A common prank is changing the labels on her tea jars. So when she goes to make her usual tea, she ends up with a completely different flavor. It's a simple yet effective prank that can lead to some really funny reactions from Toriel.
Well, in this fanfiction, Leo could be pranked by having his clothes swapped while he's in the shower. So he comes out thinking he's going to put on his normal outfit but instead gets something completely outlandish. Another possibility is that his friends set up a fake lottery win and then tell him it was all a joke.
In certain 'dumbledore gets pranked fanfiction', a popular prank is to make Dumbledore's office furniture float and move around chaotically. Imagine him trying to sit at his desk and the chair keeps scooting away or the desk starts doing a little dance. Also, there could be a prank where his glasses show false images, like seeing a dragon in the hallway when there's actually just a cat.
Mario and Luigi are the most likely. They are always looking for ways to outwit Bowser, and pranking him would be a fun way to get back at him for all his evil deeds.
Fred and George Weasley are very likely candidates. They are known for their love of pranks and their mischievous nature. They might see pranking Dumbledore as the ultimate challenge.
His friends are the most likely ones. They know his habits and routines well enough to pull off some great pranks. For example, if Leo is always punctual, they could set his alarm clock wrong to make him late.
One interesting aspect in such fanfiction could be when someone pranks Toriel by making her think that her favorite recipe has been completely changed. They might switch out ingredients when she's not looking. Toriel then tries to cook with the new 'ingredients' and gets really confused, creating a humorous situation.
Sasuke is a likely target. He's so serious all the time, and Naruto would find it quite fun to break his stoic demeanor with a good prank. Another one would be Sakura. She can be a bit hot - headed, and Naruto's pranks on her could lead to some really comical reactions. And of course, Kakashi. He's always laid - back, but Naruto might want to test his limits with some crazy pranks.