Wynonna Knows (A Second Part to the One That Was By Fall Out Boy)

"Y/n." Wynonna said and you looked up. She slowly walked towards you, a sinister smirk on her face. "I haven't really gotten a chance to hang out with you." 

"I mean, I didn't think you wanted to." You said and she moved a bit closer to you. "Is something up?" 

"I mean, I don't know, you tell me." Wynonna said and you glanced at the ground. "Look, fess up and things will be a lot less bad for you." 

"What'd I do?" You asked and Wynonna moved her hand onto your collar bone, pushing you into the wall. 

"You really think you can pull one over on two of the nicest, most honest people in my life?" Wynonna asked, her hands going towards your throat. She didn't squeeze, but you were absolutely terrified of her. "They are good people, just like I thought you were, but I guess I was wrong." 

"I don't understand." You said and Wynonna's grip got a bit tighter. If you weren't in fear for your life, this probably would have been super hot. 

"You. Cheating. With. Nicole. And. Waverly." Wynonna said, pushing you a bit harder against the wall with each word. You made a whimpering sound and Wynonna let you go. "God, why the hell did I think you were trustworthy?" 

"Because I am." You said rubbing your neck. There were tears beginning to form in your eyes and you heard Waverly and Nicole's voices in the hallways. 

"Hey, Wynonna what are you doing?" Waverly asked and Wynonna pushing Nicole. "Whoa, calm down." 

"Hey." Nicole said and Wynonna glared at her. "What's this about?" 

"You guys all cheating on each other." Wynonna said and you looked down. Nobody moved and Wynonna watched you all curiously. "Did you guys know or something?" 

"Yeah, I mean, it's a polygamous relationship." Waverly said and Wynonna looked down, looking guilty. "What happened before we got in here?" 

"I might have gotten a bit upset and choked your girlfriend." Wynonna said and you took a drink from Nicole's coffee cup. "I'm sorry Y/n and I'm really happy for you guys." 

"No problem." You said and Nicole hugged you, kissing your temple. 

"No more choking people and apparently no more secrets." Waverly said and Wynonna moved to hug you, adding to the weight put on your body. Waverly piled on top and you just let it go.