In the manga, Inumaki has distinct abilities and a quiet nature. Yuta is depicted with significant strength and a sense of purpose. Both characters have their own arcs and development.
Maki in fanfiction usually has a fierce loyalty to her friends, especially Yuta. She is the type to fight for what she believes in. Yuta is sometimes portrayed as being a bit naive in the ways of the world outside his own small circle, but his pure heart makes him endearing. In many stories, their different personalities create an interesting dynamic, like in a story where Maki's boldness gets them into a risky situation and Yuta's calm thinking gets them out.
He would probably be quite amused by some of his past antics. For example, his constant pranks on Iruka-sensei. But at the same time, he'd also see the pain he carried from not having his parents and realize how that influenced his actions. He might react with a bit of regret for some of the stupid things he did out of loneliness, but also be glad that those experiences made him who he is today.