I Didn't Know You Loved Me Too

I rubbed Lucy's nipple between my thumb and index finger, as if squeezing it.

"Ahh!"

"How about I cum inside you? Do you like receiving my semen?"

"..."

Lucy hesitated to answer.

I squeezed her nipple once more.

"Aahn♥"

"Answer."

"Originally... hnn. It's not supposed to be done, right?"

"Huh?"

Not allowed?

Is there some law against creampies in dungeons?

Lucy's face turned red.

"Creampies are for making babies. That's for people who love each other..."

I squeezed her nipple again.

"Ngh. Aahn. It hurts."

"But I love you?"

"...Huh?"

"I guess you don't feel the same way."

Lucy's eyes widened.

"Really? Actually, I... I do too."

She lowered her head.

"Then what's the problem? You should be happy to receive a creampie from someone you love."

"...I didn't know."

"What?"

Lucy glanced at me, then pouted and said,

"I... I didn't know you loved me too."

"Come here."

I leaned back in the chair.

"...Okay."

Lucy climbed on top of me and rubbed my dick against her pussy.

Her pussy was already wet and slippery.

As her lewd ass lowered, my dick slid in, scraping against her vaginal folds.

"Ahh."

Lucy tilted her head back.

Her hips trembled slightly.

It seemed she came as soon as I entered her.

I sucked on Lucy's nipple in front of me.

"Aaahn♥"

Lucy moaned like a bitch, looking up at the ceiling.

Slurp.

I teased her erect nipple with the tip of my tongue.

"Aahn. It feels good."

"Lucy. Do you like having your nipples sucked?"

"Yes. I like it."

"Do you like my dick?"

"I love it so much."

"You'll like getting creampies from now on too, right?"

"Mmm."

Lucy just moved her hips back and forth.

After days of training, her hip movements had become very lewd.

"It's from someone you love, after all?"

"I'm scared of getting pregnant."

"You can lower the chances with mana control techniques, right?"

"Even so, 2% is still a high possibility.

So when you cum inside, it feels good but it's also scary..."

I gripped Lucy's ass tightly and said,

"Lucy."

"Yes?"

"You won't be able to be with other men anyway."

"..."

"Can you give up this dick?"

"..."

"Can you live without my dick?"

"Are you threatening me?"

Lucy pouted, looking upset.

"I don't think I can live without Lucy?"

"...Really?"

She brightened up.

"Yeah.

And don't worry too much.

2% is the average, but a mage like you can lower it to under 1%.

Even condoms are only 97% effective, so that level of probability is enough."

"Is that so?"

"If you're still worried, then get pregnant."

"Huh?"

"Think about getting pregnant every time you take my semen."

"What? That's..."

Lucy's cheeks turned bright red.

I boldly said,

"Take responsibility for me."

"Huh?"

"An S-rank hunter can support at least one person, right?"

"That's true, but..."

"Zoe said she'd take responsibility if she got pregnant, so I could cum inside as much as I want-"

Lucy's eyes widened in surprise as she interrupted me.

"Wait. Wait. What? Sis Zoe said that?"

"Yeah."

"You're not lying, are you?"

"It's the truth."

"Tch."

Lucy suddenly started moving her hips back and forth quickly.

"Did you change your mind?"

"Hurry up and cum.

Cum inside me completely.

Get me pregnant."

"Move up and down."

Lucy hugged me and started moving her hips up and down.

Squelch squelch squelch squelch

Her erect nipples touched my chest.

"Aaahn. Ikan's dick feels so good.

I won't let Sis Zoe steal you.

You prefer my pussy, right?

I always make you cum faster than Sis Zoe.

Right? Answer me."

"Well, let's see how well you take my creampie this time."

"Okay. Fill me up with your semen.

I'll take responsibility even if I get pregnant, so cum as much as you want. Got it?"

Squelch squelch squelch

The sound of flesh mixing echoed continuously throughout the camp.

After climaxing twice on top of me, Lucy rubbed her cheek against mine.

"Aahn. Ikan. Hurry and cum.

I keep cumming from the excitement of possibly getting pregnant."

I kissed Lucy.

She greedily explored my lips and tongue.

"Hehe."

She looked at me with unfocused eyes, drooling slightly.

I commanded Lucy,

"I'm going to cum, so go to the bed and get in whatever position you want to be fucked in."

"Okay."

She lay down on the edge of the bed and spread her legs towards me.

"L-like this..."

I sat in the chair and said,

"Spread your pussy with your fingers."

"Mmm."

Lucy whined.

"Hurry.

You know it takes longer if you can't cum when you want to, right?"

"Ugh."

Lucy spread her pussy lips with her fingers, feeling ashamed.

"I... I did it..."

Love juices dripped out.

"Try to turn me on with your words."

"Hurry and come... cum inside me, Ikan..."

"More."

"Fill me up with your semen and get me pregnant. Ikan. Please. Please. Hurry. Hic."

That tearful face was so beautiful, I couldn't hold back any longer.

I went to the bed and inserted my dick into Lucy without hesitation.

"Aaahn♥"

"You lewd girl."

Slap slap slap slap.

I started thrusting vigorously.

Her breasts with erect nipples shook vulgarly.

Lucy grabbed her own breasts tightly.

