One idea could be the reader being a new student at the DWMA. They could struggle to find their weapon partner at first, but then end up with an unexpected and powerful weapon. Another plot could involve the reader having a special ability that draws the attention of the Kishin's minions, leading to various battles and the need for protection from the main Soul Eater characters.
First, think about the unique traits that would make your character stand out in the Soul Eater universe. For example, they could have a special type of soul wavelength that gives them an edge in battles. Also, consider their backstory. Maybe they come from a family of outcasts in the world of meisters and weapons, which shapes their personality. Give them flaws too, like being overly impulsive or having a fear of the dark that they have to overcome during their adventures in the DWMA.
Some great Soul Eater x Male Reader fanfictions can be found on platforms like Archive of Our Own. Look for ones that focus on character development and unique plotlines. For example, there are fanfictions that explore the male reader's journey as a new student at the DWMA, facing challenges and making friends along the way.
A great aspect of Soul Eater Evans x Reader fanfiction is how it allows for unique character interpretations. Writers can explore different sides of Soul Eater Evans' personality in relation to the reader - insert character. For example, they might focus on his growth as a character while in a relationship. It also gives readers a chance to be part of the Soul Eater universe in a more personal way.
Another theme is redemption. Some fanfics explore the idea of whether the Kishin can be redeemed or not, and the reader is often involved in this process. It's about exploring the good and bad sides of such a complex and usually villainous character. There are also themes of friendship and betrayal. The reader might form an unexpected friendship with the Kishin or be betrayed by it, adding a lot of drama to the story. This is because the relationship between a human - like reader and the Kishin is full of potential for different kinds of emotional and plot - driven interactions.
Another type of Soul Eater reader fanfiction involves the reader being from a different dimension. They get pulled into the Soul Eater world and have to adapt. This can lead to really cool crossovers in the story, like bringing in elements from the reader's home dimension and seeing how they clash or blend with the Soul Eater universe.
Another plot could be that the reader is an outsider to the world of Soul Eater, perhaps from a different dimension. Soul accidentally discovers the reader and at first is suspicious. But as he gets to know the reader, he realizes that they are kind - hearted. They then have to deal with the challenges of the reader adapting to the Soul Eater world while also falling for each other.
First, you need to know the Soul Eater universe well. Read the manga or watch the anime to understand the characters, the setting like Death City, and the rules about souls and weapons. Then, create your male reader character. Decide on his personality, abilities, and backstory. For example, is he a brave fighter or a more reserved strategist? After that, think of a plot that can involve your male reader interacting with the existing Soul Eater characters in an interesting way.
One great 'Soul Eater x Male Reader' fanfiction is 'A New Beginning in Death City'. It has an interesting plot where the male reader character arrives in Death City with a unique weapon ability. The story does a good job of integrating the reader's character into the Soul Eater world, making it feel like a natural part of the existing lore.
Character interaction. A good fanfiction in this category should have engaging interactions between the male reader and the Soul Eater characters. It could be humorous exchanges with Death the Kid about his symmetry obsession or deep conversations with Maka about the nature of souls.