One type could be paranormal events like ghosts. Maybe a family witnessed a ghostly figure in their old attic. It was a transparent shape that would float around and sometimes make objects move.
One of the creepy true stories could be about a haunted house. People living there reported seeing apparitions at night. They would hear strange noises like footsteps and whispers when no one else was around. It was so terrifying that they eventually had to move out.
One creepy element is the unknown. In many true creepy stories, there's something that can't be explained, like the disappearing hitchhiker. You don't know where she came from or where she went. It gives a sense of mystery and fear.
Another story involves a child who remembered being a soldier in a past life. He would have nightmares about the battles he was in, and he could describe the uniforms and weapons of that era. He even had a strange fear of certain sounds that were similar to the sounds of gunfire in his 'past life'. These details made it seem like he really had been reincarnated from a war - torn past.
One of the creepy reincarnation stories is about a child who could recall detailed events from a past life as a soldier in a war. He knew things like the location of hidden bunkers and the names of his comrades. It was so strange as he was just a little kid with no prior knowledge of military history or that specific war. Another story involves a woman who remembered living as a servant in a big mansion in the 1800s. She could describe the layout of the house and the cruel treatment she received from the owners, which sent shivers down people's spines. There's also a case of a man who claimed to be the reincarnation of a famous artist and could paint in the same unique style without any formal training.
One creepy story could be about a haunted house. People hear strange noises at night, like footsteps and whispers. Another might be a story of a cursed object that brings misfortune to whoever possesses it. There could also be a tale of a phantom hitchhiker who disappears from cars. And a story of a doll that seems to move on its own can be really creepy. Lastly, a story about a forest with an evil presence where people get lost and never return.
One of the really creepy true stories is the Dyatlov Pass incident. A group of hikers in the Ural Mountains died mysteriously. Their tents were cut open from the inside, and some had strange injuries. It's still a mystery today.
One true creepy story is about an old, abandoned house. People in the neighborhood said that at night, strange lights would flicker in the attic. A group of teenagers once dared to go inside. As they climbed the creaky stairs to the attic, they heard a low moaning sound. They got so scared that they ran out immediately and never went back.
It's hard to say for sure. A lot of the stories on Creepy Catalog are presented as if they're true, but often they incorporate elements of imagination and creativity to make them more thrilling. It depends on the specific story and the source it comes from.
One of the top creepy ghost stories is the story of the Bell Witch. It was a malevolent spirit that tormented the Bell family in Tennessee. It would pull hair, slap people, and make strange noises. Another is the Winchester Mystery House. Sarah Winchester kept building onto her house in a strange way to confuse the ghosts she believed were after her. And the story of the Brown Lady of Raynham Hall. A photograph seems to show a ghostly figure on the stairs of this old hall.