Olivia and Karl looked at each other, and then at me. “Agreed,” they said simultaneously.
“Awesome,” I replied. “I have a plan that I think is going to make all of us happy. Karl, were you serious about maybe wanting to do me?”
“Um, yeah,” he said, and then turned back to Olivia. “That’s okay, right, babe?”
“Of course,” Olivia said. “I’ve actually been kind of fantasizing about watching that. I want to see you in a different role.”
“Okay, so, Olivia, it sounded like you weren’t really wanting to do this, like doing it was unfaithful to Karl somehow. What if I could minimize what we did and give Karl a larger role?”
“That would be great, but I still think it’s going to need to be you who impregnates me,” she said.
“This child will definitely originate with me, but I have a neat idea. Can we start with everyone taking off their clothes?” I asked.
Olivia and Karl and removed their sleep clothes while I shucked off my bathing suit.