why is dumbledore bad

One reason is that fans like to explore different perspectives. In the original books, Dumbledore is presented as a wise and mostly benevolent figure. But some fans want to see what would happen if he had a darker side. It adds a new layer of complexity to the story.

One reason is that J.K. Rowling herself revealed that Dumbledore was gay. This opened the door for fans to explore this aspect of his character more deeply in fanfiction. It allows fans to fill in the gaps in the story that the original books didn't fully explore regarding his love life.

Well, some people write these fanfictions because they feel that Dumbledore in the original books had some morally grey areas. His actions, like withholding information from Harry, can be seen as manipulative. So, fans create stories where Harry gets fed up with this and decides to part ways.

One example could be those where Dumbledore is portrayed as having hidden motives that are not in the best interest of Harry or Hogwarts. In some fanfictions, he might be shown as being overly manipulative in his actions towards Harry, like using him as a pawn in a bigger game against Voldemort without fully considering Harry's well - being. However, it's important to note that these are just creative interpretations in the world of fanfiction and not the official view of the character from the original books.

Some fanfictions portray Dumbledore negatively because he made many controversial decisions in the original series. For example, his handling of Harry Potter's situation was sometimes seen as using Harry as a pawn in the fight against Voldemort. He kept many secrets from Harry that could have potentially changed the course of events and put Harry in more danger. Also, his relationship with Grindelwald in his youth and the events surrounding it add to the reasons why some writers in fanfics might choose to show him in a negative light.

Well, in some fanfictions, Dumbledore might want to punish Hermione if she goes against the school rules in a way that he thinks is particularly serious. For example, if she delves too deep into dangerous magic without proper authorization.

In some fanfics, Harry might hate Dumbledore because he feels Dumbledore has been using him all along as a tool to defeat Voldemort. Dumbledore has been making decisions for Harry without fully considering Harry's feelings and desires. For example, he didn't tell Harry about the prophecy until it was almost too late, and Harry might see this as a form of manipulation.

The tragedy of their relationship also draws people in. Snape's love for Lily and his loyalty to Dumbledore despite his difficult past make for great fodder for fanfiction. Writers can explore how their relationship might have developed differently or how they truly felt about each other behind the scenes of the main story.

Well, in some fanfictions, Dumbledore is bashed because writers want to explore alternative storylines. They might believe that Dumbledore was too controlling. He made a lot of decisions for Harry without really consulting him. So by bashing him, they can create scenarios where other characters step up or Harry has a different kind of growth without Dumbledore's influence.

Maybe in the fanfic, Harry has his own ideas and beliefs that conflict with Dumbledore's. He might think Dumbledore's plans are too risky or not in line with his own sense of justice.