The Sonic comic could be bad because of weak art, or a story that doesn't make sense and doesn't capture the essence of the Sonic universe. Also, maybe the dialogue is clunky and uninteresting.
Maybe it has poor art, a confusing plot, or doesn't stay true to the Sonic characters.
One reason could be a lack of understanding of the original Sonic characters. For example, if the author makes Sonic act completely out of character, like being overly mean or cowardly when he's typically brave and heroic in the official games and lore. Another factor might be a really convoluted and uninteresting plot. Instead of an exciting adventure like in the Sonic games, the fanfic might have a plot that's hard to follow and lacks any real action or purpose. Also, poor writing quality such as a lot of grammar and spelling mistakes can make a Sonic fanfic bad.
The Sonic Archie comic could be seen as bad for various reasons. Sometimes the character development wasn't up to par, or the plotlines became too convoluted and hard to follow. Also, changes in the creative team might have affected the quality.
It could be that the Sonic Archie comic didn't live up to fans' hopes. Maybe the writing wasn't engaging enough, or there were too many changes from the original Sonic concept that people loved.
Maybe it has poor drawing quality or a confusing plot. That could make it bad.
Well, it could be due to inconsistent plotlines or a departure from the original character traits of Tails. Also, poor illustration quality might contribute to it.
Well, sometimes the art style might not match people's expectations or the colors could be off. That can make a cover seem bad.
The Sonic comic is timeless because of its engaging characters and evergreen storylines that appeal to fans of all ages.
Poorly drawn characters or a confusing plot could make a Sonic comic cringe-worthy.
The edginess of Comic Sonic could come from its unique design or the way it's presented in the comics.