Caught in the Act (R-18)

Human World, Japan, Kuoh.

The day after the party, Rias, Akeno, and Reya returned to the Underworld. Rias and Akeno to continue training with the rest of Rias peerage, and Reya to train in magic with Serafall. As for James and his peerage, Flora was at Kuoh Academy in the MMA training hall, training her martial arts, while Mizore and Moka were out shopping/patrolling the town, Cu Chulainn was on a date with Tsubaki, and the duo of Dante and Lady were lazing around at Devil May Cry.

Meanwhile, James had just left his house and was walking across the street to see Sona. The day before, she had said she wanted to talk about something with him. Looking at the circumstances, however, he was anticipating their talk to be a little more "Physical" in nature. Once he reached Sona's front door, James wasted no time ringing her doorbell. A few moments later, the door opened, revealing Sona in a red blouse, black skirt, thigh high black socks, and short black tie.

'That's a nice absolute territory.' James thought to himself while he checked out Sona.

Sona also looked James up and down and she liked what she saw. In a dark blue unzipped hoodie with a white t-shirt underneath, light blue denim jeans, and a pair of Space Jam Jordan XI's. {A/N: My favorite of all the Jordan's released} At the end of the day, they both looked like they were ready to go on a date. Instead, they planned to stay in and talk.

"James, Welcome." Sona said with a smile and slight blush. "Please, come in."

"Thanks for having me." James said, returning the smile. "By the way, you look great today. Even better than usual."

As James finished, he stepped forward and pecked Sona on her pretty lips. In response, Sona smiled sweetly and moved aside so James could enter the house. After they were both inside, Sona closed and locked the door. As the click from the locking mechanism rang out, James also felt a barrier activate around the house.

"Hmm? The barrier activated?" James asked in confusion.

"We redesigned it so that it activates whenever the door is locked. Sona replied with an awkward smile.

James, although he knew she was lying, did not know what to say. Eventually he scratched his head and gave a generic response.

"Well, I guess it's better to be safe than sorry."

After that, Sona led James through the house and up the stairs. Eventually they ended up at what James guessed to be Sona's bedroom door. Sona opened the door and entered the room, with James following close behind. Once James entered the room Sona closed the door behind them and James once again heard the click of a lock and felt a barrier surrounding the bedroom. Raising his eyebrow, James then looked at Sona with a knowing smile.

"I see, better safe than sorry again, huh?" James said with a chuckle.

Sona blushed after being seen through. She then put on a resolute expression.

"I'll admit, I wanted to be your first." Sona said after pushing away the embarrassment. "But I'm not upset that I wasn't."

"*Sigh* You know I didn't try to get in bed with Akeno, right?" James said while looking Sona in the eyes. "In fact, I wasn't trying to get in bed with anyone. I figured letting you girls make the first move would make it seem like I wasn't playing favorites."

"I know." Sona said with a nod. "But I think it would be better if you did play favorites."

"Huh?" James found himself slightly confused by Sona's statement.

"I've done some... Um... research about what it takes to make a harem work." Sona said shyly.

"Oh?" James exclaimed with interest. Then he beckoned Sona to continue.

"If you want the harem to succeed, you can't treat us all equally." Sona said while adjusting her glasses, which gleamed when they caught the light. "You can't treat us equally because we are not equal. As we are different people, your feelings for each of us will undoubtedly be different. Do you understand?"

James lowered his head and stroked his chin while he digested Sona's words. Once comprehension dawned on him, he raised his head and spoke.

"So, what you're saying boils down to..." James trailed off as he put his thoughts in order. Once he was ready, he continued from where he left off. "It's all right to love you all. But I can't love you all the same because none of you are the same."

"That's right." Sona said with a nod. "And you should act on your own desires more. We certainly have when it comes to you."

After speaking, Sona managed to blush even harder as she stepped toward James. Once in front of him, she reached up and wrapped her arms around his neck, then whispered into his ear.

"As your fiancée, I want you to make me yours."

