Some might write it to explore the complex relationship between Snape and James. Since they were rivals at school, it gives a chance to delve deeper into their enmity. Maybe the writer wants to show a different side of Snape, not just as a victim of James' bullying but also as someone who could fight back and cause harm.
One good 'Snape Hurts James' fanfiction could be 'The Rivalry's Dark Turn'. In it, Snape uses a powerful spell on James during a duel that leaves James in a weakened state for a while. Another might be 'Snape's Revenge', where Snape gets the upper hand over James in a Quidditch - related incident. And there's also 'Unexpected Confrontation' which shows a more emotional side of Snape hurting James through some harsh words that really cut deep.
Yes, there are some. You can start by looking on fanfiction platforms like Archive of Our Own. Just search for 'Snape hurts Hermione' in the search bar and you'll likely find a variety of stories. However, keep in mind that the nature of this concept can be a bit dark, so be prepared for some intense and perhaps disturbing content.
A frequent theme is the power of forgiveness. In these fanfictions, Lily might have to decide whether to forgive James for his actions that have caused her pain. Also, the theme of self - discovery can be present. Through their relationship, both James and Lily could be on a journey of understanding themselves better. For example, James might realize his flaws and try to change for Lily, and Lily might discover new aspects of her own personality as she deals with James.
One common theme is betrayal. Sirius might do something that goes against James's trust, like revealing a secret or making a decision that impacts James negatively without his consent.
A great fanfiction is 'Cursed Bonds'. Here, Snape's curses on James are not just simple spells but are tied to a deeper, more mystical bond between them. The story unfolds with a series of adventures as they both try to break or understand this bond that the curses have created.
In most cases, it's not ethical. Torture is a cruel act. However, in the context of fanfiction, some might argue it depends on the overall narrative and the 'rules' set within that fictional universe. If it's part of a revenge plot where Snape has been deeply wronged by James in the past, it could be seen as a morally gray area. But generally, torture is not a positive or ethical behavior.
Snape's view of James might not change much at first. He has such deep - seated hatred for James due to their past. But if the fanfiction shows James in a more positive or sympathetic light, he may start to question his long - held beliefs about him, just a little bit.