Well, for one, it should capture the essence of Halloween. That means stories that are not only scary but also somehow related to the traditions and atmosphere of the holiday. It could have stories about trick - or - treating gone wrong, or the secrets that come out on Halloween night. The stories should also be accessible to a wide range of readers. So, not too overly complex in language, but still interesting for more advanced readers. And a good compilation might also include some stories that have a bit of humor mixed in with the horror, to give the reader a break from the scares.
One great Halloween short story is 'The Legend of Sleepy Hollow' by Washington Irving. It features the iconic Headless Horseman and is set in a spooky, autumnal village.
One good short Halloween story is about a little girl who goes trick - or - treating. She knocks on a spooky old house's door. An old woman answers and instead of giving candy, she tells the girl a tale of a ghost that haunts the neighborhood every Halloween. The girl is scared but also intrigued. As she leaves, she realizes it was all part of the Halloween spirit.
In my opinion, 'The Yellow Wallpaper' is quite scary. It's about a woman's psychological breakdown while being confined in a room with hideous wallpaper. The way her mind deteriorates is truly terrifying. Another is 'The Masque of the Red Death' by Poe. The description of the plague and the masked figure is bone - chilling. Also, 'The Small Assassin' by Ray Bradbury, where a baby might not be as innocent as it seems, is really spooky.
A group of friends decided to have a Halloween party in an abandoned barn. As they were setting up, they heard a creaking sound. They thought it was just the wind, but then they saw a shadow moving. Turns out it was just a stray dog looking for some food. They gave the dog some treats and the dog stayed with them for the party, making it a memorable and slightly spooky Halloween.
A simple one is about a haunted school on Halloween. The desks move by themselves and the chalk writes spooky messages on the board. But when the janitor shows up in the morning, everything is normal again. It's just the school having its own Halloween fun without scaring anyone too much.
The best short Halloween stories often have a spooky setting, like a dark forest or an old, creaky house. This immediately sets the mood for the story.
One spooky Halloween story is about a haunted house. There was an old, dilapidated mansion on the edge of town. Every Halloween night, strange noises could be heard from inside. A group of brave kids decided to enter one year. As they walked in, the doors slammed shut behind them. They saw shadowy figures moving in the dark. One of the kids felt a cold hand on their shoulder but when they turned around, there was nothing there. They ran out as fast as they could, and ever since, no one has dared to go near that house on Halloween.
Themes in classic Halloween short stories often include mystery. In stories such as 'The House on the Borderland', there are many unexplained phenomena. Madness is also a theme, as seen in 'The Yellow Wallpaper' where the main character goes mad. And the theme of the uncanny is present in many of these stories. For instance, in 'Carmilla', the relationship between the two women has an uncanny, otherworldly feel to it.