In many fanfictions, Sirius disciplining Harry shows a complex relationship. Sirius, being Harry's godfather, has a sense of responsibility. He might discipline Harry out of love and a desire to protect him. For example, he could be strict about Harry using magic irresponsibly as it might draw unwanted attention. This discipline is a way to guide Harry in the wizarding world, where there are many hidden dangers.
Often, Snape will single out Harry in front of the whole class. He might publicly criticize Harry's work or attitude. For example, when Harry is assigned a group project in Potions, Snape might give Harry extra tasks or set higher standards just for him. And during exams, Snape could be extra strict when grading Harry's papers.
Another reason is that it can add a bit of drama and tension to their relationship. It's not a typical scenario for them, so it makes for an engaging read as readers get to see how they handle this new situation. There could be moments of conflict, understanding, and ultimately, a strengthening of their bond.
One popular 'Harry disciplines Hermione' fanfic might be 'A Lesson in Magic'. In this fanfic, Harry has to discipline Hermione when she breaks a crucial school rule regarding dangerous spell experimentation. It shows their friendship evolving in a different way as Harry takes on a more authoritative role.
One reason could be Harry's impulsiveness. Harry often jumps into dangerous situations without thinking, and Sirius, being his godfather and having a protective nature, would shout at him to make him realize the risks. For instance, if Harry decides to go after a Death Eater alone.
Yes, there might be such fanfictions out there. Fanfiction writers often come up with creative and sometimes out - of - the - box ideas. They might explore the idea of Harry having a different relationship to Sirius in an alternate universe where he could be seen as Sirius's daughter. However, it's not a common or traditional take on the Harry Potter universe.
The 'Harry Potter' books are set in a magical world full of its own stories, prophecies, and secrets. Sirius is a complex character with a lot on his plate. He has to deal with his family history, his time in Azkaban, and his loyalty to his friends. Fanfiction is a form of creative writing by fans outside the original story. Sirius doesn't have the time or the inclination within the context of the story to be reading fanfiction. His life is too filled with real magical drama and danger.
Sirius could help Harry cope by sharing his own experiences of being an outcast in his family. He could tell Harry that just because his parents did this horrible thing, it doesn't mean he's unlovable. Sirius could also introduce Harry to his friends in the wizarding world, like Remus, who could also offer support and friendship.
It's possible that in the cave, they start to see each other as equals rather than just a mentor - student relationship. They might argue about the best way to deal with the cave's mysteries at first, but through that process, they learn to value each other's perspectives. Also, if one of them gets injured in the cave, the care and concern shown by the other would enhance their relationship.