'Batman: No Man's Land' is often considered among the worst. The story arc was overly long and complex, making it hard for some readers to follow. There were also some characterizations that didn't seem to fit well with the established Batman lore, like some of the extreme changes in the behavior of Gotham's citizens.
One of the worst is 'Batman: The Dark Knight Strikes Again'. It had a convoluted plot that deviated too much from the essence of Batman. Another is 'All - Star Batman and Robin'. The overly dark and violent tone was more for shock value than good storytelling. And 'Batman: Knightfall' also had problems. Bane breaking Batman's back seemed like a cheap plot device at times.
Sure. For example, 'Batman: The Killing Joke'. While it has its fans, some consider it one of the worst due to its treatment of Barbara Gordon. Her paralysis was used more as a plot device to drive the men in the story, Batman and the Joker. Another is 'Batman: Knightfall'. The story dragged on for too long, and the replacement of Batman by Azrael didn't work well for many. Azrael's violent and un - Batman - like behavior made the story less appealing.
Sure. 'Batman: The Dark Knight Strikes Again', 'All - Star Batman and Robin', 'Batman: Knightfall', 'Batman: Damned', 'Batman: One Bad Day - Two - Face', 'Batman: Son of the Demon', 'Batman: No Man's Land', 'Batman: The Killing Joke', 'Batman: Gotham by Gaslight' and 'Batman: Emperor Joker' are often considered among the worst.
One of the worst might be 'All - Star Batman and Robin, the Boy Wonder'. It was criticized for its over - the - top and sometimes out - of - character portrayals. Another could be 'Batman: The Dark Knight Strikes Again' which had a convoluted plot that many fans didn't enjoy. Also, 'Batman: Damned' had some elements that just didn't sit well with the traditional Batman lore.
The best could include 'The Dark Knight Returns' for its gritty take on an older Batman. 'Batman: Year One' is also great as it shows his origin well. 'The Killing Joke' is a classic for exploring the Joker's relationship with Batman. As for the worst, some might consider certain out - of - character stories in the later years of some runs. However, this is highly subjective as different fans have different tastes.
Well, in my opinion, 'Jeff the Killer' is among the worst. The whole white - faced, no - eyelids, and 'go to sleep' thing has been done to death and isn't really that scary anymore. 'Slenderman' started off interesting but then became more of a meme than a truly terrifying creepypasta. Also, 'Ticci - Toby' is really bad. It tries too hard to be edgy with the whole mental illness and serial killer thing but just comes off as cringy.
One of the top ten Batman stories is 'The Dark Knight Returns'. It shows an older Batman coming out of retirement in a dystopian Gotham. Another great one is 'Batman: Year One' which details his early days as a vigilante. 'The Killing Joke' is also among them, with its exploration of the Joker's origin and his complex relationship with Batman.
The best Batman stories usually have strong character development. For instance, in 'The Dark Knight Returns', we see Batman's struggle with age and his place in a changing world. In contrast, the worst stories often lack this depth. They might have convoluted plots that don't serve the character well. Also, the best ones tend to have a clear vision of Gotham, like in 'Batman: Year One'. The worst may distort the city's atmosphere.
One of the worst could be 'One More Day'. It had a very controversial plot where Peter Parker made a deal with Mephisto to save Aunt May, which erased his marriage to Mary Jane. Another bad one might be 'Civil War II' with its forced conflict and some out - of - character moments for heroes. And then there's 'Secret Wars (2015)', which was overly convoluted and didn't quite live up to the hype in terms of storytelling.