Different Sex Story 2

bySarahlovesto69©

Brooke hadn't stopped feeling guilty about what she did with those frat guys at the party a few weeks ago. She did her best to make it up to her boyfriend with extra blowjobs, cooking his favorite meals, and making an effort to nag him less. Of course she didn't plan on bringing it up to him and figured one drunk mistake in years of a great relationship was no reason to derail the whole thing.

She was finally starting to get past it as she was fumbling with her keys to get in the front door one day after her nightly yoga class.

"Hey there - Brooke, isn't it?" Nick said, just happening to walk up to his front door himself.

"Uhh yea? Aren't you the maintenance guy?" Brooke replied with a rude tone, confused why this loser was talking to her.

"Yea, my names Nick. I've been dealing with Jenny on a few maintenance things and since you're right here I was hoping you could come over for a few minutes so I could show you a few things" he replied.

"Well sorry, I don't think Jenny is home so you'll just have to wait for her - thanks!" Brooke tried getting out of dealing with Nick and began to rush inside.

"Hold on just a minute!" Nick quickly said, catching her before she was all the way in. "I have a package addressed to you that was delivered to me by accident - if you don't want it I guess I can just toss it.."

Brooke had a bit of an online shopping problem and often forgot what she ordered and when it was coming. Ugh. She was looking forward to just going inside, stripping off her leggings and sports bra and taking a long, hot bath. With a sigh she replied "Fine. I'll grab it really quick".

Nick opened his front door with a smile, gesturing for her to enter and couldn't help but notice her nipples protruding slightly through the neon green sports bra.

"If you'll just follow me upstairs.." Nick said, moving quickly up the steps and into his office before she could change her mind.

As Brooke entered the room behind him she saw what looked like porn on a few monitors.

"Ew you pervert! It's one thing to be so lonely you have to watch porn like this but you really think a gangbang is hot!? Just give me my package so I can get out of here, I feel dirty just standing here!" Brooke said with disgust, half laughing at how sad this guy was.

"Hmmm why don't you take a closer look at this little slut in action and let me know what you think". Nick hit play and the three frat guys sprang into action, within no time you could clearly see and hear that Brooke was the girl right in the middle of three dicks.

Brook gasped with horror "OH MY GOD! WHAT IS THIS? WHERE DID YOU GET IT?!" She shrieked, watching the cocks piston in and out of her simultaneously on the screen.

"Let's just say I was fortunate that it fell into my hands, and let's also say that if you behave I won't have to show this to anyone like hmmm... your boyfriend, Joe? Your roommates? Family? The whole university??" Nick replied with a sly grin on his face.

Brooke grew quiet pondering what to do. She was stuck and didn't know how to get out of this. Nick knew Joe's name so he probably would know how to get it to him. He could obviously get it to her roommates easily - would they even be friends with her after finding out she cheated like this? She broke the silence "Fine! What do you want from me you pervert!"

"I'm glad we could agree to cooperate with each other. Let's start with you stripping out of those sweaty clothes and giving me a blowjob. Then, I'll explain to you what I really need from you" Nick replied, hardly able to contain his excitement.

Brooke went back into competitive mode and she was going to do what she needed to protect her image and keep him quiet - but she was going to make sure he knew she didn't like it. With a scowl on her face she quickly peeled the second skin of her sports bra off her chest and up over her head to reveal her small but firm B cup tits. She quickly proceeded to strip off her leggings and panties together, leaving her shaved pussy and pear shaped ass bare to the room as well.

Nick had already fished out his 8 inch cock and was sitting on the couch admiring Brooke's tight, tan body - she still had tan lines from what appeared to be a very small bikini. Brooke walked over to him and knelt down in front of him. She looked up at Nick, making eye contact, and shot him the meanest, nastiest glare she could. With a scowl on her face she reached out and grabbed his cock, pointed it to her face, and began to suck and lick the head while jerking the shaft. While she hated the idea of blowing this creep, at least it would be over soon and she could forget all about it.

