It's quite exciting and captures the essence of the Star Trek universe well.
The 'New Earth' series had its detractors. The plotlines in some of the books in this series were seen as rather convoluted. For example, some of the characterizations didn't seem to stay true to the original Star Trek characters. It was like they were trying to do too much with the new setting and lost sight of what made Star Trek great in the first place.
Well, it's really subjective. But some fans might consider 'Spock's World' by Diane Duane as one of the worst. The plot can be a bit convoluted and the characterizations not as strong as in other Trek novels. It kind of strays too far from what makes Star Trek great in terms of its core values and the way the characters interact.
I think 'Vulcan's Glory' could be considered one of the worst. The story just doesn't seem to flow well and the characters don't have the same charm as they do in the TV shows or better - written novels. It lacks the sense of wonder and discovery that is typical of Star Trek.
In my opinion, 'Dyson Sphere' is also a contender for the worst Star Trek novels. The science in it was a bit iffy. It didn't really hold up to what we know about the Star Trek universe's science. And the story was just not that interesting. It lacked the excitement and the thought - provoking elements that good Star Trek novels usually have.
Well, opinions on the 'worst' can vary greatly among fans. One that often gets criticized is 'The Final Reflection' by John M. Ford. Some fans didn't like its complex and convoluted plot that deviated too much from the typical Star Trek feel. It introduced a lot of new concepts and species in a rather clumsy way, making it hard for some to follow.
I think 'Vulcan's Forge' is one of the worst. It had some really cheesy dialogue that didn't seem to fit the Star Trek style. The plot also had some holes in it. For example, some of the character's actions didn't seem to have proper motivation, which made the whole story feel a bit disjointed.
Good Star Trek novels are those that can make you feel like you're part of the crew. 'The Entropy Effect' by Vonda N. McIntyre does this well. It has a great mystery and the characters are well - rounded. In contrast, 'Prime Directive' by Judith and Garfield Reeves - Stevens is often considered bad. It takes the concept of the Prime Directive and twists it in a way that makes it seem more like a plot device than a fundamental part of the Star Trek philosophy.
In my opinion, 'The Eugenics Wars: The Rise and Fall of Khan Noonien Singh' is among the best. It gives a detailed backstory to one of the most iconic villains in Star Trek. It's full of intrigue and adventure. On the other hand, 'Strangers from the Sky' has been criticized as being one of the less - appealing novels. The pacing is slow and the story doesn't seem to add much to the overall Star Trek lore.
Well, Star Trek has indeed been turned into comics. Different publishers have released different comic series featuring the characters and stories from the Star Trek franchise. Some are standalone stories, while others tie in with the TV shows or movies.
Yes, Star Trek has been adapted into comic book form. There are various comic series based on the Star Trek universe.