Somewhat. They attract a niche audience. Those who like stories about strong female characters facing hardships are drawn to them. For example, fans of character - driven dramas might find the concept of an alpha girl dealing with death interesting as it shows a different side of a usually confident character.
The writing style can also be a factor. If the writing is too flowery or lacks authenticity, an alpha girl might not be interested. For instance, if a Wattpad story uses overly dramatic language to describe simple situations instead of presenting a realistic view, it may not appeal to her.
One example could be 'The Fall of the Alpha Girl' where the main alpha girl character is facing a terminal illness. In this story, her journey through dealing with her impending death while trying to hold on to her status and relationships is explored.
One common theme is the power dynamic. Since alphas are usually seen as more powerful and omegas as more submissive in this trope, the fanfiction often explores how the alpha girl and omega boy navigate this difference. For instance, they might have to overcome the expectations of their society regarding their roles.
An 'alpha girl' is often seen as a strong - willed female. If she'rejected' 'dying wattpad stories', it could be that she has certain standards. Wattpad has a vast number of stories, and some might be losing traction, getting fewer reads or comments. This alpha girl perhaps didn't like these stories that were on their way out, maybe because they lacked quality, an interesting plot, or proper writing style.
One popular one is 'Fifty Shades of Grey'. The male lead, Christian Grey, can be seen as an alpha male. He is dominant and in control, while Anastasia Steele is the 'good girl' who enters into a complex relationship with him.
Jealousy could be a reason. Maybe the person telling the alpha stories feels threatened by you in some way and uses this method to undermine you in front of the girl. They want to show themselves as superior to make you look bad.
One common theme is acceptance. The alpha male often has to learn to see beyond society's standards of beauty and accept the plus size girl for who she is. Another theme is mutual growth. For example, the plus size girl might gain more confidence from being with the alpha male, and the alpha male might become more empathetic.
The good girl is usually initially intimidated by the alpha male's strong personality. But as they interact more, she discovers his softer side. This is common in contemporary romance novels. For instance, the alpha male might show his vulnerability when dealing with his past traumas, which makes the good girl feel closer to him.