dorm, had an escort at a motel downtown when I was supposed to be taking an exam, banged a sorority girl in someone else's room…but the craziest thing was the two girls I had in one night.
One of them I was dating. Her name was Kat (not her real name). We weren't even supposed to hook up that night. We had gotten in to a huge fight, again, and were on a break, again. We were shitshows and our relationship was a trainwreck. So I left her apartment and realized that I wouldn't be able to do it this time. I couldn't go a week or so until we made up and were back together without getting my dick wet. So I planned on seducing this chick from my crim justice class, we'll call her Megan. She was a freshman like me, brunette, freckles, short, shy-ish personality, but a twisted sense of humor that she'd reveal to you once she got comfortable. I'd hit on her since the start of that class and she'd thought I was gross at first. But now she'd come around to my uh…charms? So I asked her out and she was hesitant, but I persisted. We went out for pizza that weekend, then to my buddy's "cocktail party." In quotes because it had just become stupid teen drinking by the time we got there. I brought this large bottle of tanqueray that I still owe Kat for (she was 22 btw) unless fucking her brains out the night she got it counts lol.
Megan and I were feeling each other already - I put my hand on her back when I led her in, so physical contact was already in play…and she thought I was hilarious and related to my stories about my family, etc. We did shots and socialized, and at some point I found myself hitting on this rando in plain sight of Megan. I think I went in to it not knowing what I was doing, but figured it would make Megan envious/want me more as I went on. It did. I even did a thing where I held this random girl's necklace in my hand and complimented it and asked her questions just like I'd done with Megan…just a favorite tactic of mine is all. When I went back to Megan she was alone and upset, but didn't tell me to fuck off, like she could have. I asked if she was upset about her ex, and that steered the convo. We went to the balcony, smoked a bowl, and she poured out all her baggage on me (parents, grades, ex, etc). I put my arm around her and comforted her. Now I knew I would fuck her.
After going back in and dancing, grinding, kissing, making out in front of people and then out in the hallway, we decided to go back to her dorm. In her dorm we stood kissing while I unbuckled her pants and stroked her between her thighs and she felt my cock through my boxers. And next thing I remember I was lying on her bed and her pussy was in my face. She was sitting on me, not sure whose idea that was.
At that time, I didn't like fingering girls while going down on them - I considered it cheating. So I licked her for a while and straddled her waist with one hand, explored her body with the other- caressing her back, smacking her ass, playing with her nipples, the works. I occasionally checked on her face and at first she was looking down at my and cupping my head in her hands, later her head was tilted back and she was just moaning at the cheap ass dorm room lights. I switched it up from side to sides to ups and downs after a while and started focusing more on her clit. That's when she really started tugging at my hair and made these shrill calls. Eventually she was really wet and I felt her tense up and her thighs went THWOMP. Over my head, blocked out my hearing completely. Like when you watch an action movie and something big happens and suddenly SILENCE. Aside from the suffocation part it was fine. I licked faster if anything, until she spazzed off my face.
We got our bearings and I kissed her, told her how beautiful she was, how I'd liked her a long time, I felt different around her than with other girls…mainly because I didn't have a condom and still wanted to fuck her. (I hate condoms lol). After just coming out with it that I didn't have a condom but with my assurance that it would feel awesome, she agreed that it was cool, she was on the pill, but asked me to be careful.
So I'm raw dogging Megan slowly, her on top, when we hear this buzzing sound on the sheets behind us. It was my phone. I knew who it was right away. If you guessed Kat, you sir/madame are correct. But I was kind of tied up right then obviously so I let it ring. Megan was a little distracted though. I told her to look at me, concentrate on me…which she did. Clearly I had to crank up the sex also, so I moved faster and without really meaning to, I got rough. The mattress was creaking, lots of panting from both of us, my skin wapping against her skin. She made things a little easier by bending down so her face was closer to mine…I moved her body up and down as fast I could. She started saying 'yes' a lot. When I asked if I could cum inside her she said yes again…in hindsight I'm not sure if it was an answer to my question or not. But anyway I did nut inside her, without attempting pull out. So yeah I wasn't careful and yes I'm terrible lol.
