Well, the 'Sally the Doll' story often goes like this. Sally was once a normal doll, but then strange things started to happen. At night, people would hear giggling coming from her. One night, a little girl who owned Sally woke up to find the doll's eyes glowing red. It was really terrifying.
The Sally Doll is often part of a spooky story. Sally was once a normal doll in an old, abandoned house. Legend has it that at night, her eyes would glow red and she would move on her own. People who entered the house claimed to hear strange giggling sounds coming from the room where Sally was. One night, a curious kid went into the house and took Sally with him. That night, he had nightmares of Sally coming to life and chasing him around his room. Ever since then, the Sally Doll has been known as a cursed object.
For me, the scariest parts are the nightmares she causes. The thought of being chased by a living doll in your dreams is truly terrifying. Also, the mystery around her origin, that she was made by a witch and has dark magic in her, makes it all the more spine - chilling.
Well, it's the unknown that makes the Sally Doll so terrifying. We don't know what's making it move or whisper. It could be some sort of evil spirit or a dark magic. Also, dolls are supposed to be innocent playthings, but when it starts to act in a way that defies that, like coming to life at night, it completely violates our sense of normalcy. And the nightmares that people have after encountering the Sally Doll add to the overall sense of terror.
In these kinds of stories, Sally is usually the main character. She is the one who experiences all the scary events. She could be a curious adventurer who stumbles upon the unknown and has to face her fears. For example, she could be a local in a town full of haunted legends who decides to check out an old, supposedly cursed place. And that's where all the horror begins for her.
Unnatural features can make a doll scary. Such as long, sharp fingernails on the doll's hands, or a strange mark on its body. The way the doll is dressed can also contribute. A tattered, old - fashioned dress that is stained can be quite disturbing. And if the doll has a smell, like a musty or rotting smell, it makes the story even more frightening. The interaction between the doll and the characters in the story, like the doll causing harm to them, either physically or mentally, is another factor that makes a doll scary in a doll scary story.
I'm not sure specifically which 'Scary Sally Story' you mean. There could be many fictional stories with that name. It might be about a girl named Sally who has some spooky experiences, like she could be in a haunted house and encounters strange noises or apparitions.
It depends. If she is a malevolent ghost who haunts people and causes harm, then she would be scary. For example, if she makes things fly around or gives people nightmares, that's quite frightening.