"Yes. That's right. I'm lewd.

I can't stand not being fucked by you every day anymore. Aahn. It feels so good."

I pounded my meat rod into her pussy, making slapping sounds.

"Aaaaaahn. Are you going to cum inside? Are you going to get me pregnant?"

"I'll cum, so get pregnant. Okay?"

"Yes. Cum. I'll get pregnant. Give me all your semen, Ikan."

"Aah-"

I closed my eyes tightly and tilted my head back.

I started ejaculating continuously deep inside her vagina, like peeing.

Spurt! Spurrrrrrt!

Pleasure semen instantly filled her vagina.

Lucy arched her back and moaned.

"Ngh!"

I continued thrusting into her cum-filled pussy.

Semen mixed with pussy juices flowed back out in waves.

"Haa haa. I can feel the semen. Ikan's semen. Trying to get me pregnant. Hnn aahn. Ikan. I'm... I'm cumming. I'm cumming!"

I pulled out my still-ejaculating dick and started cumming on her stomach.

Spurt. Spurt. Spurt.

My huge dick twitched, spewing semen.

Lucy's hips trembled.

Then she started squirting clear liquid vertically.

"Ahaahn♥"

Lucy instinctively tried to close her legs out of embarrassment.

"Ikan. Hic."

I spread her legs even wider.

"Aahn. Ikaaaan♡"

Lucy writhed in pleasure.

Squirt squirt squirt

She kept ejaculating water while her hips convulsed repeatedly.

She had finally started to fully feel the pleasure of creampies that she had been psychologically rejecting until now.

The most promising student at the Hunter Academy, coveted by all guilds.

The supremely beautiful Lucy had been completely trained to be my cum dumpster in that moment.

***

That night.

The three of us were playing a board game at the table.

I said with a smile,

"Whoever has the red 3, play it when it's a good time. We can't continue if you don't play it anyway."

"Sis, use your joker if you have one."

"Huh? I don't... don't have a joker.

Lucy, draw if you don't have anything to play."

"Okay."

Lucy drew a number block from the pile.

"Oh? It's a red 3. Ikan, I'll play the 3 for you on my next turn."

"Nice."

Zoe's eyes widened in shock.

"Hey. Lucy. Why are you helping Ikan win instead of trying to win yourself?"

"I don't think I can win this round anyway."

Ding ding ding~♪

An alarm sound came from the utility room at the back of the camp.

It was the washing machine.

I muttered to myself,

"I should hang up the laundry when it's done."

"I'll do it for you, Ikan. You must be tired after cumming so much earlier."

Zoe stroked my thigh from the side.

Lucy furrowed her brow.

I suddenly felt a chill.

There's a principle of uncertainty of getting screwed in life.

You don't realize it when things are peaceful.

Then at some point, when you start to think "Huh? Am I screwed?", getting screwed becomes a reality right before your eyes.

This was one of those moments.

Lucy's eyebrows twitched.

Her eyes were sharp.

"Ikan."

It's cold.

A dagger flies and pierces my chest.

"Yes?"

"You didn't..."

"What?"

But don't worry.

If I just talk my way out of this-

"Ugh."

Zoe grabs my thigh that she was stroking tightly.

It hurts. It fucking hurts.

"Zoe. Wh-why."

Zoe looks back and forth between Lucy and me.

She opens her mouth.

"Ikan.

Did you confess to Lucy too?"

Lucy's pupils dilated. She stood up abruptly.

"This bastard!

You told me you loved me earlier!"

The two women were glaring at me with murderous eyes.

I raised both hands and calmly said,

"No. No.

Girls, listen to me."

Zoe grabbed my collar.

"Come here."

I was dragged to the bed with my collar grabbed.

"Ugh."

I was forcibly sat down on the edge of the bed.

Zoe and Lucy looked down at me with contempt, standing one step away.

"You dare to two-time Lucy and me?"

"Are you crazy?"

The situation had become irreversible.

At times like this, a frontal breakthrough is needed.

I nodded.

I quietly took off my pants and underwear.

Zoe and Lucy exchanged glances, dumbfounded.

"What are you doing in this situation."

"Hey, Ikan! Are you making fun of us?"

I grabbed my dick, shook it, and said,

"So."

"Huh?"

"...What?"

"You're not going to do it with me?"

What can you do?

What can you do when you're addicted to my dick?

My huge training dick quickly became fully erect.

"I love both of you. I swear to heaven this is the truth."

I spread my legs wide and continued,

"Anyone who wants to maintain our current relationship even after leaving the dungeon, come lick my balls. Otherwise, go back and sit at the table."

"Ikan!"

"Hah! Unbelievable!"

They both seem incredulous.

I quietly count down.

"5. 4... If you say you won't do it, our relationship is over."

"What are you doing?"

"Sis, he's really..."

The two start glancing at each other.

"3. 2... Should I only acknowledge the first person who does it?"

"No."

"Hey."

"1. Time's-"

As soon as the countdown ended, Zoe and Lucy moved quickly, almost simultaneously.

The two knelt in front of me, each taking one of my balls, and started licking.

Lick. Lick.

"That's right. I acknowledge you both."

I gently stroked their heads.

Afterwards, I fucked them both all night long.