James, not needing to be told twice, wrapped his arms around Sona and sunk his fingers into her ass. Then, with a bestial quality to his voice he replied.

"What a coincidence." James said with a lustful smile. "As my fiancée I want to make you mine, as well."

Even though she was blushing, Sona could not help but giggle. For whatever reason, she thought James was incredibly cute right now. That thought lasted until James picked her up and threw her on her bed. When she looked up again, James was shirtless. His finely chiseled muscular torso, on full display.

James then crawled up onto the bed. Moving slowly, Sona thought James looked like a predator stalking its prey. The desire burning in his eyes was igniting her own desire as well. While James was making his way forward, Sona began to undress herself. First loosening the tie, then pulling it off all together she threw it to the floor. Then she unbuttoned the blouse, yet not removing it fully. She could not be bothered to pull its hem out of her skirt. After that, she unhooked her front hook bra and removed it fully. With her breasts exposed, her hard nipples were very prominent.

At that moment, James had arrived. Looking down on Sona's half naked form, James found it sexier than full nudity.

"Damn, that's sexy." James said with the lust in his eyes increasing. "I guess what they say about the quiet ones is true, huh?"

Sona blushed at James' comment. Yet, with impatience in her glare she spoke.

"Would you shut up and fuck me already." Sona said with an impatient, almost desperate tone.

James only smiled in response. Then, positioning himself between her legs, James leaned down and kissed Sona. Immediately, he snaked his tongue past her lips and made contact with her tongue. At the same time, he massaged her breasts.

"Mmm~!"

Feeling James hands on her breasts, Sona moaned into the kiss.

"Mmm~! Mmm~~!" Mmm~!"

Sona moaned longer and more intensely when James began rolling her nipples between his thumbs and index fingers. After kissing for a few minutes, James began to lower his kisses. Kissing straight down from Sona's lips, he kissed her chin then her throat, then her collar bone, then her upper chest, and finally between her breasts.

"Mmm~! *Gasp!* Mmm~~!"

Sona moaned and gasped with every kiss James landed on her soft, fair skin. On top of that, James fingers never left her nipples, which had been gently squeezed and rolled between them the entire time. Eventually, James wrapped his lips around her right nipple. As he did, he removed his left hand and slid it under her skirt.

"Ahn~~!"

To his surprise, Sona was not wearing panties. She moaned when the only thing James could feel was a sopping wet, freshly shaven pussy. James raised his head from Sona's breast with a bit of shock in his eyes. Before he could speak, however, Sona beat him to it.

"Like I said before." Sona said with the lust in her eyes reaching its peak. "Would you shut up and fuck me already."

James, without delay, pulled his hand out from under Sona's skirt. He then unbuttoned and unzipped his jeans and lowered them along with his boxers to halfway down his thighs. By then, Sona had flipped up her skirt. Exposing her pussy, with love juice dripping in anticipation. Wasting no more time, James lined up his dick with Sona's entrance.

"Mmm~!"

Sona moaned once again as James stretched her vaginal walls as his dick buried itself deeper. Eventually, James' path forward was obstructed. Already knowing what the answer would be, James did not even bother asking with his eyes if Sona was ready.

"Mmm~! Argh~~!"

Yet again, Sona moaned when James pulled his hips back. When he pushed forward, breaking her hymen in the process, the mix between a scream and painful groan tore its way out of Sona's mouth. James stopped moving immediately, waiting for Sona's pain to subside. Once it did, Sona signaled she was ready by wrapping her legs around James' waste. Feeling her thighs and socks on his back, James began to pump his hips slowly. As Sona's groans transformed into moans, James' speed increased.

"Mmm~~ Yes! James... Ahn~! More! Ahn~! Give me more!"

After a few minutes, Sona was fully engaged in the sex. The feeling of James drilling into her was euphoric. She even began asking for more.

"Oh~~! James! James! Ahn~! You're amazing~! Mmm~! I'm cumming~! Oh, yes~! I'm cumming~! Ahh~!"

