There's also a fanfic titled 'Substituted Hermione'. In this one, the replacement of Hermione is more of an experiment gone wrong. It shows how the Hogwarts dynamic gets completely disrupted. The new girl has a secret agenda which unfolds as the story progresses, making it an interesting read.
Some authors write 'Hermione gets replaced' fanfics to explore alternative storylines. They might be curious about how the story would unfold without Hermione's unique skills and personality.
No, it is not ethical. Writing about rape in fanfiction is a very disturbing and inappropriate topic. It can be extremely triggering for survivors of sexual assault and it goes against basic moral values of respect and human dignity.
They are popular because it shows Hermione in a vulnerable state. Usually, she's so strong and in control, but when she's sick, it's a new side of her.
In a 'hermione gets all the books fanfic', it might be about Hermione's thirst for knowledge being fully satisfied. She could be using all these books to research new spells, study the history of magic more comprehensively, or even find ways to improve Hogwarts. Since she's so studious, having all the books would be like a dream come true for her.
The negative impacts are numerous. It can cause emotional distress to a large number of people, including those who care about the character Hermione. It can also contribute to a culture that normalizes sexual violence in some way. Since fanfic often has a wide readership, this type of content can spread harmful ideas and desensitize people to the seriousness of rape.
She might discover long - lost magic. Since she has all the books, there could be some rare and forgotten spells or magical theories that she stumbles upon.
One possible reason could be a misunderstanding over a spell or a magical object. Maybe Hermione thought Harry was using a dangerous or unethical spell, and they got into an argument that turned into a fight. Another reason might be related to their different approaches to solving a problem at Hogwarts. For example, Harry might be more impulsive while Hermione wants to follow the rules strictly.
There's a fanfic titled 'When Hermione Falls Ill'. In this story, it focuses on Hermione's internal struggle while being sick. She's not used to being incapacitated and it delves into her thoughts and how she copes. It's really interesting as it gives a deep look into her character even when she's not at her best. For example, she tries to continue her studies while sick but her body just won't allow it.
One great 'Hermione gets hurt' fanfic is 'Bruised but Not Broken'. It shows Hermione getting injured during a battle at Hogwarts. The author does a wonderful job of portraying her pain and the concern of her friends. Another is 'Injured in the Line of Magic' which focuses on how Hermione's injury affects her studies and relationships. It's a really interesting take on the concept.