One scary nice guy story could be about a guy who always seemed overly friendly. He would constantly offer to help a female neighbor with tasks around her house. At first, it seemed nice, but then he started showing up unannounced. He would get really pushy when she said she didn't need help. It made her feel very uncomfortable and unsafe in her own home.
One scary nice girl story could be about a girl who always seemed very sweet and helpful in the neighborhood. But one day, people noticed that wherever she went, strange things started to happen. For example, the lights would flicker in houses she passed by. It turned out she had an otherworldly connection that she wasn't fully aware of, and her presence was disturbing the spiritual balance in the area.
One nice scary story is about a haunted house. There was an old mansion on the outskirts of town. People said that at midnight, you could see a figure in white floating through the halls. A young couple once decided to explore it. As they entered, the doors slammed shut behind them. They heard strange whispers and cold breezes swept through. They quickly found their way out, but they swore they saw a pair of red eyes watching them from an upstairs window.
One common element is the sudden shift from seeming nice to being controlling. For example, the guy who offers help at first but then gets angry when the help isn't accepted. Another is the hidden motives. They might seem friendly on the surface but actually have ulterior motives like trying to get a relationship or power over someone. And often, there's a sense of entitlement. They think that because they are 'nice', the other person owes them something, which is really scary.
One common element is the sudden change. They start off seeming really friendly and helpful, like the perfect nice person. Then, when things don't go their way, they turn mean or possessive.
One interesting story is of a nice girl who lived near a cemetery. She often left flowers there for the forgotten graves. One day, she saw a figure in white among the tombstones. Instead of running away, she approached it. It was an old woman who told her stories of the past. The spooky encounter turned into a heart - warming exchange as the girl learned about the history of the town.
Nice scary stories often tap into our primal fears. They might deal with things like the fear of the dark or the unknown. We are drawn to them because they allow us to experience these fears in a safe way. Like when we read about a haunted place, we can feel the shivers but know we're not actually in danger. Also, the way they are told, with vivid descriptions of spooky settings and eerie characters, makes them really interesting.
One scary nice guy story could be about a man who always seemed overly helpful. He would offer to drive his female neighbor to work every day. At first, it seemed nice, but then he started getting angry when she declined. He would leave passive - aggressive notes and once even showed up at her work uninvited, making her feel very uncomfortable.
A nice girl in school was very friendly to everyone. One day, she found a strange old mirror in the attic of her house. When she looked into it, she saw a different version of herself that was a bit spooky. She tried to ignore it at first, but then things started to change around her. Her toys would move on their own, and she heard her name being called when no one was there. Eventually, she learned that the mirror was a portal to a different dimension, and she had to find a way to close it to stop the scary things from happening.
You could also consider a horror - themed movie collection on DVD. Movies like 'The Sixth Sense' or 'Psycho' are well - known and might be something your mom would enjoy, especially if she likes a bit of a scare while watching a story unfold.