The 'Caleb Williams fingernail story' remains a mystery without more context. It could potentially be a story within a particular community or family. For example, Caleb Williams might have used his fingernail to mark something important during a journey or adventure, and that simple act could have led to a series of events that became a story. It could also be related to a talent or quirk he had with his fingernail, like being able to use it to play a unique musical instrument or perform a special trick.
If Caleb Williams is a sportsman, key events in his life story could include winning a major championship. That would be a huge milestone. Or perhaps an injury that he had to overcome, which made him stronger both physically and mentally. He could also have been part of a significant team - building experience that taught him valuable lessons about cooperation and leadership.
Well, I'm not sure who exactly Caleb Williams is as the name is quite common. He could be an ordinary person living a normal life, going to school, having a job, and a family. Maybe he grew up in a small town and has dreams of traveling the world one day.
Maybe Toby could be a potential love interest. They have a lot in common in the PLL world and could develop a deeper connection on a different level in a gay storyline.
A common theme might be the re - imagining of Caleb's character arc. In the original PLL, his relationships are mainly heterosexual. In gay fanfic, it could be about how his relationships with male characters develop over time. It could also include themes of friendship turned into something more, and how that impacts the overall PLL storylines that are re - written or expanded upon in the fanfic.
As of now, I'm not aware of any particularly famous 'Marshall Williams' gay stories. It could be that this is a relatively unknown or emerging area of work. However, the world of gay literature is vast and constantly evolving, so new works may gain popularity over time.
Perhaps Caleb is in a situation where he has to hide his relationship with another male due to the environment in PLL. He is constantly torn between his love and the fear of being discovered. The 'cums' could be related to a moment of passion that is both a celebration of their love and a dangerous act given the secrecy. Their relationship then becomes a journey of self - discovery and fighting for acceptance.
Sorry, I'm not that familiar with specific PLL Caleb gay fanfic. You could try searching on fanfic websites like Archive of Our Own. They usually have a wide range of fanfictions, and you can filter by tags related to 'PLL' and 'Caleb' and 'gay' to find what you're looking for.
Self - discovery is likely a theme. As a gay individual, Caleb Gallo might go through a process of understanding himself better, his identity, and what he wants in life. Another theme could be acceptance, both self - acceptance and acceptance from society or his family.