Nick couldn't believe how good her little kisses and licks felt on his cock head. All of a sudden she deep throated as much of his cock as she could take and began to play with his balls. He could feel the tip of his cock pushing at the back of her throat.

Brooke thought her best bet was just to get this over with as fast as possible, so she dove right in trying to get him off. She knew she gave great head and was proud of it - might as well put it to use.

"Eager little cocksucker, huh?" Nick said, trying to maintain his focus. "So while you're working down there, there's something else I need to ask you to do" Brooke shot another angry look and eye roll his way with his cock still in her throat thinking "Great, what else could you possibly want?"

"So I now have video of you fucking 3 random guys like a huge slut, and now I have you sucking my dick too, seeing as how this whole room is recorded with cameras aaaaand now I have these few photos" he continued as he snapped a few pictures with his phone.

"What that means is you will do what I want, when I want OR you can kiss your relationship goodbye as well as your reputation with anyone you know" Brooke was so mad he had her like this, which transitioned into her sucking even harder and increasing her speed slobbering up and down his shaft.

Through baited breath due to Brooke's doubled efforts he continued "I need you to get some blackmail on your friend Wendy for me... something good enough that will give me this sort of leverage on her. She was a bitch to me when you guys first moved in and I don't drop grudge easy. If you get me that video or photos I will erase all copies I have of you" he lied.

Brooke listened as she continued to deepthroat his cock. She would bring her lips all the way up to the tip of his dick and then drop her mouth back down on his shaft until it was almost all the way down her throat and she was gagging. She played and pulled on his balls gently while doing this and could tell he was getting close, so she sped up as much as she could - her head almost becoming a blur moving up and down his shaft.

Nick's head rolled back as he couldn't hold his cum any longer and his hands automatically went to the back of Brooke's head holding her down on his spasming cock.

Before the other night Brooke didn't normally swallow (except again on birthdays or special occasions). She couldn't help but frown and furrow her eyebrows, eyes watering as pump after pump of hot thick jizz was shot into her mouth, filling her to the brim and forcing her to gulp down the hot cum in order to breathe.

*GULP* "You fucking bastard" she breathed heavily, now on her hands and knees trying to catch her breath. Nick admired this doggy style view of her athletic body as she breathed in heavily to regain her senses.

As much as she hated Nick for doing this to her, she had to admit that Wendy did always rub her the wrong way a bit. It stemmed from when they first met and her and Joe had just started dating. Brooke came outside at a party and caught Wendy and Joe making out with Wendy rubbing his cock through his jeans. Everyone got over it and they became friends again afterwards, but a small part of that always stuck with Brooke - and now she had a chance at revenge.

"OK you sick fuck. You got your blowjob. Yes I'll help with Wendy but when I'm done, that video is gone and we are done!" She said, wiping any excess cum from her lips and then onto the carpet.

"That's great to here!" Nick said, watching her get dressed back into her tight gym clothes. "By the way - you have until the end of next weekend. If you don't have it done by then we're going to have you personally meet the hobos that hang out at the gas station a few blocks down the road".

Brooke rolled her eyes and walked downstairs and out the door, already formulating the plan in her head on how she would trick Wendy into doing something she wouldn't already do...

----------------------

"BROTHERS WEEKEND!!" Wendy yelled, excited at the idea Brooke had proposed to her.

Both of their little brothers were friends at high school and had just had their 18th birthdays - what better way to celebrate than with your older sisters at college? The plan was set: they would come up Friday night and have a low key night but then Saturday the girls would throw another great party at their place.

Friday night rolled around and both high school guys were excited. Rob was Wendy's brother and Steve was Brooke's. They both were determined to hook up with some hot college girls this weekend now that they were men at 18. The girls had a few friends over that night to play a couple drinking games and the high schoolers eyes were glued to every rack and pair of short shorts that came through the door. As some of their cheerleader friends lightly teased the brothers, Wendy couldn't help but notice how big both of their brothers cocks were with their hard ons straining through their jeans. "I wonder if I can convince Brooke to hook up with Rob somehow..." Wendy thought, her mind drifting.

