The exploration of Carolyn's powers, if she has any in the fanfiction, is also a popular theme. Writers might delve into how she discovers them, how she learns to control them, and how they affect her life. It adds an element of mystery and intrigue to the story.
Another option is to check out some Dark Shadows fan communities on social media platforms like Reddit or Tumblr. Fans sometimes share their fanfictions or recommend good ones in those communities. You could make a post asking specifically for Carolyn fanfictions and see what others suggest.
Another theme is the battle between good and evil. In the 'Dark Shadows 1991' fanfiction, writers often create new scenarios where the characters have to face more intense battles between the forces of good and evil, adding more drama and action to the stories.
One great 'Dark Shadows' fanfiction is 'The Return of Barnabas'. It delves deeper into the character of Barnabas and his struggle with his vampiric nature in a new and interesting way. Another is 'Victoria's New Adventure' which takes the character of Victoria on a journey that was not explored in the original series. And 'The Darker Side of Collinwood' shows a different perspective of the famous Collinwood estate, filled with mystery and intrigue.
I would recommend 'Darkness Unleashed in Supernatural's World'. This fanfiction delves deep into the darker aspects of both universes. It creates a unique story where the entities from Dark Shadows start to infiltrate the Supernatural world. The writing style is quite descriptive, making it easy to visualize the events.
Some common themes could be the supernatural elements that were so prominent in the original Dark Shadows. It might also explore the complex relationships between the characters, like the love - hate dynamics. Another theme could be the struggle between good and evil in the shadowy world of the story.
One idea could be exploring a different ending for the story. Maybe the main characters find a new way to defeat the evil forces that was not shown in the original. Another could be a time - travel based fanfiction where a character goes back in time to change certain events that led to the current situation in Dark Shadows 2.
You can start by looking on fanfiction websites like Archive of Our Own (AO3). It has a large collection of 'Dark Shadows' fanfiction sorted by different tags and ratings. Another option is FanFiction.net. There are also some dedicated 'Dark Shadows' fan forums where fans share their own written stories.
A good 'Supernatural Dark Shadows' fanfiction should have a strong plot. For example, it could be about how the characters from both shows team up to fight a common enemy. This creates a lot of potential for action and drama.
First, re - watch or re - read Dark Shadows 2 to get a fresh feel for the story, characters, and the overall atmosphere. Then, pick a starting point. It could be right after a big event in the story or even before the story begins if you want to write a prequel.