Carmen's opera and novelCarmen's opera was different from his novel in many aspects.
** 1. Plot **
1. ** Narrated perspective and story rhythm **
- In the novel, most of the main stories were told by Don Hauser while he was waiting for the execution order for Carmen's murder in his cell. The events were spread over a long period of time.
- The plot of the opera had a major change in the rhythm of the plot. It directly unfolded the story and did not use this method of recollection.
2. ** Character relationships and plot details **
- In the novel, Carmen had a husband named Garcia, who was killed by Don Hauser in an argument. In the novel, Escamilo was a bullfighter named Lucas. He only had a short passion for Carmen, and Michaela did not appear in the novel.
- In the opera, he arranged for Don Hauser's fiancée, Michaela. Every time she begged for marriage from Don Hauser's mother, the filial Don Hauser could not refuse. Don Hauser had no interest in Carmen, but he was passionate about guarding Carmen, who was arrested for committing a crime. He was still obsessed with Carmen after he was imprisoned for letting Carmen go. Although Carmen loved Don Hauser, he was dissatisfied with his mediocrity. After a fight with his superior over Carmen, Don Hauser gave up his military post. After the appearance of the bullfighter Escamilo, Carmen eventually fell into his arms as the situation developed, and Carmen went to the arena to cheer for the bullfighter despite the death of the card prophecy.
** 2. Character Creation **
1. ** Carmen image **
- In the novel, Carmen was described as a dissolute, immoral, and evil woman. She seduced Don José on the way to prison, causing him to become a deserter, thief, bandit, smuggler, and even a murderer. He also frequently hooked up with other men.
- In the opera, although Carmen had a fierce personality and a loose concept of love, her image was rendered by music and other artistic forms, showing more of a Romani girl who yearned for freedom and was loyal to her principles, which could also arouse the sympathy of the audience.
2. ** The image of Don Hauser **
- In the novel, Don Hauser's entanglement with Carmen was more of an image of being lured into depravity by Carmen.
- In the opera, Don Hauser had his own contradictions and struggles. He had a stable military position and his fiancée, Michaela. The development of his feelings for Carmen had more complicated plots, such as his filial piety and his jealousy with his superior, which enriched his image.
** Third, audience acceptance **
1. ** First performance reaction **
- As a literary work, the novel was accepted by readers because of its unique description of love tragedy, local characteristics, exotic atmosphere, and subversion of traditional love concepts.
- At the premiere of the opera, the audience was disgusted by the smoking actress on stage, Carmen's dissolute concept of love, and the final killing. Although some musicians gave positive comments, the criticism of the music critics affected Bizet's physical and mental health.
<a href="/?from=ask_words" style="color:red" target="_blank">Read more exciting novels for free</a>
Carmen's Concept of LoveCarmen's view of love showed a state of pursuit of freedom. Freedom was in the first place in his view of love, absolutely above feelings. She was passionate and free to do whatever she wanted. She did not care about the secular world's views, nor did she care about religious and moral constraints. In her mind, morality could not restrict her feelings and livelihood.
She had an extreme desire for money, almost a desire for freedom. Therefore, in the world of love, money and love had always been competing with each other. For the sake of money, she could pretend to fall in love with someone she did not love, swindle money, and then quickly leave. However, when she had true love in her heart, she would bravely go through fire and water for love and would not give up easily.
Her love was simple and completely loyal to her heart. When she fell in love with someone, she could throw roses at them. When she didn't love them, she would never be reluctant to part with them. Some people thought that Carmen's free love was enviable, because in reality, many people would be affected by factors such as property, social status, and the eyes of the world, so they could not treat love purely. However, some people thought that her love was irresponsible and too selfish. Her view of love contained a strong possessiveness and extreme understanding of freedom, which was contrary to the view that love should last forever and help each other. At the same time, she also expressed that "love is as important to me as breathing", reflecting the importance of love in her life.
Carmen's Complete LyricLove is just an ordinary thing, not rare at all
A man is nothing but a thing to dispel evil. What's so great about it?
Love is just an ordinary thing, not rare at all
A man is nothing but a thing to dispel evil. What's so great about it?
L'amour l'amour l'amour l'amour
What is love? What is love? Isn't it because everyone is deceiving themselves?
What do you mean by infatuation? What do you mean by mystery? It's just a show between men and women
I like all men, rich or poor, high or low
If it's a man, I'll abandon you, not afraid that you'll have magic again
Love is just an ordinary thing, not rare at all
A man is nothing but a thing to dispel evil. What's so great about it?
Love is just an ordinary thing, not rare at all
A man is nothing but a thing to dispel evil. What's so great about it?
What is love? What is love? Isn't it because everyone is deceiving themselves?
What do you mean by infatuation? What do you mean by mystery? It's just a show between men and women
If you fall in love with me, you'll have to look for trouble
If I fall in love with you, you will die in my hands
What is love? What is love? Isn't it because everyone is deceiving themselves?
What do you mean by infatuation? What do you mean by mystery? It's just a show between men and women
If you fall in love with me, you'll have to look for trouble
If I fall in love with you, you will die in my hands
Who is Carmen in the 'Expulsion Carmen Secret Story'?Since we don't have much information about the 'Expulsion Carmen Secret Story', Carmen could be anyone. She might be a student if the expulsion is from a school, or a member if it's from an organization.
3 answers
2024-11-21 10:30
Is Carmen Winstead's story real?No, Carmen Winstead's story is not real. It's just an urban legend that has been circulating on the internet.
3 answers
2024-10-15 16:38
Carmen and Don José's relationshipCarmen was a gypsy tobacco worker, and Don José was the squad leader of the dragon cavalry. Carmen seduced Don José into falling in love. Out of jealousy, Don José killed the adjutant of the United Army and joined Carmen's gang of bandits. However, Carmen did not want to be bound by Don José and fell in love with the bullfighter Lucas. In the end, he was killed by Don José. In despair, Don José surrendered to the authorities and was sentenced to hanging. The relationship between them was a love relationship full of entanglements, jealousy, betrayal, and ended in tragedy.