Friday night ended up being uneventful but Saturday came and the party started early. Everyone wanted to play beer pong as usual so the girls decided to play brothers vs. sisters for some fun. It came down to just a few cups left and without thinking, Wendy turned around to distract Steve on his shot by bending over and shaking her ass. Steve missed and Rob yelled at her:

"Hey! Come on! I don't need to see that!" Although he had to admit, his sister had a great ass.

"Sorry!" Yelled Wendy, embarrassed with her face turning red for once.

It was time for the final part of Brooke's plan to come into play now that everyone was getting pretty drunk. She told Wendy that one of the guys at the party that she had a crush on for a while was finally down to hook up with her - but he had one condition. She would need to not talk and she would need to be blindfolded. He would meet her up in her room in 30 minutes.

"Oooh kinky, but I like it!" Wendy said with a smile. Her smile quickly faded "Ugh but what about Rob!?" She asked feeling like she was missing her shot.

"I'll take care of your brother for you, don't worry! Just come back down when you're done!" Brooke said cheerfully, shooting Wendy a big smile.

"You're the best! I'm gonna go get my blindfold ready!" Said Wendy with a giggle, heading upstairs and wondering if her thought of Rob and Brooke hooking up might actually happen.

Now for Rob's part..

"Hey your sister had to run up the street to talk to a friend who is REALLY drunk and wanted to see her for some reason. She should be back in a bit but in the meantime... what if I told you I had a friend here who is super hot and into younger guys..." Brooke asked Rob.

Grinning and slightly embarrassed at the forward question Rob replied "I would say that I'm interested... what's the catch?"

"The catch is, you have to be blindfolded and NOT talk! If you can promise to do that, she'll meet you upstairs and will be ready to go. Don't worry, I'll lead you to the right room" Brooke said, giddy with excitement at her evil plan coming together.

With a little hesitation but also with more confidence than usual thanks to the alcohol Rob replied "Yea, why not? Sounds like fun... when do we do this?"

"Actually, right now would work! I just happen to have this blindfold here.." Brooke said, pulling a black sleep mask out of her back pocket and handing it to Rob. "Come on, let's go upstairs and see if she's ready!"

Brooke told another one of her friends that Rob was going to be sick so she was going upstairs to help him and asked them to watch after Steve. Once upstairs, Brooke had Rob undress to his boxers and put on the blindfold. Brooke couldn't help but notice that Robs dick was already hard and looked pretty big too! She opened the door just a bit to see Wendy completely naked except for her blindfold, legs open and idly playing with her pussy and B cup tits.

"Pssst it's Brooke - I'm sending him in!" She whispered to Wendy. She came back out into the hall and grabbed Rob by the hand, "OK are you ready? Remember, no talking!"

Brooke led Rob into the room and shut the door. She led Rob over to the bed where his sister lay naked and got out her own phone to start getting what she needed.

Rob slowly crawled across the bed until he found Wendy's slim, tight body. He immediately began squeezing her firm tits as he slowly positioned himself over top of her and between her legs. As Wendy began to unknowingly kiss her brother, she reached down and felt his impressive cock through his boxers and began rubbing it with her hand as a moan escaped her lips.

Rob reached down and began to finger Wendy's pussy while still squeezing her tit with the other, all the while continuing their hot and heavy make out session. He loved petite women and was excited that this mystery friend seemed to be exactly his type. Wendy was able to work Robs boxers all the way off and began to jack his bare cock, aching for it to fill her up.

She guided Rob by his cock to come up and straddle her head so he could fuck her mouth. Rob gladly followed her lead and before long his hefty balls were slapping against her chin with his fingers laced through her hair for control. Wendy grabbed the back of his ass cheeks for support and did her best to open her throat for who she thought to be her crush. Rob moaned at her enthusiasm and ability to take his thick cock completely down her throat.

