Kill her

"I was going to do what you asked for in the fifth wish." Rose told Ash.

"She wouldn't have agreed to that much, and even you know that." Ash replied.

"You just needed to ask who she really is. I need to ask how much she knows, who told her, who else has she told, and what does she knows about Anna. I was more in need of those answers since I risked my identity by acting sus." Rose complained.

"Now, what is done is done, and now it can not be undone. Just let our questions be buried down to our graves with us. Wait, so you are telling me Hazy is someone else and Anna is someone else too and you and I are already someone else, we both know. Now, the next thing we will know is that Mushy is not one of us." Ash exhaled, frustrated.

"I hate it too." Rose admitted.

"I, I well... I despise it." Ash remarked.

"So, you didn't know about it. You only knew about Hazy? the least sus?" Rose asked.

"Well, yeah." Ash said.

"You are more sus." Rose commented.

"Rose, the teacher is looking straight at us." Ash whispered, making Rose turn towards the whiteboard. The teacher was looking at them in the hope of getting no answer so she could throw them out of the class for not focusing and talking and disturbing the class's already boring atmosphere. She was quite successful.

"It's all your fault." Ash said to Rose as they proudly walked out of the class with their heads held high, especially smiling at Anna and Hazy. They knew that under some other circumstances, those two would have made them regret this by reminding them about this regularly until it is permanently engraved in their memory.

"No, it isn't. Wasn't it you acting all sus, going around knowing that the least sus person has another identity." Rose argued back.

" Was it me giving desperate explanations?" Ash asked sarcastically.

"Bro, leave it. What is done is done, and now it can not be undone." Rose replied with a wink.

They both sat at the chairs outside the class. As soon as the class was dismissed and the teacher was coming out, they both kicked their own chairs far away and stood up straight but tired like they were standing all this time. The chairs went sliding into a wall, causing a crash, which in turn grabbed the teacher's attention.

"You guys should not have even dared to pretend to stand. Such nuisance." The teacher said. As soon as he left, all four of the girls burst out laughing.

.........

"Ann, why haven't you yet finished her." Sebastian asked.

"I will dad, I will. Let me confirm my suspicion. What is she is not the witness, and we murder her in vainly?" Anna asked.

"Ann, she is suspicious. I agree, if she didn't see Mary then she must know something else." Sebastian suggested," Either way, she needs to die."

"She acts like this every year around this time, according to my observations. It might be a family tragedy." Anna suggested.

"But what if it's not. What if she remembers every year that what you did exactly 5 years ago?" Sebastian asked.

"I don't know, dad.I don't know. I am sorry." Anna said.

"No, you are not. Otherwise, Roseline wouldn't have been alive." Sebastian said.

"Dad! okay. Help me. Help me kill her then."