She was in the bathroom not much later, cleaning herself off/out. And I was lying on her bed letting my dick dry. And I felt a little awkward, so I decided to call Kat back. I went into the hallway to do it. She was at a party, wasted and lonely. This neckbeardy dude we both knew had been hitting on her and she didn't like that. She wanted to see me. I tried making up and excuse, but she came out with the emotional blackmail (okay, guess you don't care about me whatever… that kind of thing). I told her I'd be there in a half hour or so. I went back in and got dressed and Megan was pissed. She tried asking me who was I talking to, was I seeing somebody, what was going on…I told her sorry I had to end the night here, it was fun, we'll hang out again…and left. I think she watched me leaving for a few seconds before she slammed the door. I rinsed the taste of her labia out in the sink. I texted my friend whose party we'd been at that I was getting laid twice tonight, nanana-na-na.
When I got to Kat's friend Renata's apartment it was like 2 AM and the party had died down. Only a few people left. Creepy neckbeard had exited. Kat was in a good mood, hallelujuah. She kissed me and hugged me and we cuddled on the couch while sipping from her vodka and watching one of the transformers movies with Nata and her bf. Then the two of them called it a night and Kat and I got busy. We pulled out the couch-bed and made it and sat there kissing and necking for a while. Then I ate her out for a while (second vagina in my mouth in like 3 hours, I was suffering withdrawal symptoms yo). It was dark and she still had her shirt on while I did it. And I did it slower and more romantically than with Megan. When it felt like she was worked up enough, I took my pants off and was ready for penetration (she and I always fucked without condoms). But Kat surprised me. She moved downwards and started blowing me. Totally random, given that I don't even like BJs and she knew that. And it's also when everything went to shit. Why?
UHHHH BECAUSE SHE TASTED MEGAN ON MY COCK!
Which I'd forgot to rinse off. Duh. Kat came up and made a face and said "Adam what is that?" I didn't know what she meant for a second and told her nothing. She went back down and then I realized OOOooooohhhhh. And she stopped again and put her hand on her mouth and got wide eyed. Said "oh my god" and ran to the bathroom. I listened to her over-dramatically hack up whatever dried pussy juices had gotten in her mouth and tbh it was pretty hot. Then she ran back in to the room and smacked me, pushed me over, and whisper-screamed at me for a while. Gave me all the abuse she knew of while starting to cry. Told me I was an animal, a psycho, I needed help, if I was going to fuck other girls like this we were done, she hoped I died, hoped I got aids…the works. She sat on the edge of the bed and cried and I really did feel like shit. I tried touching her shoulder and she pushed me away.
I thought that was that. But Kat had a surprise up her sleeve, er, vagina. She sat up straight like she was making a huge decisions. She took off her shirt climbed on top of me, massaged my cock back to full mast and guided me in to her. Hate fucked me right then and there. Did almost all the work herself. I tried working her hips but she pushed my hands away and even held them down. She rode me and I refused to look at her face because I wasn't sure if she was still crying. I watched her tits bounce and her nipples get harder. She was just breathing for a while, trying to keep things mum for Nata. But at some point she was making pretty loud vocals and I was sure they were probably awake. I just hoped it put them in the mood at least. Kat bucked her thighs around my waist and had the most enraptured female orgasm I've ever been privvy too. I might have even whispered daaaaaammmmnnnn while it was happening, just to drown out her sheer volume. I hadn't cum yet. Then finally I did and had an A+ orgasm myself. And when it was over we collapsed on the bed and passed out.
I was woken up at 5 in the morning or something by Kat and Renata. They told me to get dressed and get out. Kat told me we were done, she never wanted to see me again, Renata told me not to come near her friend or I'd have to deal with her…I got the drift. I got dressed and walked across the cold and very quiet campus back to my dorm, my cock sticking to my boxers. For the next week I didn't get any action, just drank and smoked a lot and felt like an ass.