It could be Zeref. Since Zeref has an interest in powerful magic users and Natsu is a strong dragon slayer, Zeref might kidnap Natsu to study his magic or use him in some dark plan related to his quest for immortality or power.
Natsu was walking through the forest one day when suddenly a group of dark mages emerged from the shadows. They quickly overpowered him with some sort of magic -binding spell. They dragged him away to an old, creepy lair. His friends back at the guild soon realized he was missing and set out on a search mission. Happy flew around frantically looking for any sign of his friend. Lucy, Gray and Erza teamed up and followed some leads they found in the forest. They were determined to rescue Natsu no matter what it took.
Gray would be extremely angry. He would immediately start looking for clues as to where Natsu was taken. His ice - make magic would be on full display as he might freeze things in frustration while trying to figure out the situation.
One possible plot could be that the kidnappers are from a rival guild who want to use Natsu as leverage against Fairy Tail. Gray could then embark on a solo mission to rescue Natsu, facing various traps and enemies along the way. He might have to use his ice - make magic in creative ways to overcome obstacles.
Well, perhaps Zeref kidnaps Natsu because he sees Natsu as a key to some grand plan. Maybe he wants to use Natsu's power for his own dark purposes. For example, Zeref might think Natsu's unique magic can help him break some sort of ancient curse or gain access to a powerful magic source.
One idea could be that Natsu is kidnapped by a dark guild who wants to use his dragon slayer magic for their own evil purposes. They might try to force him to reveal the secrets of his magic or use him as a weapon against Fairy Tail.
A common plotline is the rescue mission. His friends from Fairy Tail band together to find and save him. Another is Natsu trying to break free on his own. He might use his fire magic in creative ways to escape his bonds.
Maybe some unexpected allies could emerge. For instance, other dark mages who oppose Zeref's actions for their own reasons. They might see Natsu as a valuable asset or simply dislike Zeref's overbearing ways. Another potential ally could be a powerful spirit that Natsu has befriended in the past. Spirits often have unique powers that could be useful in the fight against Zeref.
One possible motive could be to gain power. Natsu is a Dragon Slayer, and his magic is very powerful. The kidnappers might want to extract his magic or use him as a weapon. Another motive could be for revenge. Maybe Natsu has unknowingly wronged someone in the past, and they are out for vengeance. Or perhaps they are working for a greater evil, and Natsu is seen as a threat to their plans, so they want to get rid of him by kidnapping him.
One possible fanfiction could be 'The Abduction of Natsu' where a dark wizard kidnaps Natsu to use his power. Another might be 'Natsu's Captivity' which focuses on how his friends try to rescue him. There could also be a story like 'Kidnapped: Natsu's Ordeal' that delves into Natsu's own struggle while being held captive.