One common theme is physical injury and recovery. Since Arthur is often in dangerous situations in the game, fanfiction might explore how he deals with severe wounds, like a bad gunshot or a deep stab wound. Another theme is emotional pain from broken relationships. Maybe he has a falling - out with a fellow gang member or someone he cares about deeply. And the theme of self - blame also shows up a lot, where Arthur blames himself for things that go wrong in his life.
You could also check out some dedicated fanfiction websites other than AO3. For example, FanFiction.net. While the quality and quantity might be different compared to AO3, there are still some gems. Look for tags related to Arthur Morgan and 'hurt'. But keep in mind that you might need to sift through a lot of content to find exactly what you're looking for.
One idea could be that Arthur Morgan somehow gets transported to the RWBY universe. He could use his skills as a gunslinger and survivalist to help the RWBY characters in their battles against Grimm. Maybe he teams up with Ruby and teaches her some of his unique combat techniques.
There are fanfictions that center around Arthur's relationships within the gang. They might delve into his deep bond with Hosea, showing their conversations and how Hosea influenced Arthur. Another aspect could be his relationship with the women in the gang, like Mary, and how that evolved in different fan - created scenarios.
Well, it offers a new take on a well - known character. Instead of the traditional male Arthur, a female Arthur brings different dynamics. For example, in a male - dominated world like the one in the game, a female Arthur would face different challenges and prejudices.
Fanfiction.net could also be a great source. It has a large collection of fanfictions. You might need to sift through a bit more compared to AO3 as the tagging system isn't as refined. But if you search for 'Criminal Minds' and then look for stories specifically about Morgan getting hurt within the search results, you can find some interesting ones.
One great 'Arthur Morgan and Sadie Adler fanfiction' is 'The Journey Together'. It shows them going on a mission that wasn't in the original game and really develops their relationship in a new way. Another good one is 'Surviving the Frontier' which focuses on how they rely on each other to survive in the harsh wild west setting.
Some dedicated Red Dead Redemption fan communities or forums might also have links to or even host their own young Arthur Morgan fanfiction. For example, the official Red Dead Redemption subreddit might have some posts or threads where fans share their fanfiction works or recommend some good ones.
Another one is 'Arthur's Youthful Adventures'. This story takes a more light - hearted approach and tells about Arthur's adventures as a young lad. It might include things like his first horse ride, his early friendships in the gang, and how he started to develop his skills as a gunslinger and an outdoorsman.
Well, of course, Arthur Morgan himself is the central character since it's about being reborn as him. But often, other characters from the original game like Dutch, Hosea, and John Marston also play important roles. They interact with the reborn Arthur in different ways, sometimes being skeptical of the changes in him, other times being inspired by his new ideas.