After a few more minutes, Sona had the most intense orgasm of her life. Her legs involuntarily released James' waist, her back arched, eyes rolled back, and toes curled. For close to a minute, Sona shuddered violently with a satisfied smile plastered on her face. Once she recovered, James had already hooked his arms under her knees. When he noticed she was with him again, James leaned forward, pressing her legs back with her feet on either side of her head. Then without a word of warning, He began to drill Sona again.

"Ahh~! Oh, my Satan`! It's so deep~! Mmm~~! Yes~!"

With every stroke, James pounded harder and harder. And Sona was loving it.

"Yes! That's it~! Harder~! Deeper~! Ohh~! Yes~! I'm cumming again~!"

Even though Sona announced her orgasm, like she had before, James had no intention of stopping this time. As He continued to drill her, Sona was accumulating orgasms. As she did, their reverberations combined. In the end, it felt like all these orgasms had melded into one massive orgasm.

"Ahn~~~~~!"

Eventually, James could feel his own limit.

I'm gonna cum." James said as he was preparing to pull out.

"Inside~~! Fill me up~!" Sona Screamed, gaining the clarity of mind to make her desires known.

With Sona's scream, James last bit of rationality flew away. He redoubled his efforts and drilled Sona even harder and deeper than he was just a moment before. A moment later, James could no longer hold on.

"Mmph!"

"Ahh~~~~~~~~~!"

James grunted as he bust his nut. At the same time, Sona screamed loud enough to be heard from outside the front door of the house. It should be noted, Sona's bedroom is the location in the house with the furthest physical distance from the front door.

James, after painting Sona's insides white, repositioned his arms and allowed Sona's legs to fall to the bed. He then rolled over, laying down on his back next to his Shuddering mess of a fiancée. Sona, shuddering from the reverberations of her massive orgasm, was smiling sloppily with her tongue hanging out of her mouth and clenching the sheets with not only her fingers but also her curled toes.

Eventually, Sona regained her faculties. Turning her head in James' direction, she smiled sweetly. Though the lustful glint in her eyes was still there.

"I want more." Sona said with a smile.

Smiling back in return, James started to raise his upper body to start round two. Sona, however, stopped his movement. Instead, she rolled over on top of James, and positioned herself over his standing dick. As Sona lowered herself, they felt a tremor in the barriers surrounding not only the house, but also the bedroom.

"Mmm~! No way..." Sona said with despair in her tone, as she had just buried James entire dick inside her.

"I get the feeling this isn't going to end well." James said Simultaneously.

A moment later, the barriers active around the house and Sona's bedroom shattered simultaneously. Then, a teleportation circle bearing the mark of Leviathan appeared on the side of the bed. While Sona's expression showed despair, James' showed total indifference. He was certainly not happy being interrupted, even if it was Serafall.

Once the magic circle disappeared, as they expected, Serafall was standing where its center was. With an excited smile, she began to speak as soon as the teleportation ended and before she could register what was going on around her.

"So-Tan! So-Tan! Your [Bishop]…" Serafall began to excitedly explain about Reya's progress, however she froze when she saw the position James and Sona were in.

"What are you doing here?" Sonna shrieked as she leaned forward and hugged James to hide her half naked body. "Why aren't you with Reya? And why did you destroy my barriers?"

"Huh? What?" Serafall had lost the ability to articulate upon seeing this sight.

"Hey, Sera-Tan, if you don't plan on joining us, could you leave?" James said with an expressionless face. "If you do, you might have a niece or a nephew this time next year."

Sona glared at James for his statement. Meanwhile, his words rebooted Serafall's brain.

"Absolutely not!" Serafall shouted. "Onee-Chan does not approve! You're not even married yet."

"Sera-Tan, you're surprisingly innocent." James said with a chuckle.

"Would you shut up?" Sona said in response to James' teasing. "You're just gonna make things worse."

And for the next hour and a half, Serafall made a ruckus, Sona attempted to get her sister to leave, and James made everything worse by teasing the Sitri sisters at every opportunity.