Her brother reached back to play with her slit while she continued sucking his cock but when he realized this college slut was soaking wet from giving him head, he had to fuck her right then. He maneuvered Wendy's body into a doggy style position and could not believe how great her full ass felt in his hands. He was surprised when she reached back between her legs to grab his cock and guided it to her wet opening.

Wendy couldn't help but to moan as Rob sunk all 6 inches of his thick cock into her pink, wet pussy from behind. He grabbed her hips hard and pounded away for all he was worth right from the get go. He was fucking his sister so hard that even her small tits were shaking back and forth in this doggy style position, although only Brooke and her camera could see this given the participants blindfolds.

Brooke tried to quietly move around and capture as much of this as she could. She had plenty of different angles and lighting so that anyone that knew these two could easily tell it was Rob fucking his own sister. As much as the thought disgusted her, Brooke had never watched live sex like this before and the smells, sounds, and sight was starting to turn her on. She could feel her nipples start to harden and her own pussy became moist.

She reached down into her own pants and began to play with her clit, holding in a moan as she continued to watch and film these two.

After a while of ball smacking, loud flesh on flesh doggy style fucking Wendy stopped her brother and pushed him onto his back before climbing up on top of his cock and sinking down onto the whole length. It wasn't long before she was slumped back over his chest with her tits rubbing his chest while they made out. Rob grabbed her perfect ass cheeks and spread them for some leverage before starting to hammer his cock back up into her, eliciting a long slow moan from Wendy.

It wasn't long before both brother and sister were moaning heavily and obviously cumming soon. Brooke pulled her wet fingers out of her own pants to make sure she got the climax on camera. She circled around the two, making sure to show Rob spreading his own sisters ass cheeks and showing her tight little asshole just above her pussy getting destroyed by his cock. As she came back to the side of them they were both so close to orgasm but not quite making it.

Tired of the suspense of waiting for what felt like forever and feeling super horny herself, Brooke took matters into her own hands. She took her middle finger out of her soaking wet pussy and in between Wendy's moans of pleasure of "almost there" Brooke pressed it up against Wendy's puckered asshole. She entered with almost no resistance and jammed her whole middle finger in which pushed Wendy over the edge into orgasm immediately. Wendy's pussy clenching around Rob's cock sent him over the edge, causing him to shoot his load up into his sisters pussy, sending rope after rope of hot white cum up into her.

After both orgasms subsided Wendy fell off to the side of Rob on the bed, out of breath still and leaking cum from her pussy. Brook grabbed Rob by the arm and whispered in his ear "It's me, Brooke. We have to get you out of here before your sister gets suspicious! This is our little secret, OK?" Rob nodded and they left the room, thinking that maybe the "mystery girl" he just fucked was Brooke!

Brooke brought him to her room (where else?) and pulled off his blindfold, suddenly realizing he was naked and how good his cock looked now that she was all wound up. NO! She could not cheat again! She was not a slut!

"Um... here's your clothes you dropped in the hall earlier.. guess you'll have to go commando the rest of the night" Brooke said to Rob with an awkward laugh and walked out of her room to re-join the party.

Rob came down a few minutes later, ready to continue celebrating his birthday and his newfound college girl success. Wendy came down a half hour later looking happier than ever. She was in such good spirits after landing her crush she grabbed another beer, put her arm around her brother and gave him a big kiss on the cheek, "I'm glad you're here to celebrate! This is a great weekend!" Rob grinned and toasted with his beer "Me too! Cheers!"

"So, how was it?" Brooke said, slyly.

"AMAZING!" Wendy said, a beaming smile on her face.

Brooke could only smile back as she waited for the texts of the video and photos she took to go through to Nick as requested. She would need to follow up with him to be sure he got rid of